19.03[6] Example 2: Adjustments of Rent (Complex Operating Expense Escalations Clause) ARTICLE 5
Adjustments of Rent
[Sections 5.01 through 5.06 omitted].
5.07. For all purposes of this Lease:
(a) "Operating Expenses" for any lease year shall mean the aggregate of
all costs, expenses and disbursements incurred and paid by Landlord (directly or
by way of reimbursement by Landlord to its agents or contractors) which in
accordance with generally accepted cash basis accounting standards and
principles in the real estate industry and with Landlord's federal income tax
reporting basis consistently applied from year to year with respect to the
operation, repair, safety, cleaning, maintenance, management and security of the
Building (excluding ground floor retail space or garage areas and their core,
shell or facade), Building equipment and the Land, including any plazas,
sidewalks and curbs immediately adjacent thereto (collectively, "Landlord's
Property") and shall include (without limitation) the following:
(i) salaries, wages, fringe benefits of every kind and nature,
bonuses and the cost of any hospitalization, medical, surgical, Worker's
Compensation, union and general welfare, pension, retirement or life insurance
plans, disability or other benefits imposed by law or otherwise with respect to
employees, and social security, unemployment and other payroll taxes (including
only the foregoing and other benefits or expenses that are customary for workers
in office buildings of this stature and are in fact given to the workers in the
Building) (collectively, "Labor Costs") paid or incurred by Landlord (directly
or by way of reimbursement by Landlord to its agents) relating to employees of
Landlord or its agents engaged in the operation, repair, cleaning, maintenance,
management and security of Landlord's Property; provided that if any such
employees of Landlord or its agents provide services for more than one building,
then a prorated portion of the Labor Costs shall be included in Operating
Expenses, based on the portion of their working time devoted to Landlord's Property;
(ii) the costs of electricity, gas, steam or other fuel for common
areas and other non-leasable portions of the Building; operation of elevators
and security systems; heating, cooling, air conditioning and ventilating;
chilled water, hot and cold water, sewer and other utilities; utility taxes,
water and sewer rates and charges;
(iii) the cost of cleaning (including windows), janitorial, trash
removal, concierge, security and other services and systems (excluding purchase
and installation thereof);
(iv) the cost of all appropriate insurance, including Worker's
Compensation, property, casualty, liability, excess liability, plate glass,
multiperil, and fidelity insurance without limitation and the fees and charges
of insurance consultants and including the full replacement cost insurance
required to be maintained by Landlord as elsewhere required by this Lease;
(v) the cost of repair to, and maintenance of, Landlord's Property,
including the Building systems;
(vi) the cost of Building cleaning goods and supplies;
(vii) the cost of machinery, equipment, materials and tools used in
the operation, repair, cleaning, maintenance, management and security of the
Landlord's Property and any sales and use taxes thereon;
(viii) the cost of uniforms, work clothes and dry cleaning;
(ix) management fees for managing the Landlord's Property, or if no
management fee is being incurred, an imputed management fee which in either case
shall not exceed the amount that would be paid to an independent third party
manager for a property equal in size and class to the Building;
(x) fees and charges payable under service agreements and other
payments made to Landlord's agents or independent contractors for maintenance,
cleaning and/or operation less any payments to such agents or contractors made
pursuant to Section 5.05(a)(i) above. If there is any affiliation with such
agent or independent contractor, the costs shall be comparable and competitive;
(xi) owner's and agents' administrative costs and expenses,
including bookkeeping, stationery, telephone, telegraph, telecopy (or other
telecommunication) costs paid by Landlord with respect to the operation, repair,
cleaning, maintenance, management or security of the Landlord's Property, except
if a management fee is being paid by Landlord under (a)(ix) hereof such items
shall be excluded to the extent there is duplication of charges;
(xii) legal, accounting and professional fees and disbursements paid
in connection with the operation, repair, cleaning, maintenance, management and
security of Landlord's Property;
(xiii) fees for and costs of licenses, permits and inspections
required in connection with the operation, repair, cleaning, maintenance,
management and security of the Building;
(xiv) costs of successfully contesting the validity or applicability
of any Legal Requirement (as defined in Exhibit D) for the Landlord's Property;
provided, however, that the costs of any such contest included in Operating
Expenses for any Lease Year shall not exceed the amount by which Operating
Expenses for such Lease Year were actually reduced as a result of such contest;
(xv) those taxes, duties, charges, levies and assessments that are
payable in respect of amounts that are otherwise includable within Operating Expenses;
(xvi) all expenses and costs (excluding extraordinary repairs or
Capital Expenses) paid by Landlord as a result of or in order to comply with
applicable laws, including laws pertaining to energy or natural resource
conservation or environmental protection (such as the costs of securing
alternative sources of utilities, energy or other products or services and the
costs of making the Building compatible with the use of such alternative
sources); and codes or regulations of any governmental authority having or
asserting jurisdiction or any order, rule, requirement of any utility company,
insurer of Landlord or the Board of Fire Underwriters (or successor
organization), but excluding the cost of curing any existing violations of New
York City Local Law #5;
(xvii) rent for personal property leased to Landlord the purchase
price of which, if purchased, would be fully includable in Operating Expenses in
the year of purchase;
(xviii) Capital Expenses (as defined in § 5.07(f));
(xix) painting, wallpapering, decorations, displays and exhibits in
public or other non-leasable areas, excluding areas (if any) being used by
Landlord for purposes not connected with the operation, maintenance, management
or security of the Landlord's Property;
(xx) costs of compliance with Legal Requirements (defined below) to
the extent not elsewhere included, but excluding any non-compliance existing as
of the date of execution of the Lease;
(xxi) any and all other expenses paid by Landlord for operation and
maintenance of Landlord's Property which are customary for similar buildings in
New York City.
