Can the form be signed electronically?

Yes. Electronic signatures are legally valid under the ESIGN Act (15 U.S.C. ch. 96) and UETA in most states, provided the signature shows intent, consent, attribution, and retention of the record.

Do vendor submissions need notarization?

Generally no for vendor selection forms. Notarization is rarely required unless the solicitation or state law specifies sworn affidavits or authenticated attestations for specific procurement types.

What if a vendor provides incomplete information?

Mark missing fields and request completion within a defined period. For public procurements, follow the solicitation rules on disqualification versus allowed clarifications to avoid protest risk.

How long should records be kept?

Retain completed forms per federal and industry rules: minimum 3 years for tax purposes (IRC §6501(a)), 6 years for HIPAA-related records (45 CFR §164.530(j)), or longer per contract or state law.

Who must sign the form on the vendor side?

An authorized officer or agent with authority to bind the vendor should sign. Document signatory authority and corporate title to prevent later disputes over contract validity.

Is additional authentication required for sensitive contracts?

Consider stronger signer authentication (multi-factor, ID credential analysis) for high-risk or regulated engagements, and retain proof of identity and consent in the audit trail.

Electronic Signature
Templates
Miscellaneous
Vendor Selection Criteria Form

Vendor Selection Criteria Form

This template is fully customizable. Edit the text, fill out the fields, and send it for signature. Give it a try!

Vendor Selection Criteria Form

Recitals

WHEREAS, Client Name: seeks to procure goods and/or services described in this document; and

WHEREAS, Potential Vendor Name: has submitted information and proposals for evaluation under the criteria set forth herein; and

WHEREAS, the parties desire to document the selection criteria, scoring methodology, and related contractual terms that will govern selection and subsequent engagement of the selected vendor.

Vendor Identification

Primary Contact Business Address Primary Phone / Email

Scope of Work

Describe the goods, services, or deliverables to be provided

Evaluation Criteria and Scoring

Use the criteria below to score submissions. Enter weight as percentage and score as a numeric value. Total weight must equal 100%.

Technical Capability Applicable

Price / Commercial Terms Applicable

Experience & References Applicable

Compliance & Certifications Applicable

Evaluator Notes and Rationale

Payment Terms

Total Contract Value Payment Schedule (select all that apply and specify amounts or percentages)

Milestone-based — Specify milestones and amounts

Monthly invoicing — Net

Upon completion — Final invoice

Late Payment Fee

Term and Termination

Agreement Term Start Date:

Agreement Term End Date:

Notice Period for Termination

Either party may terminate the engagement for material breach if the breaching party fails to cure such breach within the notice period specified above. Termination for convenience by Client requires reasonable advance written notice as set forth in the notice period.

Confidentiality

Each party shall protect Confidential Information of the other with at least the same degree of care it uses to protect its own confidential information but not less than a reasonable standard of care. "Confidential Information" includes non-public business, technical, financial, pricing and customer information disclosed in connection with the procurement, and does not include information that: (a) is or becomes generally available to the public other than by breach; (b) is already rightfully in the receiving party's possession; or (c) is independently developed without use of the disclosing party's Confidential Information.

Confidentiality obligations survive termination of any engagement for a period of three (3) years unless otherwise agreed in writing.

Governing Law

This form and any subsequent agreement arising from selection of the vendor shall be governed by and construed in accordance with the laws of:

Entire Agreement

The provisions contained in this Vendor Selection Criteria Form, together with any executed engagement letter or purchase order referencing these criteria, constitute the entire agreement between the parties with respect to selection and engagement and supersede all prior communications, proposals, and understandings, whether written or oral, relating to the subject matter hereof.

Evaluation Summary

Final Selection Recommendation and Justification

By signing below, each signing party certifies that the information provided in this form is accurate to the best of their knowledge and that the selection and scoring process was conducted in accordance with applicable policies and the criteria stated herein.

Client Name:

By:

Date:

Vendor Name:

By:

Date:

What the Vendor Selection Criteria Form Is

A Vendor Selection Criteria Form is a structured document used during procurement to evaluate potential suppliers against predefined standards. It collects company details, financial stability, compliance certifications, performance metrics, insurance and references, and scoring across technical, commercial, and service categories. Organizations use it to compare bidders objectively, document decision rationale, and create an audit trail supporting contract awards and vendor onboarding.

