Motion to Reconsider
What a Motion to Reconsider is and when it applies
Why a Motion to Reconsider matters for case strategy
Use this motion to ask the deciding court to correct error, consider new evidence, or address manifest injustice before pursuing an appeal. It can preserve issues, narrow disputes, and sometimes avoid the expense and delay of appellate review.
Who typically prepares or files a Motion to Reconsider
Filing requirements and standards vary by jurisdiction; confirm applicable local rules and timing before submitting.
- Civil litigants and attorneys seeking correction of trial-court errors before appeal
- Responding parties asking clarification or modification of injunctive or interlocutory orders
- Self-represented litigants (pro se) filing under local court procedures and deadlines
Typical signers and filers
Appellant — Litigation Attorney
A litigation attorney prepares the Motion to Reconsider to preserve legal issues for appeal, cite controlling authority, and present newly discovered evidence. The attorney verifies timing, serves opposing counsel, and files proof of service under court rules to avoid waiver.
Respondent — Pro Se Party
A self-represented litigant files to ask the court to re-evaluate a ruling that materially affects their rights. They must follow local formatting, timing, and service rules and may need court clerk assistance for procedural questions.
Consequences of an incorrect or untimely motion
Common preparation mistakes to avoid
- Missing the jurisdictional or local rule deadline causes procedural dismissal rather than a merits ruling.
- Re-arguing previously litigated facts without new evidence or law rarely succeeds and may invite sanctions.
- Failing to include a proper certificate of service or incorrect service method can void the filing.
- Using vague relief statements instead of concrete, specific requests creates confusion and weakens the motion.
Step-by-step: drafting and filing a Motion to Reconsider
-
01Check deadlines: Confirm the governing rule and compute the final filing date.
-
02Identify grounds: State precise legal or factual bases for reconsideration.
-
03Draft motion: Include caption, relief, argument, and supporting exhibits.
-
04Serve and file: Serve parties, file with court, and retain proof of service.
How to prepare and submit the motion using an online workflow
| Field | Configuration |
|---|---|
| Template Upload | Store a court-form template for reuse |
| Custom Fields | Add case number, dates, and caption as Magic fields |
| Signer Order | Set signer roles and sequence |
| Filing Export | Export PDF/A or court-required format |
Typical process from drafting to court ruling
-
Draft: Prepare motion and attach exhibits
-
Serve: Deliver motion to opposing counsel
-
File: Submit to the clerk and obtain stamping
-
Decision: Court schedules hearing or issues order
Digital submission: formats, integrations, and authentication
Use platforms that retain an audit trail and export court-ready PDFs to meet court clerk technical requirements.
- Accepted Formats: PDF, PDF/A, DOCX
- Integrations: Supports Google Workspace and Microsoft 365
- Authentication: Email or SMS code verification
Common deadlines and timing rules to watch
Rule 59(e) Deadline:
File within 28 days of judgment under Fed. R. Civ. P. 59(e).
Rule 60(b) Timing:
Seek relief 'within a reasonable time'; certain grounds have a one-year limit.
State Rule Variations:
Many states set shorter deadlines; check local rules.
Service Timing:
Serve opposing parties according to local service rules before filing.
Appellate Tolling:
Filing a timely motion may toll appellate deadlines; confirm with procedure rules.
Milestones from filing to court action
Prepare Motion
Complete drafting, attach exhibits, and assemble certificate of service.
Serve Parties
Deliver per rule; obtain proof of service before or at filing.
File with Clerk
E-file or deliver paper copy and obtain stamped receipt.
Court Disposition
Court issues order, schedules hearing, or denies without oral argument.
How a Motion to Reconsider compares with other post-judgment options
| Criteria | Motion to Reconsider | Motion for New Trial | Appeal |
|---|---|---|---|
| Timing | days to weeks | days to weeks | months to appellate deadline |
| Standard | legal error/new evidence | trial errors affecting outcome | legal errors reviewed de novo |
| Court Level | trial court | trial court | appellate court |
| Effect | modify or clarify order | new trial or vacatur | reversal or remand |
eSignature platform comparison for preparing and submitting the motion
| signNow | DocuSign | Adobe Sign | PandaDoc | HelloSign | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Starting Price | $8/user/mo | $15/user/mo | $14/user/mo | $19/user/mo | $15/user/mo |
| Free Trial | 7-day free trial | Varies | Varies | Varies | Varies |
| Bulk Send | Yes | Varies | Varies | Varies | Varies |
| Audit Trail | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes |
| HIPAA Compliant | Yes | Yes | Yes | No | No |
Frequently asked questions about Motions to Reconsider
-
When must I file the motion?
Timing depends on rule and jurisdiction; under Fed. R. Civ. P. 59(e) you generally must file within 28 days of the entry of judgment. State courts and local rules may impose shorter or different deadlines, so verify the applicable rule before drafting.
-
Is this the same as an appeal?
No. A motion to reconsider asks the same court to revisit its ruling; an appeal asks a higher court to review the lower court's decision. Filing a timely motion may be required to preserve certain issues for appeal.
-
Can I e-sign the motion?
Electronic signatures are generally permitted under ESIGN (15 U.S.C. ch. 96) and UETA where adopted; include attribution and retain an audit trail that shows intent, consent, attribution, and retention capability.
-
What if I missed the deadline?
If a deadline is missed, consider Rule 60(b) relief where available or seek leave explaining excusable neglect. Courts apply strict standards; consult procedural rules and counsel promptly.
-
How should I serve opposing parties?
Follow the service requirements in the applicable rules: personal service, mail, e-service, or CM/ECF filing may apply. Always include a certificate of service indicating method, date, and recipients.
-
Can I amend or withdraw the motion?
Yes; courts generally permit amendment or withdrawal before disposition. File a written notice and serve opposing parties; check local rules for any required form or timing.