Can this document be signed electronically?

Yes. Electronic signatures are legally valid in the U.S. under the ESIGN Act (15 U.S.C. §7001) and UETA where adopted, provided intent, consent, attribution, and retention requirements are met.

Who should sign and approve it?

Signatories typically include the inspecting QA officer, an engineering approver for technical disposition, procurement for supplier remedies, and a supplier representative when applicable to document acceptance or contestation.

Is notarization or witnessing required?

Most internal nonconformance reports do not require notarization. If a state or contract requires witnessed acknowledgements, follow the applicable state rules or contractual clause, and consider RON where permitted.

How do I correct an error after signing?

Create an addendum or corrected version with clear change history and new signatures. Do not alter the signed record in place; preserve the original for auditability.

What happens if the supplier disagrees?

Record the supplier response as part of the report, escalate per contract dispute procedures, and preserve all communications and test data for resolution or arbitration.

How long must records be kept?

Follow general retention rules: at least 3 years for tax-relevant records (IRC §6501(a)) and industry-specific requirements such as HIPAA six-year retention where applicable (45 CFR §164.530(j)).

Electronic Signature
Templates
Miscellaneous
Specification Out of Spec Document

Specification Out of Spec Document

This template is fully customizable. Edit the text, fill out the fields, and send it for signature. Give it a try!

SPECIFICATION OUT OF SPEC DOCUMENT

RECITALS

WHEREAS, Client Name: and Supplier Name: entered into a supply relationship under Contract Number: effective on .

WHEREAS, during inspection, testing, or production, material or product described below was determined to deviate from the contractual or published specification (the "Nonconformity"); and the parties require a formal record of the deviation, root cause analysis, proposed corrective actions, disposition, and any commercial or schedule impacts.

SCOPE OF WORK

Scope of Work

NONCONFORMITY DETAILS

Item Description

Part / Drawing No.

Lot / Batch

Quantity Affected

Specification Requirement (as claimed)

Measured Value:

Tolerance / Acceptable Range:

Test Method / Inspection

Date Discovered

Location / Facility Initial Findings / Notes

ROOT CAUSE AND CORRECTIVE ACTION

Root Cause Analysis Corrective / Preventive Action (CAPA)

CAPA Due Date

Responsible Party

PROPOSED DISPOSITION

Select one or more disposition actions to address the Nonconformity:

Rework to specification at Supplier expense Use as-is with agreed concession/price reduction Return for credit or replacement Scrap / Dispose Other (specify)

IMPACT ON CONTRACT PERFORMANCE AND PRICE

Description of impact to schedule or deliverables

Proposed Price Adjustment

Who Bears Cost

PAYMENT TERMS

Amount Due Related to Nonconformity Payment Schedule / Terms

Late Fee or Interest for Overdue Amounts

TERM AND TERMINATION

This Specification Out of Spec Document takes effect on Start Date: and remains in effect until End Date: , unless earlier terminated in accordance with this section.

Either party may terminate this document for material breach if the breaching party fails to cure within Notice Period: days after receipt of written notice describing the breach. Termination does not relieve the breaching party of liability for breaches occurring prior to termination.

CONFIDENTIALITY

Each party will keep confidential and will not disclose to any third party information designated as confidential or that by its nature is confidential, including nonconforming test data, root cause reports, corrective actions, pricing adjustments, and any associated technical documentation. Confidential information shall be used solely for the purposes of resolving the Nonconformity and administering this document. The obligations of confidentiality shall survive for Confidentiality Period (years): years from the date of execution, except as required by law.

GOVERNING LAW; ENTIRE AGREEMENT

This document and any dispute arising out of or relating to it shall be governed by the laws of the State of without regard to conflict of law principles. The parties submit to the exclusive jurisdiction of the courts located in that state for resolution of disputes unless the parties agree otherwise in writing.

This document constitutes the entire agreement between the parties with respect to the subject matter hereof and supersedes all prior discussions, proposals, and understandings relating to the Nonconformity, except as expressly incorporated into this document in writing.

ACKNOWLEDGMENT

By signing below, the undersigned represent and warrant that they are authorized representatives of their respective parties, that they have read and understood this Specification Out of Spec Document, and that they agree to the terms, dispositions, corrective actions, and commercial adjustments described herein.

Supplier Printed Name:

By:

Date:

Client Printed Name:

By:

Date:

What a Specification Out of Spec Document Is

A Specification Out of Spec Document records and explains instances where a delivered product, component, or process does not meet a previously agreed specification. It documents the nonconformance details, affected part or batch numbers, the measured deviation, immediate containment actions, root-cause hypotheses, and recommended remediation or disposition. The document creates an auditable trail for engineering, quality, procurement, and regulatory review and forms the basis for corrective action, supplier credit, or design changes when formal approval or a change order is required.