(b) "Operating Expenses-Exclusions". The following shall be excluded from
Operating Expenses:
(i) expenses relating to leasing space in the Building or preparing
space for lease or for occupancy (including Landlord's work, other tenant work
or tenant improvements, leasing commissions and advertising expenses);
(ii) legal fees and disbursements paid for collection of tenant
accounts, or negotiations of leases, or relating to negotiation and disputes
between Landlord and other lessees and occupants of the Building;
(iii) the cost of electricity furnished to any leasable space in the
Building and the cost of electricity otherwise furnished to any tenant or
occupant of the Building or to equipment owned, installed or exclusively serving
such tenant or occupant;
(iv) the cost of repairs or replacements or restorations incurred by
reason of fire or other casualty or condemnation for which Landlord should have
coverage under agreed value replacement cost insurance policies or should
receive pursuant to condemnation awards and in any event, any Operating Expenses
shall be net of insurance reimbursements or what would have been reimbursed had
Landlord maintained the insurance levels required under this Lease;
(v) expenditures for refinancing and debt service;
(vi) taxes on any inheritance, estate, succession, transfer, gift,
franchise, corporation, income, gains or profit tax or capital levy;
(vii) depreciation;
(viii) telephone, telegraph, telecopy or other telecommunications
costs reimbursed by lessees and occupants of the Building and telecommunications
related services provided to any tenants or to others including tenant's shared
services, except such as are provided without separate charge to all office
tenants of the Building;
(ix) capital expenditures, including lobby and elevator renovation
costs, except to the extent permitted in Section 5.05(a)(xix) and not excluded
by any other provision of this Section 5.05(b);
(x) rent payable by Landlord under any ground lease;
(xi) Labor Costs of any person above the grade of Building manager;
(xii) costs and expenses otherwise includable in Operating Expenses,
to the extent that Landlord is reimbursed from other sources (including other
tenants) for such costs and expenses;
(xiii) expenditures (capital or otherwise) paid in connection with
the removal, replacement, enclosure, encapsulation or other treatment of
asbestos containing material ("ACM");
(xiv) expenditures (capital or otherwise) paid in connection with
the removal, replacement, enclosure, encapsulation or other treatment of any
hazardous material undertaken by reason of the same being hazardous material;
(xv) any amount paid by Landlord to a company or other entity
affiliated with Landlord in excess of the amount which would have been incurred
on an arms-length basis;
(xvi) the costs of HVAC services provided to any leasable space in
the Building (other than such HVAC services as a prudent owner would customarily
furnish for the proper maintenance of the Building, the costs of which shall be
included in Operating Expenses) during any time when Tenant is not entitled
hereunder to the same or does not receive same without separate or additional
charge therefor, including labor, electricity, steam, fuel and maintenance costs
allocable thereto;
(xvii) the costs of any other service or facility, or level or
amount thereof, provided to Tenant or any other tenant or occupant in the
Building which either (i) is not generally offered, supplied or furnished to
tenants, (ii) is at a greater level than provided to Tenant at no additional
cost or (iii) is supplied or furnished to Tenant pursuant to the terms of this
Lease with separate or additional charge (other than the Labor Costs relating to
those employees of Landlord, or any of their agents who man any messenger
receiving area in the Building, which Labor Costs shall be included in Operating
Expenses);
(xviii) costs and damages resulting from the negligent or tortious
acts of Landlord, its employees and agents;
(xix) any costs or expenses paid in connection with any other
building or improvement other than Landlord's Property;
(xx) any costs or expenses paid for maintenance or repair of ground
floor retail stores, garage or parking areas, including windows, storefronts, or
heating, ventilating or air conditioning not part of a building wide system,
utilities or other services;
(xxi) any doubling up of payments causing two (2) years expenses to
be paid in one calendar year.
