Can criteria be applied retroactively?

No. Apply the version of the criteria effective on the application date. Changing rules after an application is submitted can expose you to claims of unfair treatment or breach of implied agreement; retain the dated criteria in the applicant file.

Are electronic signatures valid?

Yes. Electronic signatures meet legal standards under the ESIGN Act (15 U.S.C. ch. 96) and UETA (1999) when intent, consent, attribution, and retention are satisfied. Some exceptions apply for specific document types.

When is notarization required?

Notarization for rental criteria itself is rare, but underlying documents (powers of attorney, guarantees) may require notary or RON per state rules; verify with the state notary commission for jurisdictional requirements.

How long must applicant files be kept?

Retain application files for at least 3 years from the application date for general tax and documentation purposes; longer retention may be required for certain industries or state laws and for litigation holds.

What should a denial notice include?

Provide a clear adverse action notice explaining the reason, any credit or screening source used, and consumer rights. Follow FCRA and state notice requirements for consumer reporting and adverse action.

Can criteria consider criminal history?

Yes, but states and localities may limit use of criminal records; perform individualized assessments when required and consult local ordinances to avoid unlawful exclusion.

Electronic Signature
Templates
Real estate
Rental Property Criteria

Rental Property Criteria

This template is fully customizable. Edit the text, fill out the fields, and send it for signature. Give it a try!

RENTAL PROPERTY CRITERIA

Property Identification

Property Name Property Address Parcel / APN Legal Description

Effective Date:

Property Management Contact

Owner / Managing Agent Company Contact Phone Contact Email

Unit and Financial Terms

Unit Type(s) Standard Monthly Rent Security Deposit Application Fee Holding Deposit / Reservation Fee Late Fee Returned Check Fee

Utilities and Responsibilities

Utilities paid by Landlord:

Utilities paid by Tenant:

Occupancy and Pets

Maximum occupants: (or specify per bedroom)

Pets Policy

Pets Allowed: Yes No

If allowed, pet deposit: Monthly pet rent:

Breed or size restrictions (if any):

Screening Criteria and Standards

Income Requirement: Prospective tenants must demonstrate gross monthly income of at least the monthly rent. Acceptable income documentation includes pay stubs, employer verification, tax returns, or other verifiable sources.

Credit Standards: Minimum qualifying credit score: . Scores below this may be considered with a guarantor or higher security deposit. Credit reports may be evaluated for recent collections, charge-offs, or judgments.

Rental History: Applicants must provide at least months of satisfactory rental history. Prior evictions within years are cause for denial unless resolved and documentation provided.

Criminal History: The property conducts criminal background checks. The following convictions are automatically disqualifying unless otherwise reviewed: . Consideration will be given to the nature, severity, and recency of the offense and evidence of rehabilitation.

Bankruptcy: Bankruptcy filings discharged within the last years will be considered with additional documentation and/or increased deposit.

Guarantor / Co-signer Policy: Allowed Not Allowed. Guarantors must demonstrate qualifying income and credit as specified above.

Acceptable Forms of Identification: Government-issued photo ID and Social Security number or taxpayer identification number are required for screening and lease execution.

Disclosures

Lead-Based Paint (for properties built before 1978):

Presence of known lead-based paint hazards: Yes No

Known mold or moisture intrusion affecting habitability:

Yes No

Prior structural or habitability damage repaired prior to offering:

Yes No

Screening Procedures and Privacy

Applicants must complete a written application and provide true and complete information. Screening will include verification of income, employment, rental history, and consumer reports (credit, eviction, and criminal background). Applicant information will be retained only as necessary to comply with legal obligations and defense of rental decisions.

Applicant Authorization: By submitting an application, the applicant consents to the collection and use of consumer-report information for tenancy decisions and authorizes the release of employment and rental references to the landlord or managing agent for screening purposes.

Applicant Notice Procedure

Reasonable Accommodation and Fair Housing

It is the policy of the landlord to comply with applicable fair housing laws. Reasonable accommodations for persons with disabilities will be evaluated on a case-by-case basis. Requests for accommodations should be submitted in writing and will be responded to in a timely manner.

Default, Amendment, and Governing Law

These criteria represent management policies for screening applicants for the property identified above. Management reserves the right to amend or waive any criteria in specific circumstances. All disputes regarding interpretation or enforcement of these criteria shall be governed by applicable state law where the property is located.