Why documenting out-of-spec matters

A clear Specification Out of Spec Document preserves evidence, supports consistent decision-making, and reduces dispute risk by recording facts, measured deviations, and agreed remediations in one place.

Who completes and reviews this document

Multiple teams typically contribute to and review an out-of-spec report to ensure technical accuracy and commercial clarity.

Quality assurance teams: verify measurements, containment steps, and disposition recommendations for affected lots.
Procurement and supplier managers: confirm contractual remedies, coordinate supplier responses, and track credit or replacement claims.
Engineering and product teams: assess root cause, determine rework or design changes, and update specifications if needed.

The completed record supports quality metrics, supplier management, and any necessary regulatory disclosures or warranty actions.

Typical signatories and approvers

Quality Manager

The Quality Manager signs to confirm inspection results and containment actions, provides technical context for the deviation, and authorizes disposition or rework consistent with company quality procedures.

Supplier Representative

The Supplier Representative acknowledges receipt, accepts or contests measured values, commits to remediation steps or credits, and records any timeline for corrective actions or replacement shipments.

Step-by-step: completing the out-of-spec record

Follow a consistent sequence to ensure completeness and traceability from discovery to disposition and closure.

01

Record discovery: Document date, location, inspector, and initial measured deviation.
02

Containment actions: Note quarantine steps, stop-ship orders, and any immediate safety measures.
03

Root-cause analysis: Attach test data, inspection reports, and initial causal hypotheses.
04

Disposition and approval: Specify rework, scrap, concession, or supplier replacement and collect required approvals.

Typical workflow from discovery to closure

A streamlined workflow minimizes production disruption while preserving evidence for corrective actions and commercial resolution.

Discovery and Log: Create the out-of-spec record and assign a unique ID for tracking.
Technical Review: Quality and engineering review measurement data and containment.
Supplier Engagement: Notify supplier, request root-cause analysis and corrective plan.
Close and Archive: Approve disposition, record credits or rework, and archive the finalized record.

Core elements of a professional out-of-spec report

A complete document blends factual measurement data with administrative fields to support technical decisions, contractual remedies, and regulatory compliance.

Identification

Unique report ID, related purchase order, affected product code, and specification revision to link the nonconformance to contractual and design artifacts.

Measurement Data

Precise test results, calibration references, equipment identifiers, units, tolerances, and attachments such as photos, lab certificates, or raw data files.

Impact Assessment

Quantify affected quantity, downstream risk, customer exposure, and whether functionality or safety is compromised to inform disposition choices.

Containment Actions

Immediate steps taken to isolate affected inventory, stop further assembly, and preserve evidence for root-cause investigation and supplier review.

Corrective Plan

Proposed remediation, timeline, responsible party, verification steps, and criteria for acceptance once corrective actions complete.

Approvals

Signature blocks for QA, engineering, procurement, and supplier acceptance, plus dates and role titles for clear accountability.

Supporting files and export options

Attach supporting artifacts and export the completed report in common formats for archival, supplier sharing, and audit purposes.

Attachments

Include inspection photos, lab certificates, calibration logs, and supplier test data to substantiate measurement claims and accelerate resolution.

PDF Export

Generate a PDF/A copy with an included audit trail and attachments for long-term archival and cross-system distribution.

Raw Data

Provide CSV or Excel export of measurement records and test logs when reviewers require numerical analysis or SPC charting.

Archive Metadata

Embed report ID, version history, approver names, and retention tags to support retrieval and regulatory audits.

Practical tips for accurate and efficient reports

Adopting concise habits reduces rework and clarifies responsibility across teams and suppliers.

Use consistent identifiers and templates

Standardize report IDs, spec references, and field order so downstream teams and suppliers can immediately locate required information and attachments.

Capture evidence at discovery

Take dated photos, save raw instrument output, and note operator names. Delays in evidence collection make root-cause analysis harder.

Document measurement methods

Record test procedures, calibration certificates, and environmental conditions to ensure results are reproducible and defensible.

Assign clear owners and deadlines

Specify who will perform corrective actions, set verification checkpoints, and require time-bound supplier responses to avoid open-ended issues.

Typical response and processing timelines

Define internal and supplier deadlines to keep remediation on schedule and maintain contract compliance.

Initial containment response:

Within 24–72 hours of discovery, depending on risk severity.

Supplier acknowledgement:

Supplier should acknowledge receipt within 3–5 business days.

Root-cause submission:

Supplier root-cause analysis typically due within 10–15 business days.

