Can an employee sign a review electronically?

Yes. Electronic signatures are legally binding in most employment contexts when the signer demonstrates intent, consents to electronic records, the signature is attributable, and the record can be retained and reproduced. Follow your company’s consumer-disclosure procedures where required.

Is manager signature required to finalize?

Best practice is to obtain both manager and employee signatures. Manager signature documents approval of ratings; employee signature records receipt and acknowledgement, even if the employee disagrees.

How long must reviews be retained?

Retention varies by purpose: maintain active employment records for the employment term plus at least three years; longer periods may apply for tax, HIPAA, or state-specific rules.

What if an employee refuses to sign?

Document the refusal in the record, include the manager’s notes, and proceed to archive the signed manager copy. Provide an employee copy noting refusal and follow internal dispute procedures.

Can reviews include sensitive health information?

Avoid including protected health information unless strictly necessary and permitted. If PHI is included, ensure HIPAA safeguards and a Business Associate Agreement with any vendor that processes PHI.

How to correct an error after signing?

Document any agreed changes in a supplemental amendment or corrected form, obtain fresh signatures from involved parties, and preserve both the original and the corrected records for audit purposes.

Electronic Signature
Templates
HR
Employee Performance Review Feedback

Employee Performance Review Feedback

This template is fully customizable. Edit the text, fill out the fields, and send it for signature. Give it a try!

EMPLOYEE PERFORMANCE REVIEW FEEDBACK

Personal Information

Full Name Address

Phone:

Email:

Position Information

Job Title Department Reporting Manager

Start Date:

Current Salary / Pay Rate

Review Period

Review Period From to .

Employee Self-Assessment

Summary of accomplishments during review period Key challenges or obstacles

Core Competencies and Ratings

For each competency provide a numeric rating (1 = Unsatisfactory, 5 = Exceptional) and supporting comments.

Quality of Work — Rating

Rating:

Productivity & Time Management — Rating

Rating:

Teamwork & Communication — Rating

Rating:

Reviewer Assessment

Reviewer Comments and Examples Overall Performance Rating

Rating:

Goals and Development Plan

Goals for next review period Training and development actions

Target completion date for development plan:

Performance Improvement Plan (PIP)

PIP required based on this review.

If PIP is required, describe objectives, metrics, and timeline

Employment History (for HR record)

Employer 1 — Company:

Title: Dates:

Responsibilities Reason for leaving

Employer 2 — Company:

Title: Dates:

Responsibilities Reason for leaving

Education

Highest Degree Institution

Graduation Date:

References (for HR record)

Reference 1 — Name

Phone: Email:

Relationship Reference 2 — Name

Phone: Email:

Relationship Reference 3 — Name

Phone: Email:

Relationship

Legal and Administrative Acknowledgments

At-Will Employment: Employee acknowledges that employment relationship is at-will, meaning either the employee or employer may terminate employment at any time, with or without cause or notice, unless otherwise agreed in a written employment agreement signed by an authorized company representative.

Equal Opportunity: The employer affirms a commitment to equal employment opportunity and prohibits discrimination or harassment based on protected characteristics. Performance assessments will be applied without unlawful discrimination.

Background and References Authorization: By acknowledging below, the employee authorizes the employer to contact prior employers and references and to conduct employment-related background screening consistent with applicable law.

I authorize contact of previous employers and references and any background checks permitted by law.

Employee Certification

I certify that, to the best of my knowledge, the information I have provided in this performance review and associated HR records is true, accurate, and complete. I understand that my signature indicates I have received and reviewed this document and that signing does not necessarily indicate agreement with all comments. I may provide a written response to be included in my personnel file.

Employee comments in response to review (optional):

Employee Name:

By:

Date:

Reviewer/Manager Name:

By:

Date:

What the Employee Performance Review Feedback Is

The Employee Performance Review Feedback is a formal record used by employers to evaluate an employee’s work, competencies, goals, development needs, and accomplishments during a defined review period. It typically combines quantitative ratings, manager comments, employee self-assessment, and agreed development plans to document performance outcomes. Organizations use these records for compensation, promotion decisions, training plans, and compliance with internal policies. When both parties consent, reviews may be created, shared, and stored electronically using compliant eSignature and records-management tools under applicable federal and state law.