Administrative Certification

The undersigned certifies that the information and standards contained in this Rental Property Criteria document accurately reflect the policies of the property owner or managing agent and are posted or made available to prospective applicants as required by law or practice.

Property Manager / Owner Name:

By:

Date:

What the Rental Property Criteria Document Is

The Rental Property Criteria is a written checklist or form landlords and property managers use to describe eligibility rules, required documentation, and screening thresholds for prospective renters. It clarifies income, credit, rental history, pet policy, and occupancy limits so applicants and staff share a consistent set of expectations. Well‑crafted criteria reduce subjective decision‑making, support fair housing compliance, and establish the evidentiary basis for approvals or denials. Use it as an attachment to applications, a staff checklist, or a published policy for applicants to review before applying.

Why a Clear Rental Property Criteria Matters

A concise criteria document promotes consistent screening, reduces bias, and helps demonstrate adherence to fair housing laws. It benefits both applicants and managers by setting transparent rules for income ratios, credit thresholds, and required documents.

Who Typically Creates and Uses These Criteria

The Rental Property Criteria is used across leasing teams, independent landlords, and third‑party screening services to standardize tenant selection and document retention.

Property managers and leasing agents who process multiple applications and need consistent rules for approvals.
Independent landlords managing one or several units who want clear, defensible standards and reduced screening disputes.
Third‑party screening or leasing services that execute checks and provide recommendations based on documented thresholds.

Use the criteria as a communication tool for applicants and as an operational checklist for staff to ensure consistent decisions and defensible recordkeeping.

Step-by-step process to apply the criteria

Follow these ordered steps so each application is reviewed consistently and records are retained to support decisions.

01

1. Intake: Collect application and all required documents from the applicant.
02

2. Verification: Run income, employment, credit, and rental history checks per stated thresholds.
03

3. Decision: Compare results to criteria and document approval, conditional approval, or denial reasons.
04

4. Recordkeeping: Store the application and supporting files in compliance with retention rules.

Core elements to include in professional Rental Property Criteria

A complete criteria document combines objective thresholds, acceptable documentation, and process notes so reviewers apply rules reliably across applicants.

Income Standard

Define required income (ratio or absolute), whether co‑signers count, and acceptable proof (pay stubs, bank statements, award letters).

Credit Policy

Supply minimum scores, how recent inquiries are treated, and whether bankruptcies or collections disqualify or permit conditional approval.

Criminal History

State screening scope and any exclusions required by local law; identify disqualifying offenses or individualized assessment procedures.

Rental History

Require references, acceptable verification methods, and disqualifying rental events such as evictions or unpaid rent.

Occupancy & Pets

Specify maximum occupants per unit and pet rules, deposits, or breed restrictions consistent with local ordinances.

Reasonable Accommodations

Describe process for accommodation requests under the Fair Housing Act and documentation required for verification.

Essential data points to capture and retain

Applicant Name: Full legal name

Contact Information: Phone and email

Identification: Government ID type and number

Income Proof: Pay stubs or benefit letters

Credit Report: Score and report date

Decision Record: Approval, denial, or conditional notes

How to configure an online screening workflow

Map each required action to a digital field and automated check to reduce manual steps and ensure consistent evidence capture.

Field	Configuration
Applicant Upload	Require PDF/JPG; limit size; mark as mandatory
Verification Trigger	Auto-send credit and background checks on submission
Conditional Fields	Show co-signer fields when income shortfall detected
Audit Trail	Enable time, IP, and action logging for each step

Where completed Rental Property Criteria documents should be sent

A clear routing process ensures criteria documentation is stored with the application and shared with authorized reviewers only.

Applicant Portal: Applicants upload forms and docs to the secure portal.
Screening Provider: Automated checks run and results return to the leasing file.
Leasing Team: Managers review results and apply documented criteria.
Records Storage: Finalized files archived in secure document management.

Technology and distribution options for sharing criteria

Choose channels that protect applicant data and retain a complete audit trail for each screening step.

Email: Use only encrypted file attachments; avoid unprotected personal data
Document Platform: PDF/Word support with version history
Third‑party Integrations: Connect to CRM or property management systems

Common timelines and deadline expectations

Establish service timelines for each stage so applicants know when to expect decisions and staff track compliance with fair housing and retention rules.

