Establishing secure connection…Loading editor…Preparing document…

Controverting a Claim Workers' Compensation Board

This template is fully customizable. Edit the text, fill out the fields, and send it for signature. Give it a try!

STATEMENT ON SPECIFIC ISSUES IN DISPUTE

State of New York

WORKERS' COMPENSATION BOARD

STATEMENT ON SPECIFIC ISSUES IN DISPUTE

for Controverted and Expedited Cases

THIS AGENCY EMPLOYS AND SERVES

PEOPLE WITH DISABILITIES WITHOUT

DISCRIMINATION

PLEASE ANSWER ALL QUESTIONS COMPLETELY. See reverse side for further explanation and instructions.

CLAIMANT

1. Has a claim for compensation (C-3) been filed or attached to this form?

2. Has a medical report giving prima facie medical evidence been filed or is it attached to this form? (See reverse of this form for a description of "prima facie medical evidence.")

Give physician's name and date of report which gives prima facie medical evidence:

3. Has this claim and/or disputed issues been discussed with the carrier/self-insured employer?

If no, explain why not:

4. The issues in dispute are the following: Provide only those issues in which you are prepared to provide evidence for the Board to consider.

5. The following witnesses will provide testimony on the disputed issues. Give name, purpose of testimony, and availability.

CARRIER/SELF-INSURED EMPLOYER

1. The status of the carriers/self-insured employers investigation relative to the issues in dispute is as follows:

2. If the investigation is on-going, explain why the investigation has not been completed and what further investigation is necessary.

3. Give the date when the investigation will be completed.

4. List the issues in dispute upon which you are prepared to provide evidence for the Board to consider.

5. List all witnesses who will provide testimony on the disputed issues. Give name, purpose of testimony, and availability.

6. Has the claim and/or disputed issues been discussed with claimant or claimant's counsel?

If no, explain why not:

PREPARED AND SUBMITTED BY

ON BEHALF OF

PH-16.2 (5-06)

www.wcb.state.ny.us

Enter text✕
Prepare your document for signing right on this page
  • 01 Edit the text and complete the fields
  • 02 Click Sign Now and on the next screen add recipients and signature fields in SignNow
  • 03 Start your free trial to sign and send your doc
Sign Now

What a Controversion to a Workers' Compensation Claim Is

A controversion is a formal employer or insurer response that disputes a worker's claim for benefits under a state workers' compensation system. It identifies the legal and factual grounds for denial or partial acceptance, explains which benefits are contested, and initiates an administrative review. The filing typically triggers a hearing or conference before the state board or its adjudicator and starts procedural deadlines for discovery, evidence submission, and appeals. Precise form names and filing channels vary by state; consult the relevant workers' compensation board rules before submitting.

Why Timely and Precise Controversion Matters

A correctly prepared controversion preserves legal defenses, sets the official scope of dispute, and avoids default findings. It ensures evidence is admitted in the administrative record and frames issues for adjudication under state workers' compensation law and applicable procedural rules.

Why Timely and Precise Controversion Matters

Who Typically Prepares and Reviews a Controversion

The document is normally prepared by employer claims staff, insurance adjusters, or defense counsel.

  • Employer claims administrators responsible for initial intake and recordkeeping during disputes, coordinating medical reviews, and submitting the formal controversion to the board.
  • Insurance adjusters or third-party administrators who evaluate compensability, authorize or deny benefits, and manage communication with providers and legal counsel.
  • Workers' compensation defense attorneys who draft legal grounds, prepare supporting affidavits, and represent the employer at hearings or settlement conferences.

Core Sections to Include in a Professional Controversion

A well-structured controversion combines administrative identifiers, a clear statement of contested benefits, factual and legal grounds, supporting evidence, and requested remedies or procedural actions.

Case Identifiers

Claimant and employer names, claim number, adjuster contact, jurisdiction and board office to ensure the filing is linked to the correct administrative record.

Benefits Contested

Specify which benefits are controverted — temporary total, temporary partial, permanent partial, medical-only, vocational — and the effective date ranges of the denial.

Grounds for Controversion

State the legal bases such as lack of causal connection, preexisting condition, failure to report injury timely, lack of compensable event, or noncovered condition.

Summary of Relevant Facts

Concise chronological summary of events, medical treatment, witness statements, and dates that directly support the employer or insurer position.

Exhibits and Evidence

List attached medical records, surveillance, employment records, incident reports, and expert reports; reference exhibit numbers used in hearings.

Relief Requested

Specify remedies sought such as denial, limitation of benefits, medical only classification, suspension pending further evaluation, or request for independent medical examination.

Essential Fields Required on the Filing

Claimant Name: Full legal name
Employer Name: Registered business name
Date of Injury: MM/DD/YYYY
Claim Number: Board or insurer number
Controversion Basis: Primary legal reason
Contact Info: Phone and email

Step-by-Step: Preparing and Filing a Controversion

Follow a consistent sequence to preserve rights and meet administrative timelines.