(c) "Operational Year" shall mean the calendar year 1992 and each
subsequent calendar year during the Term of the Lease and any renewal or
extension term;
(d) "Operational Year Operating Expenses" shall mean the Operating
Expenses incurred during the applicable Operational Year;
(e) "Base Operating Expenses" shall mean Operating Expenses incurred
during the 1992 Operational Year;
(f) The term "Capital Expenses" shall mean the annual amortization
(reasonably determined by Landlord on a straight-line basis over an appropriate
period, determined in accordance with generally accepted accounting principles,
but not to exceed ten (10) years) of expenditures for capital improvements or
capital equipment which either (i) under generally accepted real estate
accounting standards and principles are expended or regarded as deferred
expenses or (ii) are made by reason of Legal Requirements (excluding
requirements, obligations or conditions, compliance with which is necessary to
obtain a permanent Certificate of Occupancy for the Building or pre-existing
this Lease) or Insurance Requirements as defined in Exhibit D, provided,
however, that in the event Landlord receives a reduction, an exemption or
abatement of Taxes or insurance premiums by reason of any such capital
improvement or capital equipment, for purposes of calculating Capital Expenses,
shall be reduced by the amount of such exemption or abatement. There shall be
included in the annual amortization of such costs interest payable by Landlord
during such year on money borrowed by Landlord in order to make such capital
improvement or purchase any item of capital equipment or interest on money
borrowed by Landlord in connection with the operation of the Building and which
Landlord certifies to Tenant was allocated to such capital improvement or the
purchase of capital equipment. Notwithstanding the foregoing, "Capital Expenses"
shall not include the (a) construction of the Building or any expenditures for
any alteration, renovation, subdivision, layout or finish of any space in the
Building performed in connection with occupancy of such space by a tenant or in
connection with renewal of a lease for such space with any tenant thereof, and
(b) any item which does not result in a reduction of Operating Expenses greater
than the annual amortization of the cost of such item. Before undertaking any
work that Landlord intends to be a Capital Expense, Landlord shall forward a
lifecycle cost statement for such work to Tenant.
5.08. In determining the amount of the Base Operating Expenses or the Operating
Expenses for any Operational Year, if less than ninety-five (95%) percent of the
rentable area of the Building shall have been occupied by tenants at any time
during any such year, Operating Expenses for such Operational Year shall be
determined for such year to be an amount equal to the like expenses which would
normally be expected to be incurred had the occupancy of the Building been
ninety-five (95%) percent throughout the applicable year.
5.09. If Landlord is not furnishing any particular work or service (the cost of
which if performed by Landlord would constitute an Operating Expense i.e., such
service at such level is available to or being given to Tenant without charge)
to a tenant who has undertaken to perform such work or service in lieu of the
performance thereof by Landlord, the Operational Year Operating Expenses for
each Operational Year during which such situation shall occur shall be increased
by an amount equal to the actual consideration paid by Landlord therefor
(including any rent reduction) and if not ascertainable then by an amount equal
to the additional Operating Expense which reasonably would have been incurred
during such period by Landlord if it had at its own expense furnished such
service or services to such tenant.
5.10. In any Operational Year in which Operational Year Operating Expenses
exceed Base Operating Expenses, Tenant shall pay to Landlord Tenant's
Proportionate Share of such excess.
5.11. During or after the first Operational Year, and each year thereafter
Landlord shall forward Tenant an itemized statement prepared by Landlord's
certified public accountants in accordance with generally accepted cash basis
accounting standards and principles, consistently applied, ("Statement") and
certified by Landlord as correct, of the Base Operating Expenses and the
occupancy adjustment pursuant to Section 5.08. Thereafter, each Operational Year
during the Term Landlord shall forward to Tenant a Statement of the Operational
Year Operating Expenses for that prior Operational Year and a computation of the
amount payable by Tenant pursuant to this Article for such Operational Year.
