Peer Reviewer Qualifications and Application Form ACHENA Achena

Instructions and help about Peer Reviewer Qualifications And Application Form ACHENA Achena

In peer review there are two roles: the author, who submits a paper for review, and the reviewer, who reads the paper and provides comments. This video focuses on the reviewer role. Students often ask: "how can I be a better peer reviewer?" And the answer lies in a constructive review process. In A Short Course in Writing, Kenneth Bruffee says "In peer criticism, students learn to write helpful criticism of each other's work". He says that four terms in this sentence are critical to peer review: learn, write, helpful, and each other's." In this spirit, we offer strategies for peer review comments. Our first strategy is to ask questions as an interested reader. Questions capture reader response and keep the conversation going between author and reviewer. If you don't understand something, ask the author! Authors want to know what you're thinking! Once you get the hang of it, you can think of all kinds of questions. Another commenting strategy is to focus on global aspects before local a