Establishing secure connection…Loading editor…Preparing document…

Checklist for Employee Termination Consideration

This template is fully customizable. Edit the text, fill out the fields, and send it for signature. Give it a try!

Checklist - When Should You Fire An Employee

Answer "true" or "false" to these questions about your employee. If you answer "true" to many of these questions, you should think about how whether or not this employee is helping or hurting your business.

1. Constantly sidesteps problems that consistently happen.

2. Blames others (including yourself) when things go wrong.

3. Allows criticism of the company to go unchallenged

4. Does not worry about when he/she is consistently late for work or meetings.

5. Postpones completion of projects as long as possible.

6. Avoids seeking clarification of misunderstands so he/she can criticize later.

7. Never volunteers for an assignment when not absolutely certain of success.

8. Is not concerned about deadlines.

9. Maintains same sources of information and bases decisions on opinions rather than facts.

10. Tries to be as worry free as possible even if this causes other employees to have to “take up the slack.”

11. Transfers or releases good people who disagree with him or her.

12. Sees delegating as a way of getting rid of unpleasant chores.

13. Keeps busy on current projects and is uncomfortable about future planning.

14. Allows someone else to do his or her recruiting and selection.

15. Tends to criticize others in public rather than in private.

16. Is insulated from contact with subordinates.

17. Frequently tries to let you know how much you depend on him/her everyday.

18. Is not concerned about promotable people if they might take his or her place.

19. Is uncomfortable when he or she must depend on subordinates to provide answers.

20. Concentrates efforts on preferred tasks rather than on those he or she likes to do least.

21. Compliments you frequently, even when a reason must be created.

22. Downplays the competence of other people.

23. Takes as few risks as possible.

24. Waits as long as possible before delivering bad news.

25. Limits efforts to "on-the-job" hours; rarely takes work home.

26. Resists signing up for self-improvement programs not paid for by the company.

27. Joins in conversations about the "good old days" as often as possible.

28. Talks a lot about how difficult it is to measure his or her job.

29. Hides talented people to further his or her own career.

Employee Name

Date

Comments

Supervisor Signature

Employee Signature

Enter text✕
Prepare your document for signing right on this page
  • 01 Edit the text and complete the fields
  • 02 Click Sign Now and on the next screen add recipients and signature fields in SignNow
  • 03 Start your free trial to sign and send your doc
Sign Now

What the Checklist for Employee Termination Consideration Is

The Checklist for Employee Termination Consideration is a structured internal document used to assess and document legal, administrative, and HR steps before, during, and after an employee separation. It consolidates required notifications, final pay calculations, benefits continuation actions, equipment and data recovery, confidentiality obligations, and any regulatory or contract-specific requirements to reduce compliance risk and ensure consistent, auditable processes.

Why a Formal Termination Checklist Matters

A formal checklist reduces legal exposure, ensures consistent treatment across cases, preserves evidence for unemployment or litigation, and speeds administrative tasks such as final pay and benefit notices.

Why a Formal Termination Checklist Matters

Who Typically Completes This Checklist

HR professionals, hiring managers, and legal counsel jointly use the Checklist for Employee Termination Consideration to ensure all steps are documented and compliant.

  • Human Resources: Coordinates final pay, benefits, COBRA notices, and record retention obligations.
  • Direct Manager: Documents performance issues, returns company property, and completes exit interviews.
  • Legal / Compliance: Reviews potential litigation risk, contract clauses, and statutory notice requirements.

Use role-based signoffs and timestamps to create an auditable trail demonstrating that each party completed required actions.

Step-by-Step: Completing the Termination Checklist

Follow these sequential steps to complete the Checklist for Employee Termination Consideration and capture required approvals.

  • 01
    Confirm Reason: Document the factual basis and supporting evidence.
  • 02
    Review Contracts: Check noncompete, confidentiality, and severance clauses.
  • 03
    Finalize Pay: Calculate final wages, PTO payout, and withholdings.
  • 04
    Recover Assets: Collect devices, badges, and access credentials.

Core Components to Include on the Checklist

A comprehensive checklist groups compliance, payroll, access, and documentation tasks into clear sections for accountability.

Legal Review

Confirm contract obligations, confidentiality clauses, statutory notice periods, and risk of litigation before finalizing termination.

Payroll Settlement

Compute final paycheck components including accrued PTO, reimbursements, deductions, and any severance payments with tax treatment noted.

Benefits & COBRA

Document benefit termination dates, COBRA election window, insurance carrier notifications, and retirement plan distributions or rollovers.

Access & Security

Revoke system access, change shared credentials, recover badges and keys, and document data access logs related to the employee.

Property Recovery

Track return of company devices, keys, documents, and intellectual property; note missing items and valuation steps.

