(:opyright 0 1990 by the Genetics Society of America
Behavior of the [mi-31 Mutation and Conversionof Polymorphic mtDNA
Markers in Heterokaryons of Neurospora crussu
Alexisann Hawse,* Richard A. Collinst and Frank E. Nargang*
*Department of Genetics, University of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta T6G 2E9, Canada, and ?Departmentof Botany, University of
Toronto, Toronto, Ontario M5S lA1, Canada
Manuscript received December 29, 1989
Accepted for publication May 24, 1990
ABSTRACT
We have examined the behavior of the [mi-?] mitochondrial mutation and two physical mtDNA
markers in heterokaryotic culturesof Neurospora crassa. Previous workers showed that a 1.2-kilobase
insertion in the larger polymorphic form of EcoRI-5 restriction fragment is a site of high frequency
and rapid unidirectional gene conversion. We have confirmed this observation and determined by
DNA sequence analysis that theinsertion in the EcoRI-5 fragment correspondsprecisely to anoptional
intron that containsa long open reading frame in the NDI gene. Thus, the conversion of the short,
intron-lacking, form of EcoRI-5 to the longer, intron-containing, form may be analogous to the
unidirectional gene conversion events catalyzed by intron-encoded proteins in other organisms. T h e
resolution of two polymorphic forms of the mtDNAEcoRI-9 restriction fragment in our heterokaryons
differs from that observed previously and suggests that this locus is not a site of gene conversion in
our heterokaryon pair. T h e size polymorphism of the EcoRI-9 fragments is due to atandemly
reiterated 78-base-pair sequence which occurs two times in the short form and three
times in the long
form. One copy of the repeat unit and 66 base pairs following it have been duplicated from the N D 2
gene which is located about 30 kilobases distant on the mtDNA. In contrast to[poky]
the mitochondrial
mutant, which was completely dominant over wild-type mitochondria in heterokaryons, the [mi-?]
mutant was recovered in only seven of twenty heterokaryons after ten cycles of conidiation and
subculturing. T h e resolution of the [mi-?] or wild-type phenotype in heterokaryons may depend solely
on random factors such as allele input frequency, drift, andsegregation rather than specific dominant
or suppressive effects.
time for complete takeover by the mutant. Thus, it
ARLY studies on a variety of cytoplasmically inlikely that [ p o k y ] is completely dominant towild
seems
heritedmutants of Neurospora crassa demontype under these conditions.
strated that the phenotype
of these mutants could
The investigations into the behavior of the [ p o k y ]
predominant over wild-type strains in heterokaryons,
mutant in heterokaryons employed strains of N. crassa
or when mitochondria purified from mutant strains
carrying polymorphic mtDNA markers. An attempt
were microinjected into the hyphal compartments of
was made to utilize these markers to correlate converwild-type strains (PITTENGER 1956;
GARNJOBST,
WILsion of heterokaryons to the mutant phenotype with
SON, and TATUM
1965; DIACUMAKOS,
GARNJOBST
and
TATUM
1965; BERTRAND
and PITTENGER
1969). Furthe presence of aparticular
polymorphic marker
ther investigation of this phenomenon showed that
(MANNELLAand LAMBOWITZ
1979). The studies were
heterokaryons constructed between the [ p o k y ] mutant
inconclusive regardingthegenetic
location of the
[ p o k y ] mutation,butthe
analysisof heterokaryon
and wild-type would acquire the mutant phenotype
mtDNAs revealed unusual behavior for two polymorafter two to eight cycles of subculturing heterokarphic markers. These markers, an insertion of ca. 50
yotic conidia onto fresh minimal medium. The number of cycles required appeared to be unrelated to the base pairs in the EcoRI-9 fragment of the type I
initial ratio of conidia used to form the heterokaryon
polymorphic form of mtDNA relative to the corre(MANNELLA
and LAMBOWITZ 1978). In data combined sponding fragment in the type I1 polymorphic form,
from two separate studies, at least 38 of 42 heterokarand a ca. 1200 base pairinsertion in the EcoRI-5
yons constructed between wild type and [ p o k y ] showed
fragment of type I1 mtDNA relative to the type I
the mutant phenotype (MANNELLAand LAMBOWITZ version, were found to be sites of high frequency
1978; 1979).Since the four thathad not acquired the
unidirectional gene conversion.That is, the two inser[ p o k y ] phenotype had been taken through only two to
tions were found to spreadrapidly through the mixed
five conidial passes (MANNELLAand LAMBOWITZ mtDNA population of the heterokaryons (MANNELLA
1979), it is probable that they had not had sufficient
and LAMBOWITZ 1979).
E
( ; ~ I I ~ I I C >1 2 6
ti3-72 (Septenlhel-.1990)
64
A. Hawse, R. A. CollinsE.and F.
Recently, we constructed heterokaryons to verify
the genetic location of t h e [mi-31 mutation (LEMIRE
a n d NARGANC
1986). Analysisof these heterokaryons
revealed that unlike [ p o k y ] , [mi-)] did not predominantover wild typein all heterokaryons.Furthermore, while we did observe complete conversion to
the typeI1 form of EcoRI-5 in heterokaryon mtDNAs,
we did not observe the same extent of conversion to
the type I form of EcoRI-9 reported in the previous
study (MANNELLAa n d LAMBOWITZ
1979). Here we
describe further studies of the interaction between
[mi-31 a n d wild-type mitochondria, and the conversion
of the two polymorphic insertions in heterokaryons
examined after varying numbersof cycles of conidial
passage. In addition, in an attempt to gain insight into
the mechanism(s) involved in the conversion
of t h e
two insertions, we have determined and analyzed the
DNAsequence of theappropriateregions
of t h e
EcoRI fragments involved.
MATERIALS AND METHODS
Strains and culture conditions: Strains of N. crassa used
in this study were Abbott 12, as described by LEMIRE and
NARGANC (1986),
240 (nic-I, al-2, A), and IL-40 (pan-2,
[mi-?], A). The 240 strain possesses a wild-type cytoplasm
and contains the type I1 polymorphic form of mtDNA
(MANNELLAand LAMBOWITZ
1979). The [mi-?] mitochondrial mutation in IL-40 causes a deficiency of cytochrome
aa3 (MITCHELL, MITCHELL and TISSIERES
1953; LEMIRE
and NARCANG1986). IL-40 and Abbott 12 contain the type
I polymorphic form of mtDNA (MANNELLAand LAMBOWITZ
1979). Culture conditions for N. crassa were as described
earlier (BERTRANDandPITTENCER1969; DAVISand DE
SERRES1970).
The differences between the two polymorphic forms of
mtDNA can be summarized simply in terms of two restriction fragment length polymorphisms (RFLPs). Type I
mtDNA carriesa short form of the EcoRI-5 restriction
fragment and a long version of EcoRI-9, relative to the type
I1 form of mtDNA.
Escherichia coli strains used were derivatives of HB10 1
(MANIATIS,
FRITSCHand SAMBROOK
1982) that had been
transformed (NORGARD,KEEM and MONAHAN1978) with
one of the recombinant plasmids described below. In order
to obtain plasmids free of methylation at A or C residues
(for use with certain restriction enzymes sensitive to methylation), plasmids were transformed into strain Kur 1226
(dam-,dcm-) obtained from R. KELLN (University of Regina). Strain JM103 (MESSING1983) was utilized for the
propagation of M 13 phage for DNA sequence analysis.
Single-stranded phage DNA was prepared as described by
MESSING(1 983).
