Can an employee e-sign the review?

Yes. Electronic signatures on internal HR documents are enforceable under the ESIGN Act (15 U.S.C. ch. 96) and UETA in most states when the four legal validity conditions are met: intent, consent, attribution, and retention. Confirm PHI handling meets HIPAA requirements.

Is a handwritten signature required for validity?

No. Handwritten signatures are not required for validity under ESIGN/UETA. Provide evidence of signer identity and intent via secure authentication, audit trail, and retained record. Use stronger authentication for sensitive personnel actions or where company policy mandates wet signatures.

How long must performance reviews be retained?

Retain according to applicable federal and state standards: keep current reports during employment, retain personnel files at least three years to align with IRS guidance (IRC §6501), and six years if records reference PHI per HIPAA (45 CFR §164.530(j)). Check state law for extensions.

What happens if an employee disputes their review?

Document the dispute in writing, include the employee’s comments in the file, and record any agreed corrective steps. Maintain signed copies and audit logs to support HR decisions. Consult legal counsel for grievances that may lead to arbitration or litigation.

Can HR restrict access to employee reviews?

Yes. Limit access through role-based permissions and secure storage to comply with privacy obligations, FERPA or HIPAA where applicable, and internal policies. Log access events in the audit trail and review permissions periodically to reduce unauthorized disclosure risks.

How can e-signature authenticity be verified?

Use multi-factor authentication, audit logs with timestamps and IP addresses, and signer attribution methods like email verification or ID checks. For high-assurance needs, use PKI-based digital signatures or advanced signer authentication consistent with 21 CFR Part 11 if regulated by FDA.

Electronic Signature
Templates
HR
Employee Performance Review Report

Employee Performance Review Report

This template is fully customizable. Edit the text, fill out the fields, and send it for signature. Give it a try!

EMPLOYEE PERFORMANCE REVIEW REPORT

Personal Information

Employee Full Name

Employee ID

Phone

Email

Address

Position & Review Details

Job Title:

Department:

Reporting Manager:

Hire Date:

Review Period: From to

Review Date:

Performance Competencies & Ratings

Instructions: Rate each competency on a 1–5 scale where 1 = Unsatisfactory, 3 = Meets Expectations, 5 = Exceptional. Provide supporting evidence in comments.

Communication (written and verbal)

Teamwork & Collaboration

Quality of Work / Accuracy

Initiative & Problem Solving

Leadership / Supervisory (if applicable)

Goals & Achievements (Prior Period)

List prior goals, status, and measurable results.

Goal 1 Goal 2

Development Plan & Training

Overall Rating & Manager Summary

Overall Rating (1-5):

Manager Summary

Employee Comments

Objectives for Next Review Period

Employment History (Minimum two prior employers)

Prior Employer 1 — Company Name

Dates Employed: From To

Responsibilities Reason for Leaving Prior Employer 2 — Company Name

Dates Employed: From To

Responsibilities Reason for Leaving

Education

Highest Degree Institution Graduation Date

Professional References (3)

Reference 1 — Name Reference 2 — Name Reference 3 — Name

Legal Disclosures & Acknowledgements

At-Will Employment: The contents of this performance review are evaluative and administrative. Nothing contained herein alters the at-will employment relationship between the employer and the employee, nor creates an express or implied contract of continued employment.

Equal Employment Opportunity: The employer is committed to equal opportunity in employment. Evaluations and any employment actions will be administered without regard to protected characteristics prohibited by applicable law.

Confidentiality: This performance review contains confidential personnel information. Distribution is limited to the employee, the reviewer, and designated HR representatives. The employee acknowledges that discussion of performance matters is a protected confidentiality process of the employer.

Applicant / Employee Certification and Authorizations

I certify that the information provided in this document (including employment history and references) is true and complete to the best of my knowledge. I authorize the employer to contact prior employers and the references listed above for verification and background check purposes as necessary for employment administration.

I authorize contact with prior employers and consent to employment-related background checks and reference verification. I acknowledge receipt of this review and understand its contents; I have had the opportunity to discuss this review with my manager.