  • 01
    Gather records: Collect medical, employment, and incident reports.
  • 02
    Draft statement: Summarize facts and legal grounds concisely.
  • 03
    Attach exhibits: Number and index supporting documents.
  • 04
    File with board: Submit via board portal or mail per rules.

Configuring an Online Controversion Workflow

When completing the controversion online, set up a secure, auditable workflow that matches your internal approval process.

Field Configuration
Authentication Method Email verification or multi-factor authentication
Conditional Fields Show additional fields when denial reason is 'not work related'
Signature Type Typed name, drawn signature, or certified e-signature
Audit Trail Capture IP, timestamp, and signer identity

Where and How to Submit a Controversion

Submission routes vary by state; use the workers' compensation board portal, designated regional office, or accepted mailing address.

  • Online Portal: Preferred method in most states
  • Email Filing: Accepted where board rules permit
  • Paper Mail: Use certified mail if allowed
  • In-Person: File at regional board office

Distribution and eSubmission Considerations

Choose delivery channels that meet board rules and preserve proof of service.

  • File Format: PDF preferred; searchable where possible
  • Delivery Proof: Retain email headers or certified mail receipt
  • Integrations: Use case management or document systems

Timing and Processing Expectations

Statutory and procedural deadlines for controversion differ by state; file promptly and confirm specific board timelines to avoid waiver of defenses.

Initial Filing Window:

Varies by state — consult board rules

Service Requirements:

Serve claimant and opposing counsel per board procedure

Evidence Deadlines:

Adhere to board schedule for exhibits

Hearing Scheduling:

Board sets dates after filing is processed

Appeal Period:

Post-decision appeals follow state statute

Common Drafting Mistakes to Avoid

  • Failing to attach critical medical records leads to gaps in the administrative file and weakens defenses at hearing.
  • Using vague legal language such as 'not compensable' without specifying legal grounds reduces enforceability and invites broader discovery.
  • Misstating dates or employing inconsistent claimant identifiers can cause clerical rejection or misfiled records with the board.
  • Neglecting to serve the claimant and record service proof may result in default orders or sanctions against the filer.

Consequences of Incorrect or Late Controversions

Waived Defenses: Potential loss of certain defenses
Default Findings: Board may rule for claimant
Late Fees: Administrative penalties possible
Increased Exposure: Broader benefit obligations
Evidentiary Limits: Exclusion of late evidence
Appeal Costs: Higher litigation expenses

Representative Scenarios Where Controversion Was Used

Two anonymized examples illustrate how a focused controversion frames disputes and supports defense strategies.

Employer Denial Based on Causation

Employer documents inconsistent incident reports and medical records that question work causation

  • Board allowed motion for IME
  • Detailed exhibit indexing and a clear chronology led to a limited benefits finding, reducing long-term exposure.

Timely Reporting Dispute

Claimant reported injury after an extended delay with conflicting dates

  • Employer presented personnel timecards and surveillance
  • The board credited the employer's contemporaneous records and limited benefits to medical-only care.

Who Signs and Certifies a Controversion

Monica Reyes, Claims Manager

A claims manager typically prepares and certifies the controversion, coordinates records collection, and provides the named contact for board correspondence. They confirm internal approvals and ensure medical and employment documents are attached for the administrative record.

James Carter, Workers' Compensation Attorney

Counsel reviews legal bases, refines contested issues, and signs where attorney certification is required. Attorneys prepare hearing strategy, represent the employer at conferences, and manage appeals if the board's decision is adverse.

Supporting Documents to Attach with the Controversion

Attaching complete, well-labeled exhibits increases clarity, reduces requests for supplemental filings, and strengthens the administrative record.

Medical Records

Include full treatment records, diagnostic reports, and physician opinions; highlight dates and findings that relate to causation and treatment necessity.

Employment Records

Attach job descriptions, timecards, payroll records, and personnel files that show work duties and attendance relevant to the claimed injury.

Incident Reports

Provide contemporaneous incident or accident reports, witness statements, and photos or video that document the event and scene.

Expert Opinions

Include IME or peer review reports that address causation, impairment, and recommended vocational restrictions tied to the controversion grounds.

Frequently Asked Questions About Controverting a Workers' Compensation Claim

Answers to common procedural and evidentiary questions encountered when disputing a workers' compensation claim before a state board.


Need help? Contact support

Explore Templates

California Order Granting Authority to Consent to Medical Care Filing Cover Sheet California Order to Attend Court or Provide Documents California Petition for Disclosure of Juvenile Court Records California Petition to Obtain Report of Law Enforcement Agency California Entry Judgment
be ready to get more
Join over 28 million airSlate SignNow users
Sign Now
Company
Forms
Pricing
Resources
Knowledge base
Other Products
© 2026 airSlate Inc. All rights reserved.