Heterokaryon construction and analysis:Twenty separate heterokaryons were constructed by superimposing conidia of the pantothenaterequiring IL-40 strain with conidia
from the nicotinic acid requiring 240 strain on 50 ml of
agar hardened minimal Vogel’s medium in a 250-ml Erlenmeyer flask. The conidia that formed in this flask were
considered to representthe first “cycle”of the heterokaryon.
An inoculum from these conidia was then placed in a flask
of fresh minimal medium and the flask containing the first
cycle of the heterokaryon was stored at 4 The conidia that
formed in the second flask were considered to be the second
O .
Nargang
cycle of the heterokaryon, and conidia from this flask were
used to inoculate another flask for the third cycle. This
procedure was continued until 10 cycles of each heterokaryon were obtained. The conidia from each cycle of each
heterokaryon were available for the analysisof mtDNA
contentand mitochondrial cytochromes. We arbitrarily
chose to examine the eighth cycle of each heterokaryon as
a starting point. Depending on the results observed, either
earlier or later cycles were thenexamined in order to
determine at which cycle conversion of the mtDNAs was
complete and when the heterokaryon became phenotypically [mi-?].
Isolation of mtDNA: Mitochondria to be used for isolation of mtDNA were purified on either step gradients(NARGANG and BERTRAND 1978) or flotation gradients as described by LAMBOWITZ
(1979), except that Tris-HCI was
used instead of Tricine-KOH. MtDNA was isolated from
flotation gradient purifiedmitochondria as described by
NARGANG(1986).
LEMIRE and
Construction of recombinant plasmidsand isolation of
plasmid DNA: To facilitate the isolation of DNA for sequence analysis, each version of the EcoRI-5 and EcoRI-9
fragments was cloned into a bacterial vector. The EcoRI-5
and EcoRI-9 fragmentsfromAbbott12(type
I mtDNA)
were cloned into pBR325. The EcoRI-9 fragmentfrom
strain 240 (type I1 mtDNA) was cloned into pUC19. A clone
of the EcoRI-5 fragment from N. crassa strain 74A (type I1
mtDNA) inplasmid pBR322 was kindly provided by H .
BERTRAND
(University of Guelph). Bacterial plasmid DNA
was isolated from CsCI-ethidium bromide gradients as deand SAMBROOK 1982).
scribed (MANIATIS, FRITSCH
Agarose gel electrophoresis: Agarose gels were made to
0.8% agarose in 100 mM Tris-borate (pH 8.3),2 mM EDTA
and contained ethidium bromide at a concentration of 0.5
cLgIm1.
DNAsequencing and analysis: DNA sequencing and
analysis were as described previously (PANDE,
LEMIREand
NARGANG1989).
Analysis of mitochondrialcytochromes: Cytochrome
spectra were obtained by the method of BERTRAND
and
PITTENCER(1969) using a Shimadzu UV-265recording
spectrophotometer.
RESULTS
Conversion of EcoRI-5 and -9 and dominance of
[mi-3]in heterokaryons: In our previous examination
into the primary defect in the[mi-3] mutant (LEMIRE
a n d NARCANG
1986), we observed that the mutation
did not predominate over wild-type mitochondria in
heterokaryons to the same extent described for the
[ p o k y ] mitochondrial mutant (MANNELLAa n d LAMBOWITZ 1978, 1979). In the present study, we have
attempted to confirm this observation, and to examine
the rate of resolution of[mi-31 plus wild-type heteroTo this
karyons to one of the component phenotypes.
end, a set of twenty heterokaryons was constructed
MATERIALS
between the two strains as described in
AND METHODS. Since the component strains carried
mtDNAs with different polymorphic markers, examination of the heterokaryon mtDNAs was also used to
deevaluate the gene conversion events previously
scribed for the insertions in the EcoRI-5 a n d -9 fragbe notedthatmtDNAscarrying
ments.Itshould
Heterokaryons of Neurospora trassa
65
n
wild-type
FIGURE2.-Cytochrome spectra of the wild-type strain and the
cytochrome aaa deficient [mi-)]strain that are the components of
the heterokaryons examinedin this study.Also shown is a spectrum
that would be judgedto be a mixtureof thetwo components in the
characterization o f heterokaryon types. T h e positions o f the absorption peaks for cytochrome aas (608 nm), cytochrome b (560
nm), and cytochromec (550 nm) are shown.
FIGUREI .-RcoRI restrict ion digest patterns for type I and type
I 1 nitDNA of Neurospora. The
standardnumberingpattern of
RcoRl fragments 1 through 10 is derivedfromthetype
I 1 form
(MANNELLA and LAMROWITZ
1979). In the type I form the pattern
o f fragments is identical except for RFLPs giving a smaller EcoRI5 fragment, 5(1). and a larger BcoRI-9 fragment. 9(I).
differing forms of these polymorphic restriction fragments were originally described as type I or type I1
mtDNA (MANNELLAand LAMBOWITZ
1978,1979).
However, the differences in these mtDNAs can essentially be summarized in terms of restriction fragment
length polymorphisms (RFLPs) in the EcoRI-5 and -9
restriction fragments. Thus, onemtDNA (type I)contains a long formof the EcoRI-9 fragment and a short
form of the EcoRI-5 fragment. The other mtDNA
(type 11) contains the short form of EcoRI-9 and the
long form of EcoRI-5.
As a starting point in our study the eighth cycle of
each heterokaryon was examined for its content of
mtDNA and mitochondrial cytochromes. Figure 1
shows an example of the restriction digest patterns
expected for the type I and I1 forms of mtDNA that
exist in the original component strains of the heterokaryon. Figure 2 shows examples of the mitochondrial
cytochrome
content
observed
in thecomponent
strains and the heterokaryons. If the heterokaryons
exhibited a patternof mitochondrial cytochromesthat
was intermediate between the pattern expected for
[mi-31 or wild type (“mixture” in Figure 2), or if the
mtDNA contained a mixture of the two RFLPs for
either the EcoRI-9 or EcoRI-5 fragments, then later
cycles of the heterokaryonwere examined. If any trait
was resolved by the eighth cycle, then earlier cycles
were examined in an attempt to
discover at what point
resolution had occurred. Our judgmentof resolution
of the traits is based on examination of mitochondrial
cytochrome spectra for the [mi-3] us. wild-type phenotype, and on the presence of particular mtDNA
restrictionfragments on ethidiumbromide stained
agarose gels.
All the heterokaryons examined had acquired the
long form of EcoRI-5 by the eighth cycle. Five were
chosen at random for examinationat thesecond cycle
of passage and all were found to have fully converted
to the long form by this time. One first cycle culture
was examined and was also found to be completely
resolved to the long form (data notshown).