Application Acknowledgement:

Respond within 2 business days of receipt

Screening Completion:

Complete checks within 3–5 business days

Decision Notice:

Send approval/denial within 5 business days

Adverse Action:

Provide required notice with reason and consumer rights

Record Retention Start:

Retention period begins on the application date

Key milestones from application to occupancy

Track these numbered stages to monitor progress and maintain required documentation at each step.

01

Application Submitted

Applicant completes form and uploads required documents.

02

Identity and Income Verified

Verify ID and income per listed acceptable documents.

03

Background and Credit Checks

Order reports and evaluate against thresholds.

04

Final Decision and Lease Offer

Document approval conditions and prepare lease packet.

Common mistakes that delay processing

Accepting vague income documentation such as unsigned bank screenshots instead of certified pay stubs or employer verification.
Failing to document compensating factors when an applicant narrowly misses a numeric threshold, leaving decisions open to challenge.
Using different criteria for similar units or applicants, which can create inconsistent treatment and fair housing risk.
Not retaining a dated copy of the criteria in force at the time of application, complicating audits or dispute resolution.

Consequences of incorrect or inconsistent criteria

Fair Housing Liability: Disparate treatment claims or administrative penalties

Adverse Action Violations: Failure to provide required notices can trigger consumer complaints

Tax or Audit Risk: Missing records affect tax deductions or litigation defense

Eviction Complications: Improper screening may complicate enforcement of lease terms

Reputational Damage: Public complaints reduce applicant interest

Recordkeeping Fines: State statutes may impose fines for improper retention

eSignature vendor pricing and feature snapshot

Basic pricing and feature availability for common eSignature providers; signNow is shown first to align with platform comparison standards.

	signNow	DocuSign	Adobe Sign	PandaDoc	HelloSign
Starting Price	$8/user/mo	$15/user/mo	$14/user/mo	$19/user/mo	$15/user/mo
Free Trial	7-day free trial	Verify with vendor	Verify with vendor	Verify with vendor	Verify with vendor
Bulk Send	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No
Audit Trail	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
HIPAA Compliant	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No

Practical examples of Rental Property Criteria in use

Real‑world scenarios show how criteria reduce disputes and speed approvals across different property sizes.

Small Portfolio Landlord

A landlord formalized a 2.5x income rule and required two months of pay stubs

This reduced ambiguous approvals
As a result, denials were documented with consistent evidence and tenant turnover disputes declined, improving recordkeeping for tax and legal review.

Large Management Company

A management firm centralized criteria across 300 units and automated checks

It implemented conditional approval rules
The standardized approach cut average processing time from five days to under two days and ensured audit trails for compliance reviews.

Who may sign or approve the Rental Property Criteria

Property Owner

An owner or principal with authority to set leasing policy should sign or authorize criteria. Their signature documents official adoption and assigns operational responsibilities for enforcement and updates.

Property Manager or Authorized Agent

A designated manager or company officer can sign on behalf of the owner if granted written authority. The signer must be recorded as having delegated decision rights and documented in internal records.

Frequently asked questions about Rental Property Criteria

Answers to common operational and legal questions about creating, applying, and storing Rental Property Criteria.

Need help? Contact support

Can criteria be applied retroactively?
No. Apply the version of the criteria effective on the application date. Changing rules after an application is submitted can expose you to claims of unfair treatment or breach of implied agreement; retain the dated criteria in the applicant file.
Are electronic signatures valid?
Yes. Electronic signatures meet legal standards under the ESIGN Act (15 U.S.C. ch. 96) and UETA (1999) when intent, consent, attribution, and retention are satisfied. Some exceptions apply for specific document types.
When is notarization required?
Notarization for rental criteria itself is rare, but underlying documents (powers of attorney, guarantees) may require notary or RON per state rules; verify with the state notary commission for jurisdictional requirements.
How long must applicant files be kept?
Retain application files for at least 3 years from the application date for general tax and documentation purposes; longer retention may be required for certain industries or state laws and for litigation holds.
What should a denial notice include?
Provide a clear adverse action notice explaining the reason, any credit or screening source used, and consumer rights. Follow FCRA and state notice requirements for consumer reporting and adverse action.
Can criteria consider criminal history?
Yes, but states and localities may limit use of criminal records; perform individualized assessments when required and consult local ordinances to avoid unlawful exclusion.

be ready to get more

Join over 28 million airSlate SignNow users

Sign Now