Can this be signed electronically?

Yes. Electronic execution generally satisfies the ESIGN Act (15 U.S.C. ch. 96) and UETA when the signer shows intent, consents to electronic records, attribution is verifiable, and the record is retained in a reproducible form.

Is a notary required?

A notary is not commonly required for routine performance evaluations; however if the document is to be used in legal proceedings, or state or employer policy requires notarization, obtain a notary or remote online notarization per state rules.

What if signatures disagree?

If an employee disputes ratings or refuses to sign, document the discussion and have manager and HR note the refusal; unsigned reviews may still be kept with explanatory notes, but follow company policy and consult legal before adverse action.

How long should records be kept?

Retain evaluation sign offs for at least three years after termination to satisfy IRS and employment recordkeeping guidance; if records pertain to health information or potential litigation, retain for six years or longer per HIPAA and case requirements.

Can initials substitute for full signatures?

Initials alone are insufficient unless company policy explicitly allows them; best practice is a full signature and printed name to demonstrate intent and attribution for ESIGN/UETA compliance and to avoid later disputes.

How to correct errors after signing?

Do not edit the signed copy. Prepare an amendment or correction addendum signed by both parties, or complete a new evaluation referencing the original sign off; retain both versions and a changelog for audit.

Electronic Signature
Templates
HR
Employee Evaluation Sign Off

Employee Evaluation Sign Off

This template is fully customizable. Edit the text, fill out the fields, and send it for signature. Give it a try!

EMPLOYEE EVALUATION SIGN OFF

Personal Information

Full Legal Name Employee ID Address

Phone

Email

Position Information

Job Title Department Reporting Manager

Evaluation Period: From to Review Date:

Current Annual Salary

Evaluation Summary

Overall Performance Summary:

Overall Rating: Exceeds Expectations Meets Expectations Needs Improvement Unsatisfactory

Core Competencies and Ratings

For each competency, indicate the rating and provide comments where appropriate. Ratings: E = Exceeds, M = Meets, N = Needs Improvement, U = Unsatisfactory.

Quality of Work

E M N U

Communication & Teamwork

E M N U

Initiative & Problem Solving

E M N U

Goals and Development Plan

Short-term goals (next 3–6 months) and actions required to meet expectations.

Long-term development and training needs (6–24 months).

Employment History (for personnel record)

Employer 1

Company Name Job Title

From to

Key Responsibilities Reason for Leaving

Employer 2

Company Name Job Title

From to

Key Responsibilities Reason for Leaving

Education

Highest Degree or Certification Institution Graduation Date

References

Provide three professional references.

Reference 1 - Name Reference 1 - Phone Reference 1 - Email Reference 1 - Relationship Reference 2 - Name Reference 2 - Phone Reference 2 - Email Reference 2 - Relationship Reference 3 - Name Reference 3 - Phone Reference 3 - Email Reference 3 - Relationship

Legal Disclosures

At-Will Employment: Nothing in this evaluation changes the at-will employment relationship. Either the employee or the employer may terminate employment at any time, with or without cause or advance notice, unless a separate written agreement signed by an authorized company representative states otherwise.

Equal Employment Opportunity: The company prohibits unlawful discrimination and provides equal opportunity in all employment decisions. Performance evaluations are conducted without regard to protected characteristics and in accordance with company policy.

Employee Certification and Authorizations

I certify that I have reviewed this evaluation and that the information recorded herein is accurate to the best of my knowledge. My signature does not necessarily indicate agreement with all comments but acknowledges that the evaluation has been discussed with me.

Authorization to Contact Previous Employers and Conduct Background Checks: I authorize the employer to contact my previous employers and references, and to obtain employment-related information to the extent permitted by law. I further authorize background checks and verification of employment history where required by company policy.

Employee acknowledges: I have received and reviewed this evaluation.

Consent: I consent to the company conducting verification and background checks as described above.

Corrections or Employee Comments

If you disagree with any portion of this evaluation, you may provide written comments below. Comments will be attached to the evaluation as part of the official personnel record.