Why a Structured Feedback Form Helps

A clear feedback form creates a consistent record, reduces ambiguity in performance discussions, and supports fair, documented decision-making around raises, promotions, and corrective action. It also helps track goals over time and provides evidence of reasonable business decisions when HR or legal review is required.

Who Prepares and Receives Performance Review Feedback

Typical participants and custodians involved in performance reviews are listed below.

Managers and supervisors responsible for assessing direct reports, documenting ratings, and creating development plans for employees.
Human resources teams that administer review cycles, ensure policy compliance, and retain records in personnel files.
Employees who complete self-assessments, acknowledge feedback, and collaborate on goal-setting and development plans.

Roles vary by company size and structure; some organizations use multi-rater inputs or HR-administered templates for consistency.

Core Elements of a Professional Feedback Form

Well-designed performance review feedback includes standardized sections that allow consistent scoring, narrative context, development actions, and an audit trail of acknowledgements and sign-offs.

Identification

Employee name, job title, department, manager name, and review period. Consistent identifiers prevent file mismatches and enable correct record linkage.

Ratings

Numeric or categorical ratings for job duties and competencies. Use defined scales and rubric descriptors to reduce rater variance and support calibration.

Narrative Comments

Manager observations and employee self-assessment. Concise examples of behaviors and outcomes help make ratings actionable and defensible.

Development Plan

Agreed actions, training, and measurable goals with target dates. Specificity increases follow-through and provides a basis for future reviews.

Signatures

Manager and employee acknowledgement lines and dates. Signed records show receipt of feedback and acceptance of next steps.

Audit Trail

Record of edits, timestamps, and signatory authentication. An audit trail supports integrity, dispute resolution, and regulatory compliance.

Essential Data to Collect

Employee ID: Unique personnel identifier

Review Period: Start and end dates

Job Title: Current role name

Manager Name: Reviewer identity

Signatures: Signed and dated

Action Items: Goals and deadlines

Simple Sequence to Complete a Review

Follow these steps to produce a clear, consistent performance review that can be retained in the employee file.

01

Prepare document: Load template and confirm review period.
02

Complete ratings: Apply rubric and add examples.
03

Discuss with employee: Hold review meeting and record agreed changes.
04

Sign and store: Obtain signatures and save to HR record.

How to Configure an Online Review Workflow

Set up roles, required fields, and routing in your document platform to automate distribution and retention.

Field	Configuration
Signature fields	Require manager and employee signatures in order
Conditional routing	Route to HR if rating below threshold
Notifications	Email reminders at set intervals
Retention policy	Auto-save to personnel file with metadata

Where Completed Reviews Are Sent

Decide a canonical destination for finalized reviews to ensure consistent filing and access controls.

HR personnel file: Primary archival location for signed records
Manager records: Copies stored with supervisory documentation
Employee copy: Provide a read-only signed copy to the employee
Compliance archive: Store records for retention and audit

Technical and Compliance Considerations for eSubmission

Choose a platform that supports secure storage, access controls, and an immutable audit trail for employee records.

Encryption: AES-256 at rest
Authentication: Multi-factor options
Audit logs: Detailed timestamps

Where healthcare, education, or regulated records are involved, require a platform that supports applicable controls (for example, HIPAA, FERPA, or audit-grade retention) and a documented Business Associate Agreement when necessary.

Typical Timelines and Deadlines to Track

Maintain a schedule for review distribution, completion, and appeals to ensure timely outcomes and compliance with internal policies.

Annual review scheduling and notification window:

Publish dates and notify employees at least 30 days before reviews begin.

Mid-year check-in deadline:

Set a mid-point meeting within the review cycle, typically six months.

Manager submission deadline:

Require completed manager inputs within two weeks of meeting.

Employee acknowledgement period:

Allow 7–14 days for employee review and signature.

Appeal or HR review timeframe:

Provide a 30-day window to submit concerns to HR.

