Can a Performance Annual Review be signed electronically?

Yes. Electronic signatures that show intent, consent, signer attribution, and record retention are legally binding under the ESIGN Act (15 U.S.C. ch. 96) and UETA where adopted; exclude rare statutory exceptions such as wills or certain court filings.

Is notarization required for an annual performance review?

Typically no. Notarization and witness signatures are not required for routine Performance Annual Reviews in employment contexts. Specific transaction types (deeds, powers of attorney, wills) do require notarization or witnesses — verify state rules when a document conveys legal rights.

What retention period applies to signed reviews?

Retain active employment records while employment continues and at least three years post-termination to satisfy IRS and general HR standards; healthcare-related records may require six-year retention under HIPAA (45 CFR §164.530(j)). Consult state law for longer periods.

How do I ensure an electronic signature is attributable?

Use clear signer identity methods: authenticated email or SMS link, documented IP address, signer account records, and an audit trail with timestamps. For higher assurance, use multi-factor authentication or advanced signer verification measures.

Can the review be amended after signing?

Yes, but amendments should be captured as separate dated addenda with signatures from all affected parties. Maintain original signed review plus amendatory document to preserve auditability and avoid disputes over retroactive changes.

What filing errors should I avoid when finalizing reviews?

Common errors include missing dates, unsigned sections, inconsistent names, and failing to retain an audit trail. Use consistent templates, validate names against payroll, and preserve the signed PDF and audit log for compliance and future audits.

Electronic Signature
Templates
Miscellaneous
Performance Annual Review

Performance Annual Review

This template is fully customizable. Edit the text, fill out the fields, and send it for signature. Give it a try!

PERFORMANCE ANNUAL REVIEW AND AGREEMENT

Parties and Recitals

This Performance Annual Review and Agreement (the Agreement) is entered into between the parties below for the purposes of documenting performance, setting compensation adjustments, and memorializing mutual obligations.

WHEREAS, Employer Name: employs Employee Name: and requires a documented annual performance review and any related compensation actions; and

WHEREAS, the parties intend that this document serve both as an evaluative review for the review period and as an agreement regarding scope of responsibilities, compensation adjustments, confidentiality of review content, and the terms governing any changes to employment conditions.

WHEREAS, both parties acknowledge that the factual statements and ratings herein are accurate to the best of the signatories' knowledge and that any compensation adjustments described will be processed consistent with the Payment Terms below.

Employee and Review Identifiers

Employee ID Position / Title Department

Review Period: From to

Scope of Work

The Scope of Work describes the principal responsibilities and objectives against which performance is evaluated. The Employee's duties shall include, without limitation, the duties described below and such related tasks as reasonably assigned by the Employer.

Performance Ratings and Comments

For each criterion, select the rating that best reflects performance during the review period (1 = Unsatisfactory, 5 = Exceptional). Include supporting comments in the space provided.

Job Knowledge

1 2 3 4 5

Quality of Work

1 2 3 4 5

Communication and Teamwork

1 2 3 4 5

Compensation Adjustment and Payment Terms

Any compensation adjustments recommended as a result of this review will be processed in accordance with the Payment Terms below. All amounts are subject to applicable taxes and withholdings.

Adjustment Amount Payment Schedule Late Payment Fee

Term and Termination

This Agreement's term and any notice obligations are set forth below. The Employer and Employee may agree to extend or modify the term in writing.

Term Commencement:

Term Expiration:

Notice Period for Termination

Either party may terminate this Agreement for material breach if the other party fails to cure the breach within the notice period above. Termination for cause shall not affect accrued payment obligations.

Confidentiality

The Employee acknowledges that evaluation documents, compensation recommendations, and related communications are confidential business records. The Employee shall not disclose the substance of this review or compensation adjustments to third parties, except to the extent required by law or to tax and legal advisors under an obligation of confidentiality. Unauthorized disclosure may result in disciplinary action, up to and including termination.

Governing Law

This Agreement shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the laws of the State of without regard to conflict-of-law principles.

Entire Agreement

This document, together with any written attachments expressly incorporated herein, constitutes the entire agreement between the parties concerning the subject matter of this review and supersedes all prior agreements and understandings, whether written or oral. Any amendment must be in writing and signed by both parties.

