What evidence should I include?

Include the original appraisal, labeled comparables (date and source), photos, permits, contractor invoices, and any corrections to factual data. Clear labeling and dates help reviewers match evidence to disputed items.

Can I submit electronically?

Yes. Electronic submissions are enforceable when they meet ESIGN/UETA requirements (intent, consent, attribution, retention). For consumer-facing filings also follow the ESIGN consumer-disclosure rules in 15 U.S.C. §7001(c).

Is notarization required?

Notarization depends on jurisdiction and the receiving party’s rules. Some local record or tax processes require notarized declarations or signatures; verify requirements with the recipient or local agency.

Who reviews the dispute?

Reviews are performed by the original appraiser, an assigned reviewer, appraisal management company quality control, or a municipal assessment appeals board, depending on the context and contract terms.

What if the reviewer refuses to change the report?

If unsatisfied, check escalation procedures, request a written explanation, and consider an independent appraisal, formal appeal to the assessor’s board, or legal counsel for further options.

How do I ensure acceptance of my submission?

Provide complete, labeled evidence, match report identifiers exactly, sign the form, and follow the recipient’s submission protocol (portal, email, or certified mail) to avoid intake rejection.

Electronic Signature
Templates
Miscellaneous
Appraisal Dispute Resolution

Appraisal Dispute Resolution

This template is fully customizable. Edit the text, fill out the fields, and send it for signature. Give it a try!

APPRAISAL DISPUTE RESOLUTION AGREEMENT

Client Name: Appraiser / Firm Name: Property Address Subject to Appraisal:

This Appraisal Dispute Resolution Agreement (the Agreement) is entered into effective as of by and between the Client and the Appraiser identified above.

WHEREAS

WHEREAS, the Appraiser prepared an appraisal report dated (Report) concerning the Property identified above; and

WHEREAS, the Client disputes certain findings, opinions, or conclusions set forth in the Report and the parties desire to establish an agreed procedure to resolve such disputes without litigation.

WHEREAS, the parties intend that any resolution reached pursuant to this Agreement be final and binding as provided below.

SCOPE OF REVIEW

Scope of Work:

DISPUTE RESOLUTION PROCEDURE

1. Submission: The Client shall submit a written dispute statement identifying the specific items in the Report contested and the factual or methodological basis for each dispute. The written dispute statement must be delivered to the Appraiser within days of the Client's receipt of the Report.

2. Initial Response: The Appraiser shall acknowledge receipt and provide a written response within days. The response shall identify whether the Appraiser proposes a factual correction, an analytical revision, or stands by the original Report.

3. Independent Review Option: If the dispute is not resolved by the foregoing exchange within days from submission, the parties shall submit the contested elements to an independent reviewer selected by mutual agreement. If the parties cannot agree on a reviewer within days, either party may request appointment by a recognized professional appraisal organization or proceed to binding arbitration if elected below.

4. Remedies: The independent reviewer may recommend a correction, a supplemental appraisal, or confirm the original Report. The parties agree that the independent reviewer's findings shall be final and binding if the parties have elected binding review in writing prior to the submission.

Dispute Resolution Method (select all that apply):

Independent peer review / reappraisal
Binding arbitration of contested issues
Mediation prior to arbitration

PAYMENT TERMS

The parties agree that fees and costs for dispute resolution shall be allocated as follows.

Initial Review Fee Amount: Allocation of Additional Costs: Payment Schedule / Due Dates:

Late payments shall incur interest at a rate of per month (or the maximum lawful rate if lower) after a grace period of days from the invoice date. The delinquent party shall also be responsible for reasonable collection costs, including attorneys' fees.

TERM AND TERMINATION

This Agreement commences on the Start Date of and continues until the earlier of: (a) completion of the dispute resolution process and all associated deliverables, or (b) the End Date of .

Either party may terminate this Agreement for material breach if the breaching party fails to cure within days after written notice. Termination shall not relieve the terminating party of obligations that accrued prior to termination, including payment obligations.