The results observed for each of the heterokaryon
cycles examined, with respect to both mitochondrial
cytochrome spectrum and type of EcoRI-9 fragment,
are summarized in Table 1. By the eighth cycle, 15
heterokaryons possessed mixed populations of the
EcoRI-9 fragment, five possessed the long version,
A. Hawse, R. A. Collins and F. E. Nargang
66
TABLE 1
EcoRI-9 fragments and cytochrome spectrain heterokaryons 1 through 20
Heterokaryon cycle
2
1
Heterokaryon
1
2
RI-9
"
cyt
" _
Rl-9
nlix
3
cyt
RI-9
wt
5
4
cyt
RI-9
cyt
RI-9
- -
-
-
-
- " " mix mix wt
mix
wt
- - - 5 "
- - " - " " " (j
- - - - - - 7
- - - " " " " "
8
_ _ _ mix-."- g
- - - - - 10
- - - - - - - - - "
11
- - - - - 1 2 - - - - - - - - " - " 13
- - mix
wt
- - L mi3 - - - - - 14
- Wt
15
- - - - - - - - - - 16
- wt
Wt
- - - - 17
- - mix
-
-
-
L
mi3
L
- -
mi3
- - -
-
L
-
Rl-9
cyt
wt
mi3
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
L
-
mi3
-
" - - -
-
L
- mix
mi3
wt
-
-
wt
- - -
-
-
-
-
- -
mix
L
-
mi3
mix
-
9
8
cyt
-
m i x " - - - -
-
RI-9
mix
3
18
19
20
cyt
wt"""
4
7
6
RI-9
mix
L
mix
mix
mix
mix
L
- mix
mix
- wt mix
mix
L
- mix
- mix
- mix
- mix
wt
L
- mix
L
cyt
wt
wt
mi3
mix
RI-9
mix
mix
L
mix
wt
mix
mix mix
wt
mix
mi3
L
wt
mix
wt
mix
mix
wt
mix
m i 3 wt
S
wt
mix
wt
S
wt
mix
wt
mix
L
m i 3 -
10
cyt
RI-9
cyt
wt
S
S
-
wt
wt
mi3
wt
mi3
mi3
s
wt
S
wt
mi3
wt
mi3
wt
s
S
S
mi3
wt
wt
wt
wt
S
wt
wt
S
-
-
-
wt
wt
wt
S
S
wt
wt
S
mi3
-
L
-
S
wt
wt
wt
wt
mi3
-
T h e "R1-9"columns describe the state of the EcoR1-9 restriction fragments found in the mtDNA of the heterokaryon in a given cycle:
"mix" denotes that a mixture of the short and long forms
was found, "L"denotes that theEcoRI-9 fragment was entirely the long form, and
5 , " that the fragment was entirely the short form. T h e "cyt" columns describe the characteristics of the mitochondrial cytochrome spectra:
"mix" denotesthatacytochromespectrumintermediate
between that of wild-type and [mi-3] (see Figure 2) was obtainedfromthe
heterokaryon at that cycle, "wt" denotes a wild-type spectrum, and "mi3" denotes a [mi-3] type cytochrome spectrum. Dashes indicate that
heterokaryons were not examined at that cycle.
and none possessed solely the short form. However,
all those heterokaryons listed as having a mix of EcoRI9 fragments at the eighth cycle contained a higher
percentage of the short form with the exception of
heterokaryon 19. The latter resolved tothe long
version and the others to the short form within two
additional cycles. Thus, by the tenth cycle 14 heterokaryons contained the short version of EcoR1-9 and
six the long form of the fragment.
The fact that we observed a mixture of the short
and long formsof EcoRI-9at some cycle of passage in
all theheterokaryons (except numbers 8 and 20),
shows that the input ratios from the two component
strains is not grossly skewed in one direction or the
other. Furthermore, the
fact that all heterokaryon
mtDNAs are rapidly converted to contain the long
form ofEcoRI-5 demonstrates that efficient mixing of
mtDNA molecules must occur, since the conversion
process undoubtedly requires physical interaction of
mtDNA molecules. Thus, the mixtures of EcoRI-9
molecules do not arise from distinct populations of
mitochondria from the input strains that
might persist
in a sequestered state within the heterokaryon.
At the eighth cycle, three heterokaryons possessed
a "mixed" cytochrome spectrum while 13 were wildtype andfour were [mi-31. By theninth cycle, the
mixed heterokaryons had resolved to [mi-31 so that
13 were wild-type and seven were [mi-31. These data
suggest that for those cultures that will become [mi31, thenumber of subculturing cycles required is
similar to that required by [ p o k y ] , where up to eight
cycles may be needed. However, we cannot rule out
the possibility that some cultures, which appeared
spectrally wild-type after the tenth cycle might eventually become [mi23]. That is, a cytochrome spectrum
with only a small reduction in cytochrome uu3 might
be misclassified as a wild-type spectrum. Any [mi-3]
mtDNA in such cultures could conceivably result in
theculture eventually becoming [mi-31. In this respect, it is difficult to say that any heterokaryon has
become established as wild type. However, from the
results of both this investigation andthe previous
study (LEMIREand NARGANC1986), it appears that
some heterokaryotic cultures do become permanently
wild type rather than [ m i - 3 ] .This is in contrast to the
behavior of heterokaryons constructedbetween [ p o k y ]
and wild-type strains, where after maximum
a
of eight
cycles of conidial passage, most if not all heterokaryons exhibit themutantphenotype.
Our data do
suggest that once [mi-31 begins to become established
in aheterokaryoticculture,
the culture will almost
always become [mz-3] after further cycles. That is,
Heterokaryons of Neurospora crassa
with the single exception of heterokaryon 18, if a
heterokaryon was observed to have a mixed cytochrome spectrum, it eventually became [mi-)].Similarly, if a culture was classified as [mi-31 at any point,
it never changed to wild type. In two cases (heterokaryons 4 and 13) a wild-type cytochrome spectrum
was observed in the early cycles but later changed to
[mi-31. We assume that in these cases either the input
ratio of [mi-3] to wild-type mitochondria was relatively
low and/orthatthemutant
mitochondriadidnot
become sufficiently established in the cultures until
the later cycles.
With respect to the three characters examined in
this study, only eight of the 20 heterokaryons could
be classified as recombinant types (numbers 3,4,6, 8,
13, 18, 19 and 20) after ten cycles of subculturing.
This frequency of recombination is considerably lower
thanthatobserved previously in heterokaryons involving the [ p o k y ] mutant (MANNELLA
and LAMBOWITZ 1979).
DNA sequence analysis of EcoRI-5: Previous DNA
sequence analysis
of
the longform
of EcoRI-5
(BURGER
and WERNER 1985)
revealed the presence of
alongopenreadingframe
with homology tothe
mammalian NDI gene (formerly URF1). T h e latter
has been shown to encode a component
of the NADH
dehydrogenase complex (CHOMYN
et al. 1985). The
NDI gene of N.crassa was found to be interruptedby
a single intron of 11 18base pairs, which contained a
separateopenreadingframe(ORF)(BURGERand
WERNER 1985).
We reasoned that the previously observed ca. 1200-base-pair size difference between the
short and long forms of the EcoRI-5 fragment (MANNELLA and LAMBOWITZ
1979) might be accounted for
by the absence or presence of this intron, respectively.
T o test this possibility, we determined the DNA sequence of the short form of the EcoRI-5 fragment
from a ClaI site, 40 base pairs upstream of the predicted splice site, through theregion where the intron
exists in the long version of the fragment.Comparison
of the sequences revealed that a region corresponding
exactly to the predicted intron is absent in the short
version of the NDI gene (Figure 3).
DNA sequence analysis of EcoRI-9: T o identify
the region of the EcoRI-9 fragment that contains the
previously described ca. 50 base pair insertion (BERNARD et al. 1975; MANNELLA
and LAMBOWITZ
1979),
the DNA sequence of both the short andlong EcoRI9 fragments was determined. The sequence of both
strands of the long form of the fragment was determined entirely and is shown in Figure 4. T h e sequence
of the short form was determined completely on one
strand and on both strands in regions where the two
forms of the fragment were found to differ,or in any
region where compression caused difficulty in interpreting the sequence. The only difference found in
67
A) ND1 Gene (long version)
I
. . .TTAGCTGAGGCTACTAATATG...
_ . _L A E A
'
H ND1 Exon2
ORF
ND1
lntronic
Exon1
Intron
. . . TATTTTTTGGAATCAGMTTA ...
tE
t
I
E
5oobP
...