Development Goals and Action Plan

Acknowledgment of Review

By signing below, the parties certify that they have discussed the content of this Annual Performance Review and any recommended compensation adjustments. The Employee's signature acknowledges receipt and discussion, and does not necessarily indicate agreement with all contents.

Employer (Printed Name):

By:

Date:

Employee (Printed Name):

By:

Date:

What the Performance Annual Review Is and why it matters

The Performance Annual Review is a standardized document used by employers to evaluate an employee’s yearly performance, record objectives, and document compensation changes or development plans. It consolidates supervisor assessments, measurable goals, competency ratings, and employee self-evaluations into a single, dated record for HR files. Organizations use it to support promotion decisions, training needs, and compliance with internal policy. When completed accurately, the review provides an auditable history of performance conversations and outcomes that can be retained alongside payroll and personnel records.

Practical benefits of a well-prepared review

A Performance Annual Review clarifies expectations, documents achievements and areas for improvement, and creates a consistent record for personnel decisions. It supports fair performance management, reduces disputes about evaluation outcomes, and helps align employee development with organizational goals.

Who prepares, signs, and stores a Performance Annual Review

Human resources staff, direct managers, and employees typically prepare or contribute to Performance Annual Reviews as part of routine personnel management.

Line managers: draft evaluations, score competencies, and recommend development actions.
HR teams: consolidate reviews, maintain records, and ensure policy compliance.
Employees: submit self-assessments, acknowledge feedback, and track agreed objectives for review.

The review process also commonly involves compensation specialists, legal counsel for sensitive cases, and senior leaders for approvals and audit oversight.

Core parts of a professional Performance Annual Review

A professional Performance Annual Review contains structured ratings, goal tracking, development plans, and signatures to create a complete personnel record.

Summary

Concise executive summary of the employee’s overall performance, core accomplishments, and principal areas needing improvement; used by HR and leadership for promotion and compensation decisions, and for documenting performance trends over time.

Goals

Documented measurable objectives for the coming year with owners, deadlines, and success criteria; links to company OKRs or KPIs and a place to record progress updates during midyear check-ins.

Competencies

Ratings and narrative on core competencies, behavioral expectations, and technical skills; includes calibration notes and examples to justify ratings and reduce subjective evaluation variance across managers.

Development

Training, mentoring, and planned actions with estimated timelines and resource needs; identifies who will support development and how progress will be measured during follow-up reviews.

Compensation

Records salary adjustments, bonus eligibility, or equity recommendations tied to performance outcomes; must reference compensation policy, effective dates, and required approvals for auditability.

Signatures

Signature and date fields for reviewer, employee, and HR representative; captures acknowledgment, consent to objectives, and creates a dated legal record for personnel files.

Essential information to capture on the form

Employee Name: Full legal name as on ID

Employee ID: Company-assigned employee identifier code

Review Period: Period start and end dates

Job Title: Current role and department

Ratings: Numeric or categorical scale

Reviewer Name: Manager and HR representative

Step-by-step: complete and finalize a review

Follow these sequential steps to prepare, review, and finalize the Performance Annual Review for an employee.

01

Prepare Draft: Manager completes evaluation and attaches supporting examples.
02

Employee Input: Employee submits self-assessment and optional comments.
03

Calibration: HR reviews ratings for consistency across teams.
04

Finalize & File: Signatures captured and document saved to personnel file.

Configure the digital workflow for reviews

Configure the online review workflow to capture approvals, reminders, and electronic signatures with proper authentication.

Field	Configuration
Routing Order	Sequential approval: manager, HR, employee.
Reminder Schedule	Automated reminders at 7 and 3 days before due date.
Authentication Level	Email link with optional SMS code for higher assurance.
Signature Method	Allow typed, drawn, or uploaded signatures; capture timestamp.

Where to send or file completed reviews

Typical routes for completed reviews include HR records, manager archives, and secure digital storage for audit and compliance.

HR System: Upload signed review to HRIS or personnel database.
Manager Folder: Store a copy in the manager’s secure team folder.
Employee Copy: Provide employee with a dated PDF for personal records.
Audit Archive: Retain an immutable copy in compliance storage with audit trail.

Distribution, formats, and integration considerations

Choose distribution methods that match privacy and audit requirements, limit access by role, and ensure secure storage and retrieval.