Records & Notices

Prepare required notices, unemployment response materials, and retain copies of the checklist in personnel files for audit.

How to Configure an Electronic Workflow for This Checklist

Design the digital workflow to mirror approval steps, assign signer roles, and record timestamps for compliance.

Field Configuration
Authentication Method Email link with optional SMS or KBA for higher risk cases
Routing Order Linear: Manager → HR → Legal for signature and approval
Reminder Cadence Automatic reminders at 24 and 72 hours until completion
Storage Location Secure HR file cabinet or encrypted cloud record with access controls

Technical Requirements for Digital Use and eSubmission

Ensure the platform supports secure signatures, audit trails, and the file formats your HR systems use.

  • Formats Supported: PDF, DOCX, XLSX
  • Integrations: HRIS and payroll connectors
  • Authenticator: Email, SMS, 2FA

Confirm integrations with payroll and document retention systems, require audit logs for legal review, and choose a platform that supports HIPAA BAA when handling protected health information.

Key Deadlines and Timing Expectations

Track statutory and internal deadlines associated with termination to avoid penalties and maintain compliance.

Final Pay Deadline:

Varies by state; typically next scheduled payday or within 72 hours

I-9 Retention:

Retain for 3 years after hire or 1 year after termination, whichever is later

W-2 / 1099 Delivery:

Provide tax forms to former employees by January 31 each year

COBRA Notice Window:

Provide required notices within 14 to 45 days depending on the event type

Unemployment Response:

Respond to claims promptly; states vary on response deadlines

Milestone Timeline for a Typical Termination

Follow these numbered stages to maintain order and create an auditable separation record.

01

Stage 1: Decision

Document rationale and secure approvals before notification.

02

Stage 2: Notification

Deliver termination notice and explain next steps.

03

Stage 3: Settlement

Process final pay, benefits, and recover property.

04

Stage 4: Post-Term

Retain records, respond to claims, and close access.

Common Mistakes to Avoid

  • Failing to document the factual basis of termination, which increases litigation risk and weakens defenses.
  • Missing state-specific final pay deadlines, causing statutory wage claims or penalties from labor authorities.
  • Neglecting to revoke access immediately, which can expose systems to data breaches or IP loss.
  • Providing informal severance terms without signed agreements, creating enforceability and tax complications.

Security and Compliance Considerations

Encryption: TLS 1.2/1.3 in transit; AES-256 at rest
Audit Trail: Detailed signer timestamps and IP logs
HIPAA: BAA required when PHI is present
ESIGN / UETA: Meets electronic signature legal standards
SOC 2: SOC 2 Type II available
Access Controls: Role-based permissions and SSO

Penalties and Legal Risks from Incomplete Checklists

Wage Penalties: State fines and recovery orders
Tax Withholding: Backup withholding 24% for incorrect TINs
I-9 Penalties: $281–$2,789 per violation
HIPAA Exposure: Significant fines and corrective action
Litigation Risk: Wrongful termination claims
Recordkeeping: Regulatory noncompliance fines

eSignature Vendor Pricing & Feature Comparison

Compare basic starting price and common feature availability for eSignature vendors often used to execute HR checklists and separation documents.

signNow DocuSign Adobe Sign PandaDoc HelloSign
Starting Price $8/user/mo $15/user/mo $14/user/mo $19/user/mo $15/user/mo
Free Trial Yes, 7-day trial Varies by plan Varies by plan Varies by plan Varies by plan
Bulk Send Yes Yes Yes Yes No
Audit Trail Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes
HIPAA Compliant Yes Yes Yes No No
Envelope Cap No cap 100 envelopes/user/year Varies Varies Varies

Real-World Examples of Checklist Use

Practical scenarios show how the checklist reduces error and documents decisions for audits or disputes.

Client HR Example

A mid-size HR team standardized checks to reduce errors in final pay calculations by centralizing approvals

  • Resulted in faster payroll processing and fewer wage claims
  • Over time, the standardized checklist reduced audit exceptions and improved consistency across separations.

Legal Review Example

A small company routed terminations to legal for contract checks before notice

  • That single step flagged two severance clause issues
  • Addressing them prevented wrongful termination claims and preserved enforceability of confidentiality provisions.

Frequently Asked Questions About the Checklist

Answers to common concerns when preparing or executing the Checklist for Employee Termination Consideration.


Need help? Contact support

Explore Templates

Johnson City Community Concert Band Donor Document Notice of Appearance and Intent to Represent Divorce Complaint UCC-3 Amendment Oklahoma Will Instructions Vermont No-Fault Agreed Uncontested Divorce
be ready to get more
Join over 28 million airSlate SignNow users
Sign Now
Company
Forms
Pricing
Resources
Knowledge base
Other Products
© 2026 airSlate Inc. All rights reserved.