I
6 ) ND1 Gene (short version)
I
ND1 Gene
1
. . .TTAGCKA@XTGAATCAGAATTA. . .
. . . L A E A E S E L ...
FIGURE3.-The ND1 (formerly URFl) gene in Neurospora.A,
The long version of the gene containing the intron (BURGERand
WERNER1985). The intron contains an ORF with the capacity to
encode a 304 amino acid protein. B, The short form of the NDI
gene which contains no intron. The intron is absent in the short
NDI gene precisely at the sitespreviously predicted (shown by
arrows) to be the sites for splicing the intron from the mRNA of
the long form of the NDl gene (BURGERand WERNER1985). The
nucleotide sequence at theintron/exon boundaries is shown. Amino
acids in the ND1 coding sequence at the intron/exon boundaries
are given in the one letter code.
the two polymorphic forms of the fragmentwas in the
number of copies of a 78-base pair repeat. A single
sequencing gel which spanned this region in both
forms of the fragment, revealed that the larger form
of the EcoRI-9 fragment contained three copies of this
repeat while the short form contained only two. The
three copies of the repeat are present at nucleotides
112 to 189, 190 to 267, and 268 to 345 of Figure 4.
The EcoRI-9 fragments were found to be about 38%
G+C, in good agreement with the 40% G+C content
et al. 1975;
reported for N. crassa mtDNA (BERNARD
TERPSTRA,
HOLTROPand KROON 1977).However,
the repeats were found to be only 29% G+C.
The EcoRI-9 fragments were analyzed for the presence of reading framesin both strands. The sequence
of the adjoining regions of the EcoRI-8 fragment (R.
A. COLLINS,unpublished results) was included in the
this fragment
search so thatORFsextendinginto
might bedetected. Only one ORF over 75amino
acids long beginning with an ATG codon was found
in the long form of the EcoRI-9 sequence. This ORF
occurs in the third frameof the top strand andwould
be 115 amino acids long starting from the first ATG
4). TheORF
codon (nucleotides102-104,Figure
extends for an additional 23 aminoacids upstream of
the ATG. This ORF
spans the direct repeat region so
that the corresponding polypeptide in the short form
of EcoRI-9 would be only 86 amino acids long. Remarkably, this ORF was found to have a stretch of 47
amino acids identical to the probable ND2 (formerly
URF2)
protein
of Neurospora
encoded
on
the
HindIII-9 fragmentof Neurospora mtDNA (DE VRIES
et al. 1986). The relationship of the regions of mtDNA
involved, the location of the reading frames, and the
0
0
0
0
A. Hawse. R. A. Collins and F. E. Nargang
68
IO
20
-
30
40
50
6.0
70
00
CTGATCAAGG ATTffiCTPRT TTCTTRTATA AACTCPPACR ACCACCTCCA AGGAATAAAC
GAATTCTAGTGGATTTTTAT
CTTAAGATCA C C T A W A T R GACTAGTTCC TAATCGATTAAAGAATATATTTGAGTTTGT
110
AACTACAATT ATACCCCCCT CATGCRGCAA
90
100
1 30
TGGTGGAGGT TCCTTATTTG
1230
I 50
160
AATRATAG
GAACTGTTGT
RGGTTTAACA CAGTTTAGAA
TTRAAAGATT
TTGATGTTAA TATGGGGGGA GTACGTCGTT g T l A T T A T C CTTGACAACATCCAAATTGTGTCAAATCTT
RATTTTCTAA
230
270
120
140
220 170 210
100
200
I90
240
GCTTGCATAT AGTACAATCT
CTCATCTA
AATAATAGGA ACTGTTGTAG GTTTARCRCA GTTTRGAATT MAAGATTGC
CGAKGTRTA TCATGTT&W G A G T A G R T ~TTATTATCCT TGACARCATC CAAATTGTGTCAAATCTTAATTTTCTRACG
260
300
250
310
320
TTGCATATAG
TACAATCTCT
CATCTA
AA TAATAGGAAC TGTTGTRGGT TTRACRCRGT TTAGAATTAR
AAGATTGCTT
ARCGTATATC RTGTTAGAGR GTAGAT$TT
ATTATCCTTG ACAACATCCR ARTTGTGTCA ARTCTTAATTTTCTAACGAA
330
340
350
370
360
300
GCATATAGTA CAATCTCTCPl TCTR TTTTATTTTRTTAGCTTTAAGTGT
CGTRTATCAT GTTRGAGPGT RGA$AAAR
TAARRTAATCGARATTCACA
390
400
TTCCRCACRR RGTGTGGAGT CCACRCAAGC
ARGGTGTGTT TCRCACCTCA GGTGTGTTCG
410
420
430
440
470
460
480
A T T I A T A T T T TGGGAGGAGT GARATTACAG GGAGATTAAA AlAGTT*
CTGTAAGAAC ATTAAGATGG CGRTTCCACT
TAAATATAAA RCCCTCCTCA CTTTAATGTCCCTCTAATTTTATCAAATTAGACATTCTTGT&ATTCTACC
GCTAAGGTGA
490
500520
530
510
540560
5501640
I630
CGGCCCCCCC TCCAGCGAAG CTGGPGGGGG TRGCGAGTGA ARGCTTTTAA TAAPGTTGGR TTGCCATGRC CGCTTCGAGC
GCCGGGGGGG AGGTCGCTTC GACCTCCCCC ATCGCTCACT TTCGRRAATTATTTCAACCT
ARCGGTACTG GCGAATCTCG
590
580
1730 1720
630
570
1710
640
GTTGGTCCCT ATCTTCCTCAGTAGTTTRCT
GCTGAGGAAG GTAGAGCRGT CAGCAAAGAG GACGGACCGT AAAGCCATAC
CAACCAGGGA TAGPAGGAGT CATCAAATGA CGACTCCTTC CATCTCGTCAGTCGTTTCTC
CTGCCTGGCA TTTCGGTATG
1000
1790
bJO670
6bO
720
710
LBO700
690
RTCGRGGGAA TAGTAPACCC CAGCTACCCT ACAGATTTTA ATCTGTAGGG TAGCCTTATG GAATAGAGGR AAAAATTTTC
TAGCTCCCTT ATCATTTGGG GTCGATGGGA TGTCTAAAAT TAGACRTCCC ATCGGMTPlCCTTATCTCCTTTTTTRAAAG
7so
740
730
800
CTARCGTAAA TACCTTAATG CCTCCCAGGA GATAAGTATCATTGATGTTA
GATTGCATTTATGGAATTAC
GGAGGGTCCT CTATTCPTAGTARCTACART
TCCTAGTACC TATTTTCACC TPlTAATCACT
RGGATCATGG ATAAAAGTGG ATATTAGTGA
010
020
030
840
050
070
860
000
TGTCGCTGAT AAGCTRGCGC AGGTGCGCTG GTGCCTTGRC CCCGGATGGT CGTATTTTTCCTACTRTTGA
CGAGGGTATT
ACAGCGRCTA TTCGATCGCG TCCRCGCGAC CACGGAACTG GGGCCTRCCA GCATAAAAAG GATGATAACT GCTCCCRTAA