CONFIDENTIALITY

All non-public information exchanged in connection with the dispute resolution (Confidential Information) shall be held in confidence by the receiving party and used solely for the purpose of resolving the dispute. Confidential Information does not include information that (a) is or becomes generally available to the public through no fault of the receiving party; (b) was rightfully in the receiving party's possession prior to disclosure; or (c) is required to be disclosed by law, provided the receiving party gives prompt written notice to the disclosing party to permit a protective order or other remedy.

Neither party shall disclose the final determination, independent reviewer's opinion, or settlement terms to third parties except as required by applicable law or as necessary to enforce this Agreement.

GOVERNING LAW

This Agreement shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the laws of the state whose jurisdiction is selected by the parties: . Choice of law shall not deprive any party of rights to seek provisional remedies in another jurisdiction where permitted by law.

ENTIRE AGREEMENT; AMENDMENT

This Agreement constitutes the entire agreement between the parties with respect to the subject matter hereof and supersedes all prior oral or written agreements, negotiations, and understandings. Any amendment or modification to this Agreement must be in writing and signed by both parties.

MISCELLANEOUS PROVISIONS

Severability: If any provision of this Agreement is held invalid or unenforceable, the remaining provisions shall remain in full force and effect. Remedies: The rights and remedies provided in this Agreement are cumulative and not exclusive.

Notices: All notices required or permitted under this Agreement shall be in writing and delivered to the addresses for the parties set forth below or to such other address as either party may designate by written notice.

Client Contact for Notices: Appraiser Contact for Notices:

Client Printed Name:

By:

Date:

Appraiser Printed Name:

By:

Date:

What an Appraisal Dispute Resolution Is and When it’s Used

An Appraisal Dispute Resolution is a formal written request to review, correct, or challenge a property appraisal report used in lending, tax assessment, insurance valuation, or litigation. The document identifies disputed items in the original appraisal, provides supporting evidence (comparables, photos, factual corrections), and asks the appraiser, lender, assessor, or review panel to reconsider the value or specific findings. It is most commonly used by borrowers, sellers, property owners, tax agents, and attorneys when material errors, omitted data, or misapplied methods materially affect the reported value.

Why Using a Structured Appraisal Dispute Resolution Helps

A clear dispute resolution form organizes factual corrections, documents chain of custody for evidence, and creates a record that supports timely reconsideration or administrative review. Using a standard form helps ensure the dispute is accepted, routed to the correct reviewer, and processed consistently across lenders, assessors, or appraisal management companies.

Who Typically Files an Appraisal Dispute Resolution

The following groups commonly prepare and file appraisal dispute requests.

Homeowners and borrowers seeking correction for valuation errors or missing comparables.
Mortgage lenders or loan servicers requesting reconsideration before ordering a new appraisal.
Real estate agents or brokers assembling market evidence to support a different value.
Local governments and taxpayers disputing assessment amounts for property tax purposes.

The correct filer varies by context — borrowers typically contest mortgage appraisals while property owners contest assessment valuations through local administrative procedures.

Representative Signers and Role Descriptions

Property Owner

A person or entity with legal ownership of the property. They provide authorization, supporting documents (deeds, recent improvements), and their contact information. Their signature attests to ownership facts and consent to release appraisal materials.

Authorized Representative

An agent, attorney, broker, or mortgage servicer with written authority to act. The representative should attach proof of authorization and include their firm contact details to ensure proper routing and verification.

Essential Sections of a Professional Appraisal Dispute Resolution

A complete dispute resolution form collects identifying details, a precise statement of disagreement, and substantiating evidence. Templates vary, but six structural elements are standard.

Case Identifiers

Property address, appraisal report number, appraisal date, lender or assessor file number, and the original appraiser’s name so the request can be matched to the correct record.

Declarant Information

Name, relationship to property, mailing address, phone number, email, and any authority documents for representatives (POA or engagement letter).