Employee Printed Name:

By:

Date:

Reviewer Printed Name:

By:

Date:

What the Employee Evaluation Sign Off Is

An Employee Evaluation Sign Off is a formal acknowledgment that an employee and reviewer have completed an evaluation document and agree on the recorded performance assessment, action items, and next steps. Typically appended to performance reviews, disciplinary evaluations, or development plans, the sign off documents names, dates, ratings, summary comments, and agreed follow-up activities. It creates a written record for HR, payroll, and legal compliance, and can be executed on paper or electronically using compliant eSignature platforms that meet ESIGN and UETA requirements.

Why a Signed Evaluation Matters

Use an Employee Evaluation Sign Off to document agreed performance outcomes, minimize disputes, and support personnel decisions. When executed electronically under the ESIGN Act (15 U.S.C. ch. 96) or UETA, the sign off is generally legally enforceable and reproducible for audits.

Who Completes and Keeps the Sign Off

Common users include HR professionals, direct managers, and employees completing or acknowledging performance reviews and development plans.

Human Resources — manages records, compliance, and retention scheduling for review documents.
Managers/Supervisors — complete evaluations, set goals, and approve final sign off entries.
Employees — acknowledge ratings, discuss corrective actions, and confirm understanding of expectations.

Larger organizations may include legal, payroll, or union representatives as signatories where policy or collective bargaining requires additional approvals.

Step-by-Step: Completing the Sign Off

Follow these steps to complete and record an Employee Evaluation Sign Off accurately, whether on paper or via an electronic signing platform.

01

Prepare Document: Attach evaluation and supporting notes.
02

Review With Employee: Discuss ratings, examples, and action items.
03

Obtain Signatures: Have employee and reviewer sign and date.
04

Save Record: Store final signed copy in HR file and system.

Key Elements Every Professional Sign Off Should Include

A professional Employee Evaluation Sign Off should be concise, auditable, and structured to record ratings, comments, signatures, and any corrective or developmental steps agreed by both parties.

Identification

Include employee legal name, employer name, job title, department, and unique employee or payroll identifier to ensure this sign off maps unambiguously to personnel and payroll records for audits and benefits administration.

Evaluation Period

Specify the exact date range covered by the appraisal, with MM/DD/YYYY start and end dates, so eligibility for raises, bonuses, and benefit changes can be determined without ambiguity during reviews.

Ratings & Comments

Provide numerical or categorical ratings accompanied by objective examples and concise manager commentary; separate factual observations from subjective opinion to reduce dispute risk.

Action Plan

Record specific development goals, timelines, responsible parties, and measurable success criteria so follow-up meetings and performance improvement tracking are enforceable and verifiable.

Signatures

Include printed name, signature, title, and date for the reviewer and employee; note that initials or unchecked fields may invalidate acknowledgments in HR processes.

Audit Trail

For electronic workflows, retain metadata such as signer email, IP address, timestamps, and version history to support compliance, internal audits, and legal defensibility.

Security and Compliance Considerations

Encryption: TLS 1.2/1.3 in transit; AES-256 at rest

Certifications: SOC 2 Type II; ISO 27001; PCI DSS

HIPAA: BAA available; HIPAA-compliant workflows

21 CFR Part 11: Supports FDA audit requirements

ESIGN & UETA: Compliant with U.S. electronic signature laws

Accessibility: WCAG 2.0 Level AA support

Common Preparation Pitfalls to Avoid

Incomplete fields or inconsistent dates cause payroll or benefits delays and can trigger rework or disciplinary disputes when records do not align with personnel files.
Using nonstandard rating scales or uncategorized comments increases ambiguity and makes cross-employee comparisons and legal defenses more difficult.
Failing to record agreed action items with owners and deadlines undermines follow-up and weakens performance improvement plans.
Relying on unsigned printouts or unsigned electronic copies can nullify the acknowledgment and impede disciplinary or termination processes.