Why a Clear Criteria Form Matters

A consistent Vendor Selection Criteria Form reduces bias, speeds evaluation, and creates a documented audit trail for procurement decisions. It helps purchasers compare offers on measurable factors and supports vendor accountability during contract performance.

Who Typically Completes or Uses This Form

This form is used by teams that manage procurement, risk, and vendor relationships as part of a structured sourcing process.

Procurement teams responsible for sourcing and scoring suppliers against objective criteria during RFPs and RFQs.
Contract managers who verify contractual readiness, insurance, and SLA alignment before award and onboarding.
Compliance and risk officers who confirm certifications, security controls, and regulatory fit for sensitive projects.

Use the form as a shared, auditable record to support selection decisions and as an input to contract terms and onboarding checklists.

Primary Roles Involved

Procurement Officer

A procurement officer completes scoring sections, aggregates vendor responses, and documents evaluation rationale. They coordinate cross-functional review, confirm required certifications, and ensure the chosen vendor meets procurement policy and budget constraints.

Vendor Representative

A vendor representative supplies company information, references, insurance certificates, pricing, and clarifications. Accurate, timely responses reduce follow-up requests and improve scoring during the evaluation phase, shortening procurement cycle time.

Core Sections of a Professional Vendor Selection Criteria Form

A complete form groups vendor data, evaluation metrics, compliance checks, scoring rules, references, and recommended actions to make comparisons straightforward and defensible.

Vendor Identification

Company legal name, DBA, address, tax ID, primary contact, and point-of-contact information for contracting and invoicing purposes.

Financial Health

Requested financial statements, credit references, and minimum turnover or bonding requirements used to assess stability and project delivery risk.

Technical Capability

Evidence of relevant experience, staffing plans, certifications, sample deliverables, and performance metrics tied to the solicitation requirements.

Compliance and Security

Required regulatory or security attestations (HIPAA, SOC 2, ISO), insurance limits, and evidence of data protection practices for sensitive work.

Commercial Terms

Pricing structure, payment terms, warranty provisions, service levels, and any standard exclusions that affect total cost of ownership.

Evaluation Scoring

Scoring methodology, weighted criteria, pass/fail thresholds, and a recommended award rationale field to capture evaluator conclusions.

Required Fields and Short Data Checklist

Legal Name: Exact entity name

Tax ID: EIN or SSN

Primary Contact: Name and email

Insurance: Policy type and limits

Certifications: SOC 2, ISO, HIPAA

References: Three client references

Key Risks and Potential Penalties

Tax reporting: Backup withholding risk 24% if TIN missing

Incorrect 1099s: 1099 late: $60–$660+ (IRC §6721)

I-9 violations: I-9 fines $281–$2,789 per violation

HIPAA breaches: HIPAA penalties and corrective action

Contract risk: Liability exposure from vague terms

Data loss: Operational and reputational damage

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Preparing the Form

Using inconsistent scoring weights across evaluators, which undermines fairness and creates audit challenges during contract award reviews.
Failing to require current insurance certificates or expired certificates, leaving the organization exposed to uninsured vendor activity.
Requesting unnecessary sensitive data without a lawful basis or data protection controls, increasing privacy and compliance risk.
Not documenting evaluation decisions or tie-breakers, which can lead to protests or challenges in public procurement contexts.

Step-by-Step: Completing a Vendor Selection Criteria Form

Follow this sequence to collect complete responses, score consistently, and document the award decision.

01

Prepare Form: Define criteria, weights, and pass/fail requirements.
02

Distribute to Vendors: Send form with RFP or request for information.
03

Collect Responses: Verify completeness and request missing items promptly.
04

Score and Document: Apply weights, reconcile scores, and record rationale.

Routing and Approval Workflow Overview

A clear routing flow reduces delays between submission, evaluation, and award.

Vendor Submission: Vendor uploads or returns the completed form and attachments.
Initial Review: Procurement checks mandatory fields and eligibility.
Scoring Panel: Subject matter experts score assigned sections.
Final Approval: Contract owner reviews scores and issues award recommendation.