910
900
970
1210
I270
I240 1260 1250
1200
TTCTAGTCTT M G P C T T C T GTPCTTCGCA ACCCCCTCCT TTGCAATTAA GCRRRGGffiG GGGGTAGARG GAGTTTTRTG
CGTTTCCTCC CCCCATCTTC CTCAAPATAC
W T C A W A T T T C T G M P CATOMGCGTTGGGffiR00AAPCGTTARTT
1290
1300
1310
1320
1330 1350 1340
13bO
ffiTATATTAC TTGTTAAACC TCCTCPACAC TAATTAGCGR CCCCTATTCC TCGGGTCGCT GTAAAATTRG TGRRCAGAAG
TCATRTAATG AACPATTTGG AGGPGTTGTG ATTAATCGCT GGGGATAAGG AGCCCRGCGA CATTTTRATCACTTGTCTTC
1390
I400
1300
1410
I420
1430
1440
1370
CCTTTGPWG CTCCTTTCAA TATTAGAACR GTMTGTGGT TATCACCRAT A!ATATGTAAG TCIATACCCG GAGACGGCTC
G W A C T T C C GAGGPJIAGTT ATRATCTTGT CATTACRCCA ATAGTGGTTA TTATRCATTC AGTTATGGGC CTCTGCCGAG
1450
1460
1470
I400
1490
IS00 1520 I510
TGGPdGIITAG RTTTGAGGTC TGTGGATTTTTATAAAAGAACGTTTGATRA
AATAGACAAA GGAGGATTAA TTATGGTTAA
PCCTTCTPTCTAAACTCCAG
ACRCCTAAAA ATATTTTCTTGCAAACTATTTTATCTGTTTCCTCCTAATT
AATACCRATT
1530
1540 1560 1550
1570
1500
1590
1600
AGTTATTATR CCGGACAATA RCTAATTTTA ATTTCATRTTTTTCCTGTAA
GTGTCGGTAA CACTTACTRG AGCCGCAAGG
TCAATARTRT GGCCTGTTAT TGATTAAAATTAAAGTATRA
AAAGGACATT CACAGCCATT GTGAPTGATC TCGGCGTTCC
I620
1610
I650
1660
I670
1600
CGTCTATTTT ATTAARCCCC TTGTCTTTTT TAGGATCTTC AGATTTTGAGTTGAAGTTAA
TGAGAACTCG AAGGGGTTGA
GCPGATAAAA TPATTTGGGG RRCRGRAAAA ATCCTAGAAG TCTAAAACTC WCTTCAATT RCTCTTGPGC TTCCCCAACT
1700
1690
1740
1750
1760
CCTPTGTATT ATCGGAGTCA TGGTGCCACA GAACGATAGG GTCCCCACAA CGAAGTTGTG GGGTCCCCCG ATTTPlGTTCG
GGATACATAA TRGCCTCAGT ACCACGGTGT CTTGCTATCC CAGGGGTGTT GCTTCAACAC CCCAGGGGGC TAAATCAAGC
1700
1770
1010 1030
1820
I040
AGGWTTAGA AGGGAACCAA AGGRTCPTPT RAGTTGCAAT T T L T A C A T T T GATGTTGAAG &TCGRTGTAG PiClATTGTATA
TCCTTPATCT TCCCTTGGTT TCCTAGTATRTTCAPCGTTAAATATGTAAA
CTACRACTTC TAGCTACATC TTTAACATAT
1900
1850
lab0
1070
1910
I920
1000
1090
T G W T T G A G ACTTCGAGTA TTAGGTCCGG ATRATRCTCT ACTTTCCACT CGRCCCCCCC TCACCAATCT TACTTRAACT
RCTTTAACTC TGARGCTCAT AATCCAGGCC TATTRTGAGA TGRRAGGTGA GCTGGGGGGG AGTGGTTAGR ATGAAllTGA
1930
1940
1950
1960
1970
1900
1990
2000
CAAATGTTGA GGATCAGCAT TAGCRACTCR TTTAAAATCC TTGTGATCCT TCTTGAAATC TTTCAAATAT TTRAAATCAT
GTTTACAACT CCTAGTCGTR ATCGTTGAGT AAATTTTAGG AACACTAGGA AGRACTTTRG RAAGTTTATP AATTTTAGTR
2000 2070
2010 2060 2050
2020 2040 2030
090
CAATATCTAG GAGMRTTTC GRTTTCTCTRGGTAATATGA
GTTATAGATCCTCTTTAAAGCTPAAGAGATCCATTATACT
900
1220
990
DAGAGGTGTC AAAGATTCTCCTGATGTTTA
TTCTCCPCAG TTTCTRRGAGGPCTACRAAT
1000
ACCAGGCTTT GGCCCACTCC ATTGGGTATT RTCGGTTGAA
TGGTCCGAAA CCGGGTGAGG TRACCCRTAR TAGCCAACTT
IOIO
1020
1030
IO40
TCTCACCAGC CCCCTTCCCC CAACACCTTT CCCTGATATC CRCTAATAAG
AGAGTGGTCG GGGGAAGGGG GTTGTGGAAP GGGACTATAG GTGATTATTC
TRCTTTTATC AGATMAAAA ATTTCTTGATTTTGATCACTATTTCCATTTCCATTCGTTG
AAAATARTCG TGCTGCLATT
ATGAAAATAGTCTACTTTTTTAAAGAACTR
AAACTRGTGR TAARGGTAAA GGTAAGCAAC TTTTATTAGCACGACGTTW
2100 2090
2140
2110 2130 2120
TTAATGTGRT ATCTGGGCAA ATAAAAATTA ATCRTAATATARATATTTAC
W4lTPCAClA TAGACCCGTT T A T T T T T A A T TRGTATTATRTTTATAAATG
2150
2160
ACCCAATATC TCGRTTTGGC TTTTGTGTCG
TGGGTTATAG AGCTRAACCG AAAACPCAGC
2170
2100 2200 2190
1050
IObO
1070
IO80
1090
1100
Ill0
1120 AGTTTGGCGG GCCCTCATTC TATGCGTTCC TTGGGATACG GARTTC
TGGAAGTCCT TGGTTATCAACTCAATTTTG
TTCGTAGCCT CTATTTTAAG ATRAGCCACC CCGGAGGGGT G G A ~ C T T A T T TCAAACCGCC CGGGAGTARG ATACGCAAGG AACCCTATGC CTTAAG
KCTTCAGGA ACCAATAGTTGAGTTAAAAC
AAGCATCGGA GATAAAATTC TATTCGGTGG GGCCTCCCCA CCTTGAATAP
1130
1140
1190
1200
1150
IIbO
1170
1100
GAGATTITAG GAAAGGTRAA RTTAGCAGTT AGCTGGATTC TCATGGRAGA ARTCCGATCT TAGTTCTTTG TTGCAAGGAT
CTCTAAAATC CTTTCCATTT TAATCGTCAA TCGRCCTAAG AGTACCTTCT TTAGGCTAGR RTCAAGRRAC AACGTTCCTR
FIGURE4.-DNA sequence of the long BcoR1-9 fragment. Numbering begins at the EcoRI site adjacent to the EcoRI-8 fragment (see
Figure 7 ) . T h e positions of the 7 8 base pair repeats are indicated by square brackets. T h e sequence of the shorter form of the fragment is
identical except that it contains only 2 copies of the 7 8 base pair repeat. T h e start (ATG) and stop (TAA) codons of the longest O R F in the
sequence are indicated by solid circles above the bases.
and NARGANC 1986;this study). The EcoRI-5 fragment of Neurospora mtDNA contains the NDI gene
(formerly URFl, BURGER
and WERNER 1985). Here
we show that the short form lacks the intron present
in the NDl gene of the large form, precisely at the
splice points predicted previously (BURGER
and WERNER 1985). T h e intron of the ND1 gene contains a
long ORF of 304 amino acids (BURGER
and WERNER
1985;Figure3)
andthe rapid conversion tothe
longer, intron-containing form is thus reminiscent of
the geneconversion events observedin other systems,
whereintronencodedproteinspromoteunidirectional conversion of alleles lacking introns into introncontaining alleles. Examples include the omega UACQUIER and DUJON1985; MACREADIEet al. 1985) and
al4alpha (WENZLAU
et al. 1989;DELAHODDEet al.