5.12. With each installment of Fixed Rent payable during the Term during and
after the 1994 Operational Year, Tenant shall pay to Landlord on account of the
amount payable pursuant to this Article for the then Operational Year:(i) until the earlier of (a) nine (9) months after the end of the
preceding Operational Year or (b) the date Landlord forwards the applicable
Statement for the preceding Operational Year, the amount of the monthly payment
due during December of such Operational Year; and
(ii) Landlord shall use all reasonable efforts to forward the applicable
Statement for the preceding Operational Year within six (6) months after the end
of such Operational Year, but if Landlord does not forward the applicable
Statement for the preceding Operational Year, within nine (9) months after the
end of the Operational Year, payments by Tenant shall be suspended until the
applicable Statement is forwarded; and
(iii) after Landlord forwards the applicable Statement for the preceding
Operational Year, one-twelfth (1/12th) of Landlord's estimate of the amount
payable to Tenant for the current Operational Year, not to exceed one hundred
five (105%) percent of the amount payable pursuant to this Article for such
preceding Operational Year.
5.13. Once Landlord forwards the applicable Statement for the preceding
Operational Year, Landlord and/or Tenant, as the case may be, promptly shall
make appropriate payment to the other within thirty (30) days (without interest)
of any amount overpaid by Tenant or owing to Landlord for such Operational Year
based on the amount due pursuant to such Statement and amounts theretofore paid
by Tenant for such preceding Operational Year. Such payments shall not be deemed
a waiver of Tenant's rights to dispute any Statement.
5.14. Landlord's and Tenant's obligations to make any payment pursuant to this
Article shall survive the Expiration Date or any sooner termination of this
Lease and shall be appropriately prorated for any Operational Year which is only
partially within the Term.
5.15. Each Statement given by Landlord pursuant to Section 5.11 shall be binding
upon Tenant unless, within six (6) months after its receipt of such Statement,
Tenant notifies Landlord of its disagreement therewith, specifying the portion
thereof with which Tenant disagrees. Pending resolution of such dispute, Tenant
shall, without prejudice to its rights, pay all amounts determined by Landlord
to be due, subject to prompt refund by Landlord (without interest) upon contrary
determination.Provided that Tenant complies with the provisions of this Section 5.15 and
Section 5.16, Tenant shall have the right to reasonably review books and records
relevant to Operating Expenses for each Operational Year and for the Base
Operating Year. The right of the Tenant under this paragraph to dispute
Operating Expenses may only be exercised once for any Statement. Tenant agrees
that any review of records under this paragraph shall occur at Landlord's
office. Except as provided in Section 5.14, any review to be conducted under
this paragraph shall be at the sole expense of Tenant and shall be conducted by
public accountants.
5.16. Landlord's failure to render Statements with respect to any Operational
Year shall not prejudice Landlord's right to thereafter render a Statement with
respect thereto or with respect to any subsequent Operational Year, nor shall
the rendering of a Statement prejudice Landlord's right to thereafter render a
corrected Statement for that Year. If such dispute shall not be resolved within
ninety (90) days after the giving of such Landlord's Statement or estimate, as
the case may be, Tenant shall, within sixty (60) days after written notice from
Landlord of the expiration of such ninety (90) day period, submit the dispute to
arbitration pursuant to Article 34, failing which Tenant shall be deemed to have
waived its objections. Tenant agrees to use reasonable efforts to see that any
information obtained by Tenant pursuant to this section shall be treated as
confidential (but such information may be disclosed in the arbitration
proceeding on a confidential basis).
Any agreed on or arbitrated errors disclosed by the review of records
under this Article shall be promptly corrected. In the event that the results of
the review of records (taking into account, if applicable, the results of any
arbitration) reveal that Tenant has overpaid its obligations for a preceding
period, the amount of such overpayment shall be credited against Tenant's next
subsequent installment payments of rent or if after the Expiration Date,
refunded to Tenant. In the event that such results show that Tenant has
underpaid its obligations for a preceding period, the amount of such
underpayment shall be paid by Tenant to Landlord with the next succeeding
installment obligation of rent.
5.17. Landlord's and Tenant's obligation to make the adjustments or payments
referred to in this Article 5 shall survive any expiration or termination of
this Lease. Any delay or failure of Landlord in billing any amounts due under
this Article 5 shall not constitute a waiver of or in any way impair the
continuing obligation of Tenant to make any such payments hereunder; provided
however if Landlord fails to render a Statement within two (2) years after the
expiration of any Operational Year, then Landlord waives the right to collect
any additional Operating Expenses based on such Statement for that Operational
Year and Landlord's future Statements (for increases, if any, of subsequent
Operational Years over the Base Year) shall not thereby be affected if timely sent.