Corrective action implementation:

Target completion within 30–60 days unless safety risk demands faster action.

Final verification:

Verification testing and closure within 5–10 business days after remediation.

Milestones from report filing to closure

Track key stages as numbered milestones to provide visibility and measure cycle time improvements.

01

1. Report Filed

Create the out-of-spec record and assign an ID immediately after discovery.

02

2. Containment Enacted

Isolate affected inventory and notify impacted teams or customers if needed.

03

3. Corrective Actions

Implement remediation steps, schedule rework, or arrange replacements.

04

4. Verification and Close

Confirm acceptance criteria met, document results, and archive the record.

Setting up a digital review and approval workflow

Configure an electronic workflow to automate routing, approvals, and archival while preserving an audit trail.

Field	Configuration
Document ID	Auto-generate unique ID on create
Approval Sequence	QA → Engineering → Procurement → Supplier
Authentication	Email verification or SMS code; optional KBA for suppliers
Retention Tag	Apply retention policy and archive upon closure

How this document differs from a formal change order

Compare the immediate nonconformance record to a formal change order to clarify purpose and next steps.

Criteria	Specification Out of Spec	Formal Change Order
Purpose	document deviation	authorize permanent change
Approval needed	qa and supplier	cross-functional sign-off
Timing	immediate containment	planned scheduling
Contract impact	remedy-focused	contractual amendment

eSignature vendor comparison for this document type

Comparing baseline service capabilities and cost models can inform platform selection for signing, routing, and archival of out-of-spec records.

	signNow	DocuSign	Adobe Sign	PandaDoc	HelloSign
Starting Price	$8/user/mo	$15/user/mo	$14/user/mo	$19/user/mo	$15/user/mo
Free Trial	7-day free trial	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
Bulk Send	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No
Audit Trail	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
HIPAA Compliant	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No

Common preparation and handling mistakes

Incomplete identifiers: omitting lot or serial numbers that prevent traceability and slow supplier response.
Insufficient evidence: failing to attach calibration certificates or raw measurement data undermines technical conclusions.
Vague disposition: using terms like 'may rework' without acceptance criteria leads to disputed outcomes and delays.
Missing approvals: circulating an unsigned report or lacking supplier acknowledgment exposes the company to unresolved warranty claims.

Consequences of poorly documented nonconformance

Contractual liability: Supplier or purchaser liability for breach

Warranty exposure: Extended repair or replacement obligations

Regulatory risk: Possible inspection or fines in regulated industries

Recall costs: High remediation and logistics expenses

Reputational harm: Customer trust and brand damage

Operational delays: Production stoppage and schedule slippage

Real-world examples of digital handling

Below are anonymized customer scenarios showing how digital records and signatures improved traceability and resolution.

Tim Martin — Martin Properties

When a critical component failed incoming inspection, the team logged a complete nonconformance record and attached photos and lab data

Immediate containment quarantined two lots pending supplier analysis
Using a single digital report enabled rapid supplier agreement on rework, expedited replacement shipments, and clear archival for warranty claims and audit.

Dan Rotelli — BIS

A supplier shipment had dimensional deviations discovered during assembly, prompting an out-of-spec report and engineering review

The supplier provided root-cause analysis within ten days
The documented workflow, signatures, and attachments reduced cycle time and created a defensible record for contractual remediation and future supplier scorecarding.

Frequently asked questions and practical answers

Answers address common legal, procedural, and technical questions about completing and using a Specification Out of Spec Document.

Need help? Contact support

Can this document be signed electronically?
Yes. Electronic signatures are legally valid in the U.S. under the ESIGN Act (15 U.S.C. §7001) and UETA where adopted, provided intent, consent, attribution, and retention requirements are met.
Who should sign and approve it?
Signatories typically include the inspecting QA officer, an engineering approver for technical disposition, procurement for supplier remedies, and a supplier representative when applicable to document acceptance or contestation.
Is notarization or witnessing required?
Most internal nonconformance reports do not require notarization. If a state or contract requires witnessed acknowledgements, follow the applicable state rules or contractual clause, and consider RON where permitted.
How do I correct an error after signing?
Create an addendum or corrected version with clear change history and new signatures. Do not alter the signed record in place; preserve the original for auditability.
What happens if the supplier disagrees?
Record the supplier response as part of the report, escalate per contract dispute procedures, and preserve all communications and test data for resolution or arbitration.
How long must records be kept?
Follow general retention rules: at least 3 years for tax-relevant records (IRC §6501(a)) and industry-specific requirements such as HIPAA six-year retention where applicable (45 CFR §164.530(j)).

be ready to get more

Join over 28 million airSlate SignNow users

Sign Now