1989) systemsinyeast
mtDNA, the nuclear rDNA
group I intron of Physarum (MUSCARELLAand VOGT
1989), and the td and sunY introns of bacteriophage
DISCUSSION
T 4 (QUIRK, BELL-PEDERSEN
and BELFORT
1989). T h e
intronic ORFs in these systems are known to encode
In all studies on the behavior of Neurospora mtproteins with double stranded endonuclease activity
DNAs in heterokaryons, the complete conversion of
and it seems likely that the Neurospora NDl intronic
short EcoRI-5 fragments to the longer formhas been
observed (MANNELLA
and LAMBOWITZ 1979; LEMIRE ORF encodes a similar function.
repeat units in EcoRI-9, is shown in Figure 5. At the
nucleotide level, a regionof 144 base pairs of the ND2
gene is homologous to a similar region of EcoRI-9
with identity at 141 of those positions (Figure 6). The
region of identity begins precisely at the start of the
last 78 base pair repeat unit and includes the entire
repeat unit plus an additional 66 base pairs. Thus, of
the 47 amino acids homologous to the ND2 gene, 25
are encoded within the repeat unit (Fig. 6). We could
find no similarity in the sequences, at either the nucleotide or the amino acid levels, outside this short
region of identity.
Shorter ORFs found in the EcoRI-9 fragment were
compared to proteins in release number 20 of the
National Biomedical Research Foundation(NBRF)
database. The analysis revealed no striking similarities.
Heterokaryons of Neurospora crassa
69
78 bp repats
y
5y
1000
*
1500
I
2000
f
I
I
I
EC0Rl-g
(long version)
2000
500
P"
FIGURE 5,"Homologybetween the BcoRI-9 fragment and the ND2 gene (formerly URFP, DE VRIES et al. 1986) of N . crassa. The lower
right hand corner contains a representation of the circular Neurospora mtDNA with the location of EcoRI fragments indicated. The filled
portions of the circle indicate the location of the EcoRI-9 fragment and restriction fragment HindIII-9 which is found at thejunction of the
I:'coKI-l and -2 fragments. The N D 2 gene is found within the HindllI-9restriction fragment. Solid lines represent each restriction fragment.
The position of the N D 2 gene is shown beneath the HindIII-9 fragment as a cross-hatched box. The numbering of the N D 2 gene sequence
is consistent with DE VRIESet al. (1986). The position of the longest ORF in EcoRI-9 is shown below the EcoRI-9 fragment as a cross-hatched
box. The region of homology between the two is indicated by the vertical dashed lines. The position of the three 78-base-pair repeats in the
type I form of EcoR1-9 is also indicated. The region of homology begins precisely at the start of the third repeat.
Repeat 1
Ecm-9
om:
Q
I
T V V G L
TGTTGTAGGTTTA
TAATMTAGGAACTGTTGTAGGTTTA
AGCTGAATCTACGGACTACTAGTCAGTTCTTTTCTTTCCT
I I G T V V G L
S W I Y G L L V S S F L S L
F
R
I
X
R
L
L
A
Y
S
T
I
S
H
F
T
G
L L A
T T T A M
T ~ T A A A A G A T T G C
L L A Y S T I S B L G F I L
mTTTmTTAAUGATTGCTTGCATATAGTATAGTACAATCTCTCATC
A
I
...
mz
T
Repeat 3
Repeat 2
~ T T ~ T
Q F R I K
A
R
I
L S
A T T
T C
L A
J
V S
A G C T C C
T ~ T C
L S V F
T
~
W E E W N Y R E I X I V e n d
Q A F I F GGGAGGAGTGAAATTACAGGGAGKTTAAAATAGTTTAA
A C A C A M C T G T G G A G T C C T T T
ACACAMCTGTAGAGTCTACACAAGCATTTTATATTTT
T Q S V E S T Q A F I F ATTTAATACAATA~TATTCTTTTACTAATTTAAATCTCTfi.
Y L I Q Y S F S N L N V F
..
FIGURE
6.-Homology between the EcoRI-9 fragment (top)and the N D 2 gene (bottom). The long form of EcoRI-9 containing three repeat
units is shown i n the figure. The two DNA sequences are aligned closely where they are homologous and farther apart where the sequences
differ. Amino acids are shown i n the one letter code. For EcoRI-9, the entire region that encodes the longest ORF in the sequence is shown,
except that the nucleotide and amino acid sequences within the 78 base pair repeats are shown only in the third repeat and at the repeat
junctions. The sequences within the other repeat units are identical to the third repeat. The location of the repeat units is indicated. Arrows
indicate mismatched bases in the region of homology. Only the sequence homologous to the EcoRI-9 fragment, plus a few flanking nucleotides,
is shown fox-the N D 2 gene. The N D 2 gene continues for 31 1 codons upstream, and 201 codons downstream of the region shown (DE VRIES
et al. 1986).
We have shown that thedifference between the two
forms of the EcoRI-9 fragment is the numberof copies
of a 78-base-pair repeat. One copy of this repeat, plus
an additional 66 base pairs of downstream sequence,
has been derived from the
N D 2 gene, which is located
in a distant region of the mitochondrial genome (Figure 7). It appears that either during or following the
transfer of sequence from the N D 2 gene, a region of
that sequence was duplicated to give rise to the 78base-pair repeats. That originalevent probably resulted in the generation of either two or threecopies.
In either case a separate eventmust have occurred to
give rise to thetwo separate polymorphic forms of the
EcoRI-9 fragment. Sequencesin or near theN D 2 gene
~
A
A. Hawse, R. A. Collins and F. E. Nargang
70
II
ORF
I
t m w t
\
[mi-31
mutation
FIGI‘RE 7.-(;ircuhr
representation of the Neurospora mitochondrial genome. The outer circle shows the position of genes
discussed in the text.Solid black portions represent exons andwhite
portions represent introns. The inner circle shows the EcoRl fragnlents of the mtDNA. The regions designated “A” and “B”,which
are indicated above the N D 2 gene regionof the map. represent the
sequences which have been duplicated a t other positions in the
mtDNA where they are shown a s open boxes on the outer circle.
The sm;lllblack rectangle outsidetheouter circle indicates the
position of the directly repeated units in the EcoRI-9 fragment. The
psition ofthe intronic O K F which encompasses virtually the entire
intron of the AID1 gene(BURGERandWERNER1985), andthe
position of the [mi-31 mutation in the C O X 1 gene (LEMIREand
1986) are also shown.
NARGANG
may be sites of high frequency recombination since
deletions in various stopper mutants of Neurospora
have been shown to begin near the location of this
et al. 1980; GROSS,HSIEHand LEVgene (BERTRAND
INE 1984; DE VRIES et al. 1986). Furthermore, the
amino-terminalportion of the ND2 geneandthe
upstreamtRNAmetgene,
normally foundatthe
junction of the EcoRI-1 and EcoRI-2 fragments, have
also been shown to be duplicated at the junction of
the EcoRI-1 and EcoRI-6 fragments (ACSTERIRBE,
HARTOG,and DE VRIES, 1989; See Fig. 7), although
the sequences found in the latter duplication do not
include those foundin the EcoRI-9 duplication. Nonetheless, sequences from the ND2 region of the mtDNA
appear to behave in a fashion that is in some senses
reminiscent of the GC-rich clusters in yeast mtDNA
(DE ZAMAROCZYand BERNARDI1986), which are
thought to spread through the
yeast mitochondrial
genome by processes such as transposition and gene
and GROSSMAN1985;
conversion (BUTOW,PERLMAN
WEILLER,
SCHUELLER
and SCHWEYEN
1989). GC-rich
clusters havealso been shown to be sites of both intraand intermolecularrecombination inyeast mtDNA
molecules (DE ZAMAROCZY, FAUGERON-FONTY
and
BERNARDI1983; DIECKMANNand GANDY 1987;
CLARK-WALKER
1989).