Configuring the Digital Workflow

Map the form fields to routing rules and approvals for efficient e-processing.

Field	Configuration
Mandatory Flags	Set required fields to prevent incomplete submissions
Conditional Logic	Show or hide questions based on vendor responses
Approval Steps	Define sequential approvers with thresholds
Notification Rules	Email or platform alerts for status changes

Digital Tools and Integration Considerations

Choose a platform that supports secure submissions, audit trails, and integration with procurement systems.

File formats: Accept PDF, DOCX, and Excel inputs
Integrations: Connectors for ERP and CRM platforms
Authentication: Email, SMS, or SSO options

Ensure the selected solution preserves timestamped audit trails and stores attachments securely to support compliance and future audits.

Typical eSignature Vendor Pricing and Feature Snapshot

A compact comparison of starting price and core capabilities useful when choosing an eSignature provider to distribute and sign vendor forms.

	signNow	DocuSign	Adobe Sign	PandaDoc	HelloSign
Starting Price	$8/user/mo	$15/user/mo	$14/user/mo	$19/user/mo	$15/user/mo
Free Trial	Yes, 7-day trial	Verify	Verify	Verify	Verify
Bulk Send	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No
Audit Trail	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
HIPAA Compliant	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No
Envelope Cap	No cap	100 envelopes/user/year	Verify	Verify	Verify

Typical Timing and Deadlines in Procurement Cycles

Vendor selection timelines vary; set clear deadlines in the RFP and allow sufficient review time for complex submissions.

RFP Issue to Response Window:

Commonly 2–4 weeks depending on project complexity

Evaluation Period:

Allow 1–2 weeks for scoring and clarifications

Contract Negotiation:

Expect 1–4 weeks after award for terms finalization

W-9 / Tax Documents:

Provide W-9 upon request; needed before payments

Recordkeeping Start:

Retention begins at contract execution or final award date

Practical Tips for Accurate, Efficient Completion

Adopt consistent controls and templates to reduce rework and accelerate vendor evaluation.

Standardize Scoring and Weights

Use a preapproved scoring template with numeric weights and pass/fail thresholds. Train evaluators to apply criteria consistently and require written rationale for any deviations to maintain a defensible procurement record.

Require Current Documentation

Mandate current insurance certificates, active certification documents, and dated financial records. Stipulate minimum validity periods to avoid receiving expired credentials at bid time.

Use Digital Collection and Audit Trails

Collect forms electronically to capture timestamps, file versions, and signer metadata. Audit trails streamline review, support legal defensibility, and reduce administrative follow-ups for missing items.

Limit Sensitive Data Requests

Request only necessary personal data and protect it under access controls. For healthcare or financial contexts, document legal basis for processing and limit distribution to essential reviewers.

Frequently Asked Questions and Troubleshooting

Answers to common questions about using, signing, and storing the Vendor Selection Criteria Form.

Need help? Contact support

Can the form be signed electronically?
Yes. Electronic signatures are legally valid under the ESIGN Act (15 U.S.C. ch. 96) and UETA in most states, provided the signature shows intent, consent, attribution, and retention of the record.
Do vendor submissions need notarization?
Generally no for vendor selection forms. Notarization is rarely required unless the solicitation or state law specifies sworn affidavits or authenticated attestations for specific procurement types.
What if a vendor provides incomplete information?
Mark missing fields and request completion within a defined period. For public procurements, follow the solicitation rules on disqualification versus allowed clarifications to avoid protest risk.
How long should records be kept?
Retain completed forms per federal and industry rules: minimum 3 years for tax purposes (IRC §6501(a)), 6 years for HIPAA-related records (45 CFR §164.530(j)), or longer per contract or state law.
Who must sign the form on the vendor side?
An authorized officer or agent with authority to bind the vendor should sign. Document signatory authority and corporate title to prevent later disputes over contract validity.
Is additional authentication required for sensitive contracts?
Consider stronger signer authentication (multi-factor, ID credential analysis) for high-risk or regulated engagements, and retain proof of identity and consent in the audit trail.

be ready to get more

Join over 28 million airSlate SignNow users

Sign Now