Common Mistakes to Avoid When Preparing Reviews

Using inconsistent rating scales across teams, which undermines comparability and can trigger disputes during calibration sessions.
Relying on vague narratives rather than specific examples, reducing the utility of feedback for development and risk mitigation.
Failing to secure signatures or consent for electronic records, which can create questions about authenticity in later reviews.
Not aligning development actions with measurable deadlines, resulting in untracked promises and ineffective follow-up.

Risks of Incomplete or Incorrect Reviews

Discrimination risk: Inaccurate records

Compensation disputes: Pay decision challenges

Regulatory exposure: Industry penalties

Legal evidence gaps: Weak documentation

Employee morale: Reduced engagement

Record integrity: Unauthorized edits

Real-world Examples of Digital Review Workflows

Organizations across sizes use electronic workflows to collect, sign, and archive performance reviews with fewer delays and clearer records.

Optica Ventures — COO

A small investment firm centralized reviews to reduce turnaround and ensure consistency across teams.

Managers completed reviews online within the scheduled window.
"The interface is simple and easy-to-use for our team; more importantly, it is just as easy for our customers."

Xerox — NetSuite Ops

An enterprise integrated review templates with HR systems to populate job and manager data automatically.

Automation reduced administrative work and errors.
"airSlate SignNow provides us with the flexibility needed to get the right signatures on the right documents, in the right formats, based on our integration with NetSuite."

Who Typically Signs or Approves Reviews

Jane Doe HR Manager

HR managers finalize template settings, confirm policy alignment, and often receive the signed review into the personnel file. They coordinate calibration meetings and retain the official copy for compliance and audit purposes.

Carlos Ruiz Department Head

Department heads review manager ratings, approve final performance decisions that affect promotion or compensation, and attest to the accuracy of documented outcomes before HR archives the record.

How Review Feedback Differs from Improvement Plans

Compare the feedback form to a performance improvement plan to choose the correct document when performance issues arise.

Criteria	Review Feedback	Performance Improvement Plan
Formal purpose	document performance	address specific deficiencies
Typical timing	routine cycle	triggered by concerns
Required fields	ratings and goals	specific corrective actions
Outcomes	development and promotion	corrective measures or termination

eSignature Platform Pricing and Feature Snapshot

Comparison of typical starting prices and selected features for common eSignature providers; signNow appears first per product listing conventions.

	signNow	DocuSign	Adobe Sign	PandaDoc	HelloSign
Starting Price	$8/user/mo	$15/user/mo	$14/user/mo	$19/user/mo	$15/user/mo
Free Trial	7-day free trial	No	No	Yes, limited	Yes, limited
Bulk Send	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	No
Audit Trail	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
HIPAA Compliant	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No

Frequently Asked Questions About Performance Review Feedback

Answers to common questions about format, electronic signatures, retention, and data privacy for performance reviews.

Need help? Contact support

Can an employee sign a review electronically?
Yes. Electronic signatures are legally binding in most employment contexts when the signer demonstrates intent, consents to electronic records, the signature is attributable, and the record can be retained and reproduced. Follow your company’s consumer-disclosure procedures where required.
Is manager signature required to finalize?
Best practice is to obtain both manager and employee signatures. Manager signature documents approval of ratings; employee signature records receipt and acknowledgement, even if the employee disagrees.
How long must reviews be retained?
Retention varies by purpose: maintain active employment records for the employment term plus at least three years; longer periods may apply for tax, HIPAA, or state-specific rules.
What if an employee refuses to sign?
Document the refusal in the record, include the manager’s notes, and proceed to archive the signed manager copy. Provide an employee copy noting refusal and follow internal dispute procedures.
Can reviews include sensitive health information?
Avoid including protected health information unless strictly necessary and permitted. If PHI is included, ensure HIPAA safeguards and a Business Associate Agreement with any vendor that processes PHI.
How to correct an error after signing?
Document any agreed changes in a supplemental amendment or corrected form, obtain fresh signatures from involved parties, and preserve both the original and the corrected records for audit purposes.

be ready to get more

Join over 28 million airSlate SignNow users

Sign Now