Our results with respect to the resolution of the
short and long EcoRI-9 fragments differ from those
and LAMROWITZ
( 1 979). In their studies
of MANNELLA
of “[poky]plus wild-type” heterokaryons, the majority
(25 of 34) resolved to the long form of EcoRI-9 and
the remainder to the short form. The combined data
of the present study and of LEMIREand NARGANC
( 1 986) show that only 9 of 30 “ [ m i - ) ] plus wild-type”
heterokaryons resolved to the long form of EcoRI-9,
while 21 of 30 resolved to the short version of the
fragment. Thus, in our study,a process involving
directional conversion of the short to the long form
of EcoRI-9 does not seem to have occurred. Interestingly, despite evidence that efficient mixing of mtDNAs occurred (see RESULTS), we recovered only
eight recombinant mtDNAs from twenty heterokaryons, while in the study of MANNELLAand LAMBOWITZ
( 1 979), almost all heterokaryon mtDNAs resolved to
recombinants. Therefore, a possible explanation for
the differences observed in the two sets of studies is
that less overall mtDNA recombination has occurred
with our heterokaryon pair. Conceivably, the strains
usedin the present study could be
less efficient in
either the promotion of exchange between mtDNA
molecules, or a specific gene conversion process, than
the strains used in previous studies.
Our data show that [mi-31 mitochondria are less
dominant over wild-type mitochondria than are the
mitochondria of the [poky] mutant. In fact, only seven
of twenty heterokaryons acquired the [mi-3] phenotype under conditions of conidial passage similar to
those used in at least one of the previous studies where
ten of ten heterokaryons became [poky] (MANNELLA
and LAMBOWITZ
1978). There are a number of possible explanations for the different behaviorof [mi-31
and [poky] mitochondria in heterokaryons with wildtype mitochondria. First, it is conceivable that small
differences in the nuclear genetic backgroundsof the
strains involved in the various studies might influence
the process of takeover by mutantmitochondria.
However, it is difficult to imagine a mechanism
whereby particular nuclear gene products would discern differences in mutant and wild-type mitochondria andfavor the propagation of one over the other.
Second, it is possible that conversion to the long form
of the NDI gene (in EcoRI-5), from the wild-type
mtDNA componentof o u r heterokaryons, sometimes
extends 4 kilobases into the region of mtDNA where
the [mi-31 mutation is found, andco-converts it to the
wild-type allele. However, unless co-conversion in
Neurospora extends for much greater distances than
in other genomes (DUJON, SLONIMSKIand WEILL
1974; JACQUIERand DUJON 1985; WENZLAUet al.
1989; BELL-PEDERSEN
et al. 1989), this is unlikely.
Third, given thattheparental,
wild-type, type I1
mtDNA was the form most frequently recovered, the
infrequent takeoverby the [mi-31 phenotype might be
Heterokaryons of Neurospora crassa
explained if type I1 mtDNA had a replicative advantage over the type I mtDNA which carries the [mi-31
mutation in our heterokaryons.However,alarge
difference in the rates of replication between the two
mtDNAs is not likely since our data provide evidence
that mixtures of the two input formsof mtDNA persist
in the heterokaryons for many cycles of subculturing.
A fourth possibility is that the mechanism of propagating the heterokaryons could influence the degree
of takeover by different mutant mitochondria. For
example, if cells that have come to contain predominantly [mi-31 mitochondria produce conidia less efficiently than cells that are predominantly wild-type,
possibly due to defects in energy metabolism, then
there would bea selective advantagefor wild-type
cells during theprocess of conidial passage that would
not occur during propagation by continuous growth.
However, this seems an unlikely explanation given
that conidial passage of heterokaryonsconstructed
with the [poky] mutant, which should suffer similar
defects in energy metabolism, all became [poky] (MANNELLA and LAMBOWITZ,
1978). Furthermore, it is
doubtful that othermethods of propagation are more
efficient at producing takeover by cytochrome uu3deficient mutantslike [mi-31,since in a previous search
for cytoplasmic mutants from continuously growing
cultures, only "poky-like'' mutants, deficient in both
cytochromes uu3 and b, were obtained (BERTRAND
and
PITTENGER
1969).
The latter observation suggests a fifth possible explanation for the different behaviorof the [poky] and
[mi-?] mutants in heterokaryons. The most likely defect in mutants that lack both cytochromes uu3 and b
is a deficiency of mitochondrial proteinsynthesis (COLLINS and BERTRAND
1978). The mutation in [poky] is
known to affect mitochondrial protein synthesis and
has been characterized as a four base pair deletion in
the codingsequencefor
the mitochondrial small
rRNA (AKINSand LAMBOWITZ
1984).In [mi-?], a
missense mutation affects the codingsequence for
subunit 1 of cytochrome c oxidase (LEMIRE
and NARGANG 1986). Regulationof mtDNA replication in [mi?] and [poky] could be affected differently if a previously postulated mitochondrial repressor of replication was translated in mitochondria (BARATHand
KUNTZEL 1972; AKINS and LAMBOWITZ
1984). The
production of such a repressor would be less efficient
in [poky] than in [mi-31 and [poky] mtDNA would be
expected to replicate morerapidly than [mi-)] or wildtype mtDNA. Thus, in heterokaryons, mitochondria
containing a higher ratioof [poky] mtDNA molecules
mightbeexpectedto
have ahigher rate of DNA
replication. This model would predict that all mitochondrial mutants that affect mitochondrial protein
synthesis in Neurospora would bemoredominant
than those that affect single components involved in
71
oxidative phosphorylation. The notion that mutations
not affecting mitochondrial protein synthesis are not
as strongly dominantas [ p o k y ] might also explain why
only two mitochondrialmutantsthat
do not affect
both cytochromes uug and 6, namely [mi-)] and [exn51, have been described in Neurospora to date.
In yeast it has been shown that the frequency of an
allele within the mitochondrial population of genes
depends on the input frequency, random drift, and
random segregation of the mitochondria into daughter cells (BACKER
and BIRKY1985). Similarly, in Neurospora mtDNA, these factors may be all that govern
the fixing of mutations that affect genes not involved
in mitochondrial protein synthesis. Perhaps the most
parsimonious interpretation of our results is that the
above random factors also determine the frequency
of recovery of the [mi-31 mutation in N . crussu heterokaryons.
This work was supported by grants from the Natural Sciences
and Engineering Research Council of Canada to F.E.N. and R.A.C.
A.H. was supported by a postgraduate scholarship from the Alberta
Heritage Foundation for Medical Research. We are grateful to P.
HASTINGSand E. LEMIRE for helpful discussion.
LITERATURE CITED
AGSTERIBBE,
E., M. HARTOGand H. DE VRIES,1989 Duplication
of the tRNAM" and
tRNA"Ys genes and of fragments
of a gene
encoding a subunit of the NADH dehydrogenase complex in
Neurosporacrassa mitochondrial DNA. Curr. Genet. 15: 5762.