Supported Formats: PDF, DOCX, and HTML supported.
Integrations: Salesforce, NetSuite, Google Workspace integration.
Authentication Options: Email link, SMS code, and SSO.

Typical deadlines and timing expectations

Key deadlines govern form distribution, employee acknowledgment, and HR filings to meet internal policy and external obligations.

Manager Submission Deadline:

Complete manager evaluation within 14 days after period end.

Employee Self-Assessment Due:

Employee submits self-assessment within 7 days of manager draft.

Calibration Window:

HR completes calibration within 21 days of submission.

Final Sign-Off Date:

All signatures and approvals obtained within 30 days.

Record Filing Deadline:

Signed review uploaded to HRIS within 5 business days.

Key milestones in the review cycle

Major milestones outline preparation, feedback, calibration, and finalization steps in sequence for each review cycle.

01

Draft Prepared

Manager completes initial evaluation and records supporting examples.

02

Employee Review

Employee reads feedback and adds self-assessment comments.

03

HR Calibration

HR reviews across teams and resolves rating discrepancies.

04

Documentation Filed

Final signed review stored in HRIS with audit trail.

Common mistakes to avoid when preparing reviews

Incomplete dates or missing effective date can create ambiguity about which performance period a review covers and complicate retroactive pay or benefit calculations.
Vague or unsupported ratings without concrete examples increase the risk of disputes, inconsistent calibration, and potential legal exposure in discrimination or wrongful termination claims.
Failing to capture employee acknowledgment or signatures leaves personnel actions open to challenge and can invalidate processes tied to promotion or bonus eligibility.
Storing signed reviews in unsecured or personal folders impedes audit readiness and may violate internal retention policies or data protection requirements such as HIPAA where applicable.

Consequences of incorrect or incomplete reviews

Disputed Decisions: Employee appeals and grievance proceedings

Compensation Errors: Incorrect pay adjustments

Compliance Violations: Breach of recordkeeping laws

Legal Exposure: Potential employment litigation

Audit Findings: Failed internal or external audits

Reputational Harm: Loss of trust among staff

Comparing eSignature platforms commonly used for reviews

Pricing and feature comparison for common eSignature plans used to complete Performance Annual Reviews; signNow appears first per platform ordering rules.

	signNow	DocuSign	Adobe Sign	PandaDoc	HelloSign
Starting Price	$8/user/mo	$15/user/mo	$14/user/mo	$19/user/mo	$15/user/mo
Free Trial	7-day trial	Varies	Varies	Varies	Varies
Bulk Send	Yes	Varies	Varies	Varies	Varies
Audit Trail	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
HIPAA Compliant	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No

FAQs: signing, storage, and common issues

Answers to frequent questions about completing, signing, and storing Performance Annual Reviews, including digital signature and retention concerns.

Need help? Contact support

Can a Performance Annual Review be signed electronically?
Yes. Electronic signatures that show intent, consent, signer attribution, and record retention are legally binding under the ESIGN Act (15 U.S.C. ch. 96) and UETA where adopted; exclude rare statutory exceptions such as wills or certain court filings.
Is notarization required for an annual performance review?
Typically no. Notarization and witness signatures are not required for routine Performance Annual Reviews in employment contexts. Specific transaction types (deeds, powers of attorney, wills) do require notarization or witnesses — verify state rules when a document conveys legal rights.
What retention period applies to signed reviews?
Retain active employment records while employment continues and at least three years post-termination to satisfy IRS and general HR standards; healthcare-related records may require six-year retention under HIPAA (45 CFR §164.530(j)). Consult state law for longer periods.
How do I ensure an electronic signature is attributable?
Use clear signer identity methods: authenticated email or SMS link, documented IP address, signer account records, and an audit trail with timestamps. For higher assurance, use multi-factor authentication or advanced signer verification measures.
Can the review be amended after signing?
Yes, but amendments should be captured as separate dated addenda with signatures from all affected parties. Maintain original signed review plus amendatory document to preserve auditability and avoid disputes over retroactive changes.
What filing errors should I avoid when finalizing reviews?
Common errors include missing dates, unsigned sections, inconsistent names, and failing to retain an audit trail. Use consistent templates, validate names against payroll, and preserve the signed PDF and audit log for compliance and future audits.

be ready to get more

Join over 28 million airSlate SignNow users

Sign Now