Disputed Items

Clear itemized list of errors or omissions (e.g., incorrect square footage, omitted comparable sales, factual mistakes) with cross-references to report page or line numbers.

Supporting Evidence

Attach comparables, MLS printouts, recent inspection photos, contractor invoices, building permits, or survey data that substantiate the correction request.

Requested Remedy

State the specific relief sought (reconsideration, corrected report, second appraisal, or administrative review) and any preferred timeframe.

Signature & Attestation

Signature block for the filer, date, printed name, and a checkbox or statement confirming truthfulness and authorization to file the dispute.

Step-by-Step: Completing and Submitting the Dispute

Follow this sequence to prepare a complete submission and reduce the chance of rejection.

01

Gather Documents: Collect appraisal, comparables, permits, photos, and ownership proof.
02

Complete Form: Fill every required field and number each disputed item.
03

Attach Evidence: Attach labeled files and verify legibility and dates.
04

Submit & Track: Send to the designated reviewer and retain a receipt or confirmation.

How to Configure an Online Review Workflow

Set up routing, reviewers, and notifications for efficient processing when using an eSubmission platform.

Field	Configuration
Primary Reviewer	Assign appraiser or assessor email; require acknowledgement.
Secondary Review	Escalate to appraisal management or quality control if not resolved in X days.
Attachments Required	Make evidence upload mandatory for submission to avoid incomplete filings.
Notifications	Enable email confirmations to filer and reviewers with timestamped receipts.

Typical Processing Path for an Appraisal Dispute

Understanding the typical review flow helps you anticipate responsibilities and timelines.

File Submission: Filer uploads the dispute form and attachments to the designated recipient.
Intake Review: Administrator confirms completeness and assigns to the correct reviewer or panel.
Appraiser Response: Original appraiser or reviewer examines evidence and returns findings.
Final Determination: Reviewer issues a decision or correction; notifications sent to all parties.

Distribution Channels and eSubmission Platforms

Choose a platform that supports secure uploads, evidence attachments, and an auditable trail for every action.

Email Submission: Simple but can lack structured evidence fields and reliable audit metadata.
Portal Upload: Preferred for high-volume workflows; supports required fields, attachments, and reviewer roles.
Secure eSignature: Use ESIGN/UETA-compliant platforms to capture signer intent and preserve a tamper-evident audit trail.

Platforms integrating with common tools (PDF, Word, Salesforce, NetSuite) streamline routing and preservation of the dispute record.

Required Data Elements and Security Considerations

Property ID: Parcel number or legal description

Appraisal ID: Appraisal report number

Filer Identity: Name and contact details

Attachments: List of evidence files

Authentication: Signer email, SMS or MFA details

Audit Trail: Timestamped action log and IP address

Common Pitfalls to Avoid

Submitting incomplete evidence or unlabeled attachments that cannot be matched to disputed items.
Using vague language like 'value is wrong' without citing report pages, comps, or factual corrections.
Mismatched names or authority documents when an agent files on behalf of an owner.
Missing or improperly formatted dates leading to routing errors or missed deadlines.

Consequences of Improper or Late Submissions

Rejection: Form may be rejected for incompleteness, causing delays

Waiver: Failure to timely contest can waive challenge rights under lender or assessment procedures

Fee Exposure: Some lenders or jurisdictions may charge administrative fees for excessive re-reviews

Record Risk: Unsigned or unauthenticated submissions may not be accepted as official evidence

Legal Risk: Incorrect filings can weaken later legal claims in tax or litigation contexts

Privacy: Improper handling of PII can trigger data-protection obligations and penalties

Typical Deadlines and Timing Expectations

Timelines vary by lender, appraisal management company, or municipal assessor. Observe all specified windows and confirm local procedures when available.