Risks and Consequences of Incorrect Sign Offs

Dispute Risk: Challenges to termination or discipline

Recordkeeping Penalties: Violations of retention rules

Benefits Errors: Incorrect payroll or benefits decisions

Union Grievances: Contract disputes and arbitration claims

I-9 Noncompliance: Potential DHS fines for paperwork errors

Privacy Breach: HIPAA or data-protection incidents

How the Electronic Sign Off Workflow Typically Flows

Typical routing for an Employee Evaluation Sign Off moves from manager drafting to employee review, signature, and final HR filing; electronic platforms automate these steps.

Upload: Attach completed evaluation and evidence files.
Assign Signers: Add manager and employee email addresses for signing.
Authenticate: Choose signer verification (email, SMS, KBA) as needed.
Store: Save signed PDF with audit trail metadata.

Configuring an Electronic Sign Off Workflow

Configure an eSigning workflow to capture signatures, authenticate signers, and route final copies to HR and payroll systems.

Field	Configuration
Signature Type	Electronic signature with audit trail
Authentication	Email link or SMS code; KBA optional
Routing	Sequential approval: manager then employee then HR
Storage	Save to HRIS and cloud storage (PDF)

Platform Capabilities to Look For

Select a signing platform that supports secure storage, audit trails, and integration with HR and document management systems.

File Formats: Supports PDF, DOCX, HTML, Excel
Integrations: Works with HRIS, Google Workspace, NetSuite
APIs & SSO: API access and SAML single sign-on

Typical Timelines and Deadlines for Sign Offs

Timelines for completing sign offs vary by policy; set deadlines and reminders to ensure evaluations are signed within the review cycle.

Annual Reviews Deadline:

Typically within 30 days of review period end

Probationary Review:

Complete sign off before end of probationary period

Corrective Action:

Sign off at issuance and after completion of actions

Promotion Effective Date:

Signatures must reflect the effective promotion date

Record Retention Start:

Retention clock begins on the signature date

Pricing and Feature Comparison: Common eSignature Providers

Comparison of common eSignature plans useful when selecting a platform to execute Employee Evaluation Sign Off documents securely and compliantly.

	signNow	DocuSign	Adobe Sign	PandaDoc	HelloSign
Starting Price	$8/user/mo	$15/user/mo	$14/user/mo	$19/user/mo	$15/user/mo
Free Trial	7-day free trial	Varies	Varies	Varies	Varies
Bulk Send	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No
Audit Trail	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
HIPAA Compliant	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No

Frequently Asked Questions About Employee Evaluation Sign Offs

Answers to common questions about completing, signing, and storing Employee Evaluation Sign Offs, including electronic signature and retention concerns.

Need help? Contact support

Can this be signed electronically?
Yes. Electronic execution generally satisfies the ESIGN Act (15 U.S.C. ch. 96) and UETA when the signer shows intent, consents to electronic records, attribution is verifiable, and the record is retained in a reproducible form.
Is a notary required?
A notary is not commonly required for routine performance evaluations; however if the document is to be used in legal proceedings, or state or employer policy requires notarization, obtain a notary or remote online notarization per state rules.
What if signatures disagree?
If an employee disputes ratings or refuses to sign, document the discussion and have manager and HR note the refusal; unsigned reviews may still be kept with explanatory notes, but follow company policy and consult legal before adverse action.
How long should records be kept?
Retain evaluation sign offs for at least three years after termination to satisfy IRS and employment recordkeeping guidance; if records pertain to health information or potential litigation, retain for six years or longer per HIPAA and case requirements.
Can initials substitute for full signatures?
Initials alone are insufficient unless company policy explicitly allows them; best practice is a full signature and printed name to demonstrate intent and attribution for ESIGN/UETA compliance and to avoid later disputes.
How to correct errors after signing?
Do not edit the signed copy. Prepare an amendment or correction addendum signed by both parties, or complete a new evaluation referencing the original sign off; retain both versions and a changelog for audit.

be ready to get more

Join over 28 million airSlate SignNow users

Sign Now