Administrative Use

HR Notes (actions taken, pay adjustments, disciplinary notes):

Employee Name:

By:

Date:

Reviewer Name:

By:

Date:

What the Employee Performance Review Report Is

The Employee Performance Review Report documents an employee’s job performance over a defined period, summarizing goals, accomplishments, competencies, and areas for development. It typically includes quantitative ratings, manager commentary, self-assessment excerpts, and agreed action plans or training recommendations. Organizations use this record for pay decisions, promotions, performance improvement plans, and legal defensibility. When completed accurately, the report supports objective evaluations, documents counseling or disciplinary steps, and creates a clear timeline of expectations. The format varies by employer but should balance measurable metrics with qualitative observations to guide future performance.

Why a Well-Prepared Report Matters

A well-constructed Employee Performance Review Report clarifies expectations, documents achievements and gaps, and provides evidence for compensation and staffing decisions. It reduces subjective bias, supports legal compliance, and creates a documented basis for performance improvement or disciplinary action.

Who Uses the Employee Performance Review Report

Common users include HR professionals, hiring managers, department heads, and employees participating in performance cycles.

HR administrators: manage schedules, compile reports, ensure documentation and compliance.
Managers: provide ratings, narrative feedback, and develop actionable improvement plans with staff.
Employees: complete self-assessments, review feedback, and agree on developmental goals.

Use the report for annual reviews, mid-year check-ins, performance improvement plans, and documentation for HR records.

Core Elements Every Report Should Contain

Essential components ensure clarity, comparability, objective scoring, and a defensible record for personnel decisions, talent development, and regulatory or legal review.

Identification

Employee name, job title, department, manager, review period dates, employee ID, and employment status to uniquely identify the subject and link the report to payroll and HR records.

Performance Ratings

A standardized rating scale for key competencies and objectives, with numeric or descriptive scores, supporting aggregated analysis and consistent comparisons across teams or periods and calibration.

Manager Feedback

Concise narrative detailing strengths, areas for improvement, examples of behavior, prior commitments, and recommended actions tied to measurable outcomes or timelines for follow-up and accountability.

Employee Input

Self-assessment section capturing employee achievements, barriers encountered, development interests, and agreement or commentary on manager observations and goals, including evidence or metrics where available and suggested training or resources.

Goals & Plan

Documented SMART objectives, target dates, success measures, required training, and owner assignments to track progress and inform future reviews or promotion decisions, with review checkpoints and escalation steps.

Signatures

Signature lines for employee, reviewer, and HR representative with dates, affirming review completion, acknowledgement of feedback, and acceptance or documented disagreement where applicable to maintain audit trail.

Required Identifying Data and Fields

Employee ID: Unique HR identifier matching payroll.

Review Period: Start and end dates MM/DD/YYYY.

Job Title: Official position title on file.

Ratings Scale: Scale definition (numeric or label).

Manager Name: Full name and contact email.

Signatures: Signed by employee, manager, HR.

Step-by-Step: Completing the Report

Follow these steps to complete an accurate, fair Employee Performance Review Report and preserve a clear audit trail.

01

Prepare: Gather goals, job description, prior reports, and performance data.
02

Self-Review: Have employee submit self-assessment before meeting.
03

Manager Review: Manager completes ratings and writes evidence-based comments.
04

Sign & File: Both parties sign, date, and route copy to HR.

How to Configure an Online Review Workflow

Configure an online review workflow to auto-route forms, enforce fields, and preserve an immutable audit trail for each signed report.

Workflow Setting (field name and purpose)	Configuration
Reviewer sequential approval order setting	Sequential approval routing
Required fields enforcement and validation	Mark ratings, sign, and date required
Authentication methods and options available	Email + optional SMS code
Reminder schedule and cadence settings	Schedule automated email reminders
Storage location and retention policy	Save PDF and metadata to HR folder

Typical eSubmission Flow for Completed Reports

Typical e-submission flow for completed reports, from authoring to signing, delivery to HR, and archival.

Upload: Upload the report template or DOCX to the platform.
Place Fields: Add signature, date, and required data fields.
Send: Send to signers with authentication settings.
Archive: Store signed PDF and audit trail in HR system.

Platform and File Requirements for eCompletion

Technical integrations and file format requirements when completing Employee Performance Review Reports electronically, including HRIS connections and secure storage.

Formats: PDF and Microsoft Word DOCX supported.
Integrations: Connects with HRIS and cloud storage.
Authentication: Supports email, SMS, and SSO.

Timing Considerations and Recurring Deadlines

Key timing for issuing, completing, and storing Employee Performance Review Reports to meet organizational and legal recordkeeping expectations.

Annual performance review window each fiscal year:

Typically scheduled within a defined calendar or fiscal period; varies by employer.

Mid-year checkpoint or progress review meeting:

Used for course correction, goal updates, and informal feedback documentation.

Final sign-off and HR filing:

Managers and employees both sign; HR receives final copy for personnel file.

Performance-based pay effective date:

Salary changes or bonus eligibility dates should be recorded and linked to report outcomes.

Retention and access review schedule:

Review retention annually to comply with IRS, HIPAA, or company policies.

Common Preparation Pitfalls to Avoid

Using vague language for expectations can create disputes; quantify objectives and include measurable success criteria tied to dates or metrics.
Failing to retain signed copies or audit logs weakens legal defensibility and may violate recordkeeping obligations under IRS or HIPAA rules.
Relying solely on handwritten notes without updating the formal report leads to inconsistent records and employee confusion during reviews or appeals.
Neglecting to document employee objections or disputes at the time of sign-off can complicate later grievance or arbitration proceedings.

Risks and Consequences of Incomplete Reports

Disciplinary exposure: Incomplete records increase risk.

Compensation disputes: Unclear evidence may invite claims.

Regulatory noncompliance: Missing retention violates rules.

Legal discovery burden: Poor documentation raises costs.

Employee relations harm: Trust and morale decline.

Audit findings: HR audits can require remedial action.

eSignature Pricing and Compliance Comparison

Compare core pricing and compliance features across common eSignature providers to inform platform selection for Employee Performance Review Report workflows.

	signNow	DocuSign	Adobe Sign	PandaDoc	HelloSign
Starting Price	$8/user/mo	$15/user/mo	$14/user/mo	$19/user/mo	$15/user/mo
Free Trial	7-day free trial	Varies by plan	Varies by plan	Varies by plan	Varies by plan
Bulk Send	Yes (Business Premium)	Varies by plan	Varies by plan	Varies by plan	Varies by plan
Audit Trail	Yes	Varies by plan	Varies by plan	Varies by plan	Varies by plan
HIPAA Compliant	Yes (BAA available)	Varies by plan	Varies by plan	Varies by plan	Varies by plan
Envelope Cap	No envelope cap	100 envelopes/user/year	Varies by plan	Varies by plan	Varies by plan

Frequently Asked Questions

Answers to frequent questions about completing, signing, and storing Employee Performance Review Reports, including eSignature and compliance issues.

Need help? Contact support

Can an employee e-sign the review?
Yes. Electronic signatures on internal HR documents are enforceable under the ESIGN Act (15 U.S.C. ch. 96) and UETA in most states when the four legal validity conditions are met: intent, consent, attribution, and retention. Confirm PHI handling meets HIPAA requirements.
Is a handwritten signature required for validity?
No. Handwritten signatures are not required for validity under ESIGN/UETA. Provide evidence of signer identity and intent via secure authentication, audit trail, and retained record. Use stronger authentication for sensitive personnel actions or where company policy mandates wet signatures.
How long must performance reviews be retained?
Retain according to applicable federal and state standards: keep current reports during employment, retain personnel files at least three years to align with IRS guidance (IRC §6501), and six years if records reference PHI per HIPAA (45 CFR §164.530(j)). Check state law for extensions.
What happens if an employee disputes their review?
Document the dispute in writing, include the employee’s comments in the file, and record any agreed corrective steps. Maintain signed copies and audit logs to support HR decisions. Consult legal counsel for grievances that may lead to arbitration or litigation.
Can HR restrict access to employee reviews?
Yes. Limit access through role-based permissions and secure storage to comply with privacy obligations, FERPA or HIPAA where applicable, and internal policies. Log access events in the audit trail and review permissions periodically to reduce unauthorized disclosure risks.
How can e-signature authenticity be verified?
Use multi-factor authentication, audit logs with timestamps and IP addresses, and signer attribution methods like email verification or ID checks. For high-assurance needs, use PKI-based digital signatures or advanced signer authentication consistent with 21 CFR Part 11 if regulated by FDA.

be ready to get more

Join over 28 million airSlate SignNow users

Sign Now