Initial Filing Window:

Often 10–30 days after appraisal delivery; check contract or lender policy

Acknowledgement:

Administrative intake confirmation typically within 2–5 business days

Reviewer Response:

Reviewers commonly respond within 10–30 business days

Escalation Period:

If unresolved, escalation to quality control or appeals may take an additional 15–45 days

Statutory Limits:

Tax assessment appeals follow strict local statutory deadlines — verify with the assessor's office

Key Milestones in the Dispute Lifecycle

A sequential view of the dispute process highlights when actions and responses typically occur.

01

Submission

Filer submits dispute and attachments; system records timestamp and receipt.

02

Intake Verification

Administrator confirms completeness and assigns to reviewer or requests missing items.

03

Review Analysis

Appraiser examines evidence, checks comparables, and documents findings.

04

Final Notice

Determination communicated to parties; corrected report issued if required.

Comparing Formal Appraisal Dispute to Informal Reconsideration

A simple comparison of structured dispute resolution versus informal inquiry helps determine which route fits your situation.

Criteria	Appraisal Dispute Resolution	Informal Reconsideration
Formality	formal written request	phone or email inquiry
Evidence Required	documented attachments	often anecdotal or preliminary
Audit Trail		often limited
Appeal Options	escalation available	limited escalation

eSignature Vendor Comparison for Appraisal Dispute Resolution Workflows

eSignature costs and capabilities affect how you collect authenticated dispute submissions; the table compares signNow with common alternatives.

	signNow	DocuSign	Adobe Sign	PandaDoc	HelloSign
Starting Price	$8/user/mo	$15/user/mo	$14/user/mo	$19/user/mo	$15/user/mo
Free Trial	7-day trial	Varies	Varies	Varies	Varies
Bulk Send	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Varies
Audit Trail	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
HIPAA Compliant	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No
Envelope Cap	No cap	100 envelopes/user/year	Varies	Varies	Varies

Real-World Examples of Appraisal Dispute Resolution Use

Two concise examples show how dispute submissions are used in practice and the kinds of outcomes they support.

Residential Mortgage Reconsideration

Borrower found measurement errors in the original report and submitted corrected floor plans and recent comps

Reviewer rechecked comps and adjusted comparable selection
The lender accepted the correction and ordered a revised appraisal that lowered borrower costs and preserved loan terms.

Property Tax Appeal

Owner disputed an assessor’s omission of a recent subdivision sale and attached MLS records and closing statements

The assessor’s office reviewed the comparables and methodology
The municipal appeal board adjusted the assessed value, reducing the tax bill for the current year and correcting future roll entries.

Frequently Asked Questions About Appraisal Dispute Resolution

Answers to common questions about form content, deadlines, evidence, and electronic submission.

Need help? Contact support

What evidence should I include?
Include the original appraisal, labeled comparables (date and source), photos, permits, contractor invoices, and any corrections to factual data. Clear labeling and dates help reviewers match evidence to disputed items.
Can I submit electronically?
Yes. Electronic submissions are enforceable when they meet ESIGN/UETA requirements (intent, consent, attribution, retention). For consumer-facing filings also follow the ESIGN consumer-disclosure rules in 15 U.S.C. §7001(c).
Is notarization required?
Notarization depends on jurisdiction and the receiving party’s rules. Some local record or tax processes require notarized declarations or signatures; verify requirements with the recipient or local agency.
Who reviews the dispute?
Reviews are performed by the original appraiser, an assigned reviewer, appraisal management company quality control, or a municipal assessment appeals board, depending on the context and contract terms.
What if the reviewer refuses to change the report?
If unsatisfied, check escalation procedures, request a written explanation, and consider an independent appraisal, formal appeal to the assessor’s board, or legal counsel for further options.
How do I ensure acceptance of my submission?
Provide complete, labeled evidence, match report identifiers exactly, sign the form, and follow the recipient’s submission protocol (portal, email, or certified mail) to avoid intake rejection.

be ready to get more

Join over 28 million airSlate SignNow users

Sign Now