AKINS, R. A., andA. M. LAMBOWITZ,
1984 The [poky] mutant of
Neurospora contains a 4-base-pair deletion at the 5' end of the
mitochondrial small rRNA.Proc.Natl.Acad.
Sci. USA 81:
3791-3795.
BACKER,
J. S., and C. W. BIRKY, JR., 1985 The origin of mutant
cells: mechanism by which Saccharomyces cerevisiae produces
cells homoplasmicfornewmitochondrialmutations.Curr.
Gene. 10: 7-13.
BARATH,Z., and H. KUNTZEL,1972Cooperationofmitochondrial and nuclear genes specifying the mitochondrial genetic
apparatus in Neurospora crassa. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA 69:
1371-1374.
BELL-PEDERSEN,
D., S. M. QUIRK,M. AUBREY andM. BELFORT,
1989 A site-specific endonuclease and co-conversion of flanking exons associated with the mobile td intron of phage T4.
Gene 82: 119-126.
BERNARD,U.,A.PUHLER,
F. MAYERandH.
KUNTZEL, 1985
Denaturation map of the circular mitochondrial genome of
Neurospora crassa. Biochim. Biophys. Acta 402: 270-278.
BERTRAND, H., and
T . H. PITTENGER,1969 Cytoplasmic mutants
selectedfromcontinuouslygrowingculturesof
Neurospora
crassa. Genetics 61: 643-659,
BERTRAND, H., R.A. COLLINS, L. L. STOHL,R. R. GOEWERT and
A. M. LAMBOWITZ,1980 Deletionmutants of Neurospora
crassa mitochondrial DNA and their relationship to the "stopstart" growth phenotype. Proc. Natl. Acad.
Sci. USA 77: 60326036.
BURGER,G., and S. WERNER,1985ThemitochondrialURFl
gene in Neurospora crassa has an intron that contains a novel
type of URF. J. Mol. Biol. 1 8 6 231-242.
BUTOW,R.A.,P.
S. PerlmanandL.
I. GROSSMAN,1985 The
unusual v a r l gene of yeast mitochondria DNA. Science 228:
1496-1501.
72
A. Hawse, R. A. Collins and F. E. Nargang
CHOMYN, A,,P. MARIOTTINI,
M. W. J. CLEETER, C.I. RAGAN,A.
MATSUNO-YAGI,
Y. HATEFI, R.F. DOOLITTLE
and G. ATTARDI,
1985 Six unidentified readingframes of humanmitochondrial DNA encode componentsof the respiratory-chain NADH
dehydrogenase. Nature 314 592-597.
CLARK-WALKER,D.,
G. 1989 I n vivo rearrangement of mitochondrial DNA in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Proc. Natl.Acad. Sci.
USA 8 6 8847-8851.
COLLINS,R. A,, and H. BERTRAND, 1978 Nuclear suppressors of
the [ p o k y ]cytotplasmic mutant of Neurospora crassa. 111. Effects
on other cytoplasmic nlutants and on ribosome
assembly in
[poky]. Mol. Gen. Genet. 161: 267-273.
DAVIS,R. H., and F. J. DE SERRES,1979 Genetic and microbiological research techniques for Neurospora crassa. Methods En7ymol. 17A:79-143.
DELAHODDE, A,, V. GOGUEL,
A. M. BECAM,F. CREUSOT,
J. PEREA,
J. BANROQUES
and C. JACQ, 1989 Site-specific DNA endonuclear and RNA tnaturase activities of two homologous intronencoded proteins from yeast mitochondria. Cell 56: 431-441.
C. A. BREITENBERGER,
DE VRIES,H., B. ALZNER-DEWEERD,
D. D.
CHANCJ. C. DE JONGE and U. L. RAJBHANDARY, 1986T h e
E35 stopper mutant of Neurospora crassa: precise localization
of deletion endpoints i n mitochondrial DNA and evidence that
the deletedDNA codes for a subunit of NADH dehydrogenase.
EMBO J . 5: 779-785.
DE ZAMAROCZY,M., and G. BERNARDI, 1986 T h e GC clusters of
the mitochondrial genome of yeast andtheirevolutionary
origin. Gene 41: 1-22.
D E ZAMAROCZY, M., G. FAUGERON-FONTY
andG. BERNARDI,
1983 Excision sequences in themitochondrialgenome
of
veast. Gene 21: 193-202.
DIECKMANN, C., and
B. CANDY,
1987 Preferential recombination
between GC clusters in yeast mitochondrial DNA. EMBO J. 6
4 197-4203,
DIACUMAKOS,
E. G., L. GARNJOBST
and E. L. TATUM,
1965 A
cytoplasmic character in Neurospora crassa, the role of nuclei
and mitochondria. J.Cell Biol. 26: 427-443.
DUJON,B., P. P. SLONIMSKI
and L. WEILL, 1974 Mitochondrial
genetics IX. A model for recombination and segregation of
mitochondrial genomes in Saccharomyces cerevisiae. Genetics 7 8
4 15-437.
GARNJOBST,
L., J. F. WILSONand E. L. TATUM, 1965 Studies on
a cytoplasmic character in Neurospora crassa. J. Cell Biol. 26:
4 13-425.
GROSS,S. R.,T-s. HSIEH and P. H. LEVINE, 1984 Intramolecular
recombination its a source of mitochondrial chromosome heteromorphism in Neurospora. Cell 38: 233-239.
JACQUIER, A,, andB. DUJON,1985 An intron-encoded protein is
active i n a gene conversion process that spreads an intron into
a mitochondrial gene. Cell 41: 383-394.
LAMROWITL,
A. M., 1979 Preparation and
analysis of mitochondrial ribosomes. Methods Enzytnol. 59: 421-433.
LEMIRE,E. G., and F. E. NARGANC, 1986A missense mutation in
the 0x2-3 gene of the [mi-3] extranuclear mutant ofNeurospora
crassa. J. Biol. Chem. 261: 5610-5615.
MACREADIE,
I. G., R. M. SCOTT,A . R. ZINN and R. A . BUTOW,
of anintron in yeast mitochondria re1985Transposition
quires a protein encoded by that intron. Cell 41: 395-402.
MANIATIS,T . , E. F.FRITSCH and J. SAMBROOK, 1982Molecular
Cloning. A Laboratory Manual. Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory,
Cold Spring Harbor, NY.
1978Interaction
of
MANNELLA,
C. A,,and A. M . LAMBOWITZ,
wild-type and [poky] mitochondrial DNA in heterokaryons of
Neurospora. Biochem. Biophys. Res. Commun. 80: 673-679.
C. A,,and A. M . LAMBOWITZ,
1979 Unidirectional
MANNELLA,
gene conversion associated with two insertions in Neurospora
crassa mitochondrial DNA. Genetics 93: 645-654.
MESSING,J.,1983
New M I 3 vectors for cloning. Methods Enzymol. 101: 20-78.
MITCHELL,M. B., H. K. MITCHELLand A. TISSIERES, 1953
Mendelian and non-Mendelian factorsaffectingthe
cytochrome system Neurospora crassa. Proc. Natl. Acad. Sci. USA
39: 606-613.
MUSCARELLA,
D.D., and V. M. VOGT, 1989 A mobile group I
intron in the nuclear rDNA ofPhysarum polycephalum. Cell 56:
443-454.
NARGANG,
F. E., andH. BERTRAND,1978Nuclearmutantsof
Neurospora crassa temperature-sensitiveforthe
synthesis of
cytochrome aa: