How do I confirm the referee's identity

Ask the referee to sign via a verified email and provide a business phone number; follow up by calling the provided number. For sensitive roles, use SMS code or knowledge-based authentication to strengthen identity evidence.

Can the report be e-signed legally

Yes. Electronic signatures meet ESIGN (15 U.S.C. ch. 96) and UETA standards for most transactions. Avoid e-signature for categories expressly excluded from ESIGN such as wills or certain court filings.

What if the referee refuses to sign

Collect a written, dated statement of refusal and document attempts to obtain a signed report. Consider alternative verification such as HR records or publicly available employment confirmations.

Can PHI be included in the report

Minimize PHI. If health information is necessary, ensure a Business Associate Agreement (BAA) is in place and retain records in a HIPAA-compliant environment with restricted access.

How long should we keep reports

Retain applicant and referee reports per retention policy that satisfies IRS and industry rules: typically at least 3 years after final action; HIPAA-related items require 6 years where applicable.

Is notarization ever required

Most referee reports do not require notarization. If a role demands certified statements or the organization policy requires notarized attestations, follow state notary rules or remote notarization processes where permitted.

Electronic Signature
Templates
HR
HR Referee Report

HR Referee Report

This template is fully customizable. Edit the text, fill out the fields, and send it for signature. Give it a try!

HR REFEREE REPORT

Purpose: This Referee Report is intended to provide an independent verification of the candidate's employment history, performance, and suitability for the position identified below. The information supplied will be relied upon in making hiring decisions and will be treated as confidential to the extent permitted by law.

Candidate Information

Candidate Name:

Candidate Contact / Address

Phone:

Email:

Position Information (Position the candidate applied for)

Position Title Department / Reporting Manager

Proposed Start Date Proposed Salary

Employment History (Verification)

Please confirm the candidate's employment details for the positions you held with or observed the candidate in.

Employer 1 — Company Name

Title:

From:

To:

Primary Responsibilities / Duties Reason for Leaving / Termination Circumstances Employer 2 — Company Name

Title:

From:

To:

Primary Responsibilities / Duties Reason for Leaving / Termination Circumstances

Education (as known to referee)

Highest Degree / Qualification Institution Graduation / Completion Date

Additional References (provided by referee)

Reference 1 — Name

Phone:

Email:

Relationship:

Reference 2 — Name

Phone:

Email:

Relationship:

Reference 3 — Name

Phone:

Email:

Relationship:

Referee Details and Relationship to Candidate

Referee Full Name Referee Position / Title Organisation / Employer

Work Phone:

Work Email:

Business Address Relationship to Candidate & Duration

Performance Evaluation (Please assess the candidate based on your direct knowledge)

Use the following scale: Outstanding, Above Average, Satisfactory, Below Average, Unsatisfactory. If you have no basis to judge, select "Not Applicable."

Work Quality / Job Knowledge

Technical Skills / Competence

Teamwork / Interpersonal Skills

Reliability / Punctuality

Initiative / Problem Solving

Overall Recommendation Detailed Comments on Performance, Strengths and Areas for Development

Employment Conduct and Eligibility

Was the candidate subject to any formal disciplinary action while employed with your organisation? Yes No

If yes, please provide dates and brief description

Is the candidate eligible for rehire at your organisation? Yes No Unknown

If not eligible, please explain

Legal Statements, Consent and Certification

Confidentiality Notice: The information you provide is given in confidence for recruitment purposes. By completing this form you acknowledge you are authorized by your employer to provide this information and consent to its use by the requesting organisation for recruitment and employment screening.

Certification: I certify that the information provided on this form is true and accurate to the best of my knowledge. I understand that providing false or misleading information may expose me to legal liability. I confirm that I have obtained any necessary consent from the candidate to disclose the information provided in this report where required by law.

Referee Attestation (check to confirm)

I confirm my identity and authorised role to provide this report.
I confirm the candidate has given consent for this referee contact and disclosure.

Additional Information

Is there any other information we should consider regarding the candidate's suitability for the role?

At-Will and Equal Opportunity Statements: Completion of this report does not alter any at-will employment relationship nor does it substitute statutory obligations. The requesting organisation is an equal opportunity employer and will make employment decisions without unlawful discrimination.

Referee Printed Name:

Signature:

Date:

What the HR Referee Report Is and when it's used

An HR Referee Report is a structured employment reference completed by a referee (former manager, HR representative, or colleague) that documents a candidate's job performance, responsibilities, attendance, disciplinary history, and suitability for a role. Organizations use it as part of pre-employment screening, internal promotions, or due diligence for regulated positions. The report records factual observations, dates, and verifier contact details and is often retained in the applicant file to support hiring decisions and compliance with internal hiring policies.

Why a formal HR Referee Report matters

A standardized referee report improves hiring quality and auditability by capturing consistent, verifiable information about past performance, role fit, and potential risks. It reduces bias, creates a documented chain of custody for reference data, and supports defensible hiring decisions in regulated or high-risk roles.

Who completes and who reviews these reports

Typical participants include referees who supply the report, HR specialists who request and review it, and hiring managers who use the information to make decisions.

Referee: direct manager or HR partner who can verify dates of employment and duties.
HR Reviewer: talent acquisition or HR operations staff who evaluate completeness and compliance.
Hiring Manager: the decision-maker using the referee's observations to assess fit.

In regulated industries, compliance or legal teams may also review reports for issues related to background checks, licensing, or patient/client safety.

Primary signatories for the report

Referee — Title

The referee should be the most senior person who directly supervised the candidate or an HR representative who maintained employment records. The narrative must reflect first-hand knowledge, and the contact information provided should enable verification if the hiring organization needs clarification.

HR Reviewer — Title

An HR reviewer or recruiter certifies that the report was requested and received through proper channels. That person should confirm document integrity and that any consent requirements (where applicable) were met before using the report in hiring decisions.

Core elements to include in a professional HR Referee Report

A complete report balances objective facts and measured observations. Use clear fields, consistent date formats, and concise answer options to make the report machine-readable and auditable while preserving context for human reviewers.

Employment dates

Exact start and end dates in MM/DD/YYYY format to verify tenure and eligibility.

Job title and duties

Primary role, key responsibilities, and any significant projects or supervisory duties.

Performance summary

Objective ratings and short narrative on quality of work, reliability, and strengths.

Attendance and disciplinary history

Documented absences, warnings, or disciplinary actions with dates and outcomes.

Reason for leaving

Voluntary, involuntary, or position elimination with neutral, factual wording.

Referee contact and verification

Referee name, job title, employer, phone and email for follow-up verification.

Required data fields and format notes

Candidate Name: Full legal name

Dates of Employment: MM/DD/YYYY

Referee Name: Full name

Referee Contact: Phone and business email

Role/Title: Official job title

Verification Method: Phone call or written

Step-by-step: filling and submitting an HR Referee Report

Follow these steps to complete the report accurately, whether on paper or in an electronic workflow. Each step ensures the report is verifiable and complies with common hiring policies.

01

Request: Send standard request with candidate consent
02

Complete: Referee fills fields and signs
03

Verify: HR confirms referee identity and responses
04

Store: Save report in applicant file with retention tags

Configuring an online referee report workflow

Set up clear stages and authentication requirements in your digital workflow to protect data integrity and reduce signer friction.

Field	Configuration
Authentication	Email link or SMS code
Required Fields	Name, dates, contact, narrative
Conditional Logic	Show disciplinary questions only if flagged
Retention Tag	Assign HR file category and retention period

Where to send and how the report flows

A clear routing path ensures the report reaches the right reviewers and is archived correctly for compliance and audits.

Request Origin: Hiring manager or recruiter
Referee Action: Completes and signs report
HR Review: Verifies details and flags issues
Archive: Store in applicant record

Digital signing and integration considerations

Choose a platform that supports secure e-signing, audit trails, and easy export to HR systems.

Document formats: PDF, DOCX supported
Integrations: HRIS, ATS, cloud storage
Authentication: Email, SMS, KBA optional

Ensure the provider supports required compliance standards (ESIGN/UETA, HIPAA if health data included) and preserves an auditable record of the signing event.

Timelines and typical processing expectations

Understand common timing expectations to manage candidate experience and reduce hiring delays.

Referee response time:

3–7 business days typical

HR verification window:

1–3 business days

Follow-up attempts:

Two reminders spaced 3 days apart

Complete hiring hold:

Dependent on role, usually 1–2 weeks

Record retention start:

From date of last action

Common mistakes to avoid

Using informal language or opinions instead of facts and dates
Omitting referee contact or providing personal emails only
Failing to obtain candidate consent where required
Entering inconsistent date formats leading to verification delays

Risks and compliance consequences

Disallowed disclosure: Privacy violation

Incomplete verification: Hiring risk

I-9 impact: Employment eligibility issues

HIPAA exposure: If PHI included

Legal challenge: Negligent hiring claim

Data breach: Regulatory fines

How the HR Referee Report differs from an informal reference or background check

Compare the formal HR Referee Report with other verification artifacts to choose the appropriate evidence level for hiring decisions.

Criteria	HR Referee Report	Informal Reference
Purpose	verifiable record	quick anecdotal feedback
Format	structured form	free-form conversation
Auditability	high with signatures	low
Use in disputes	admissible supporting evidence	limited

Real-world examples of HR Referee Report use

These short scenarios show how reports are used in hiring, promotion, and compliance reviews.

Verification for regulated hire

A hospital requested a referee report for a nursing supervisor to confirm license-related duties.

The referee provided dates, shift patterns, and one incident summary.
The report supported the credentialing committee's decision and was retained under HIPAA rules with restricted access for six years.

Promotion due diligence

A manufacturing firm collected referee reports before promoting a line manager.

HR confirmed supervisory experience and safety record.
The standardized form allowed rapid comparison across candidates and reduced bias in the promotion audit trail.

Practical tips for accurate and efficient completion

Use standardized language and clear evidence statements to improve consistency and defensibility across hires.

Use defined scales

Adopt consistent performance rating scales and provide brief examples to justify ratings.

Document consent

Confirm candidate consent for reference checks before contacting referees to comply with privacy standards.

Limit PHI

Avoid including protected health information unless strictly necessary and covered by a BAA.

Keep audit trail

Record who requested, who completed, and the method of submission (email link, portal, signed PDF).

eSignature vendor comparison for referee report workflows

Compare common vendor attributes relevant to HR referee report workflows: price, trial availability, bulk send, audit trail, HIPAA support, and envelope limits.

	signNow	DocuSign	Adobe Sign	PandaDoc	HelloSign
Starting Price	$8/user/mo	$15/user/mo	$14/user/mo	$19/user/mo	$15/user/mo
Free Trial	7-day free trial	Trial varies	Trial varies	Trial varies	Trial varies
Bulk Send	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
Audit Trail	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes	Yes
HIPAA Compliant	Yes	Yes	Yes	No	No

FAQs and troubleshooting for HR Referee Reports

Common questions about completion, digital signing, and legal validity are answered here to reduce delays and ensure consistent handling.

Need help? Contact support

How do I confirm the referee's identity
Ask the referee to sign via a verified email and provide a business phone number; follow up by calling the provided number. For sensitive roles, use SMS code or knowledge-based authentication to strengthen identity evidence.
Can the report be e-signed legally
Yes. Electronic signatures meet ESIGN (15 U.S.C. ch. 96) and UETA standards for most transactions. Avoid e-signature for categories expressly excluded from ESIGN such as wills or certain court filings.
What if the referee refuses to sign
Collect a written, dated statement of refusal and document attempts to obtain a signed report. Consider alternative verification such as HR records or publicly available employment confirmations.
Can PHI be included in the report
Minimize PHI. If health information is necessary, ensure a Business Associate Agreement (BAA) is in place and retain records in a HIPAA-compliant environment with restricted access.
How long should we keep reports
Retain applicant and referee reports per retention policy that satisfies IRS and industry rules: typically at least 3 years after final action; HIPAA-related items require 6 years where applicable.
Is notarization ever required
Most referee reports do not require notarization. If a role demands certified statements or the organization policy requires notarized attestations, follow state notary rules or remote notarization processes where permitted.

be ready to get more

Join over 28 million airSlate SignNow users

Sign Now