© 2016 - U.S. Legal Forms, Inc
USLegal Guide to
Disabled Adults
T YPES OF D ISABILITIES
Partial Disability:
Partial disability is the
result of an injury which
permanently impairs a
person's ability to
function, but still allows
the person to work or
participate in other
activities. In worker's
compensation cases, an
injured worker is often
awarded a percentage
rating of permanent
partial disability, which
will entitle him/her to a
money settlement. The
percentage of disability
compensation is often
based on a physician's
evaluation of what
percentage of the
person's normal
functioning is gone.
Some states have a
workers' insurance fund
in which partial
disability benefits are
paid when an employee
returns to work, or is
medically able to
perform currently
available work as
determined by an
agreement or a judge's
decision, but at wages which are lower than the
employee's earnings
prior to the injury.
Partial disability may
mean a person is able to
perform one or more,
but not all, of the
material and substantial
duties of their own or
any other occupation on
a full time or a part time
basis; or able to perform
all of the material and
substantial duties of
their own or any other
occupation on a part-
time basis.
Permanent Disability:
Permanent disability an
injury which impairs the
physical and/or mental
ability of a person to the
extent that they are
never again able to
resume his/her normal
work or non-
occupational activities.
Permanent disability is
that disability or
impairment that remains
after the employee has
reached the point of
maximum healing.
Under worker's
compensation laws, once
the condition is stable, a
degree of permanent
disability is established
even if the employee is
able to work despite the
physical problem.
Permanent disability
general damages may be
awarded in a lawsuit for injury suffered due to
the negligence or
intentional act of
another. Permanent
disability ratings are
provided under the law
in the form of money
payments, the amount of
which depends on a
number of factors,
including the injured’s
age, occupation, and the
extent of disability. The
rating can range from
1% to 100% depending
on how the permanent
disability interferes with
the ability to engage in
work. A total disability
for any type of work
carries a 100% rating
Total Disability:
Total disability is a term
used in insurance law to
refer to an injury which
impairs the physical
and/or mental ability of
a person to the extent
that they are never again
able to resume his/her
normal work or non-
occupational activities.
Total disability is that
disability or impairment
that remains after the
employee has reached
the point of maximum
healing.
Under this definition,
this means that as long
as the insured is unable
to perform the duties of
his/her own occupation,
they will be able to
collect full total
disability, even if they
were working in another
occupation and earning
income. Some insurers
vary the definition of
total disability coverage
to exclude benefits for
those who chose to work
in another occupation.
Temporary Disability:
Temporary disability is
defined as a physical or
mental disability which
hampers your
discharging of
responsibilities for a
short period of time. The
federal government
passed the Family &
Medical Leave Act in
1992 which provides
some job protections for
persons who must take
time off for medical
reasons. Employees
covered under the law
may access the
protections if they must
take time off due to
either their own medical
condition or to care for a
spouse, child or parent
who is seriously ill.
Benefits are also
available at the birth or
adoption of a child.
Mental Disability:
A mental disability is
typically defined as: (1)
having a mental or
psychological disorder
or condition that limits a
major life activity, including working; (2)
any other mental or
psychological disorder
or condition that
requires special
education or related
services; (3) having a
record or history of a
mental or psychological
disorder or condition
which is known to the
employer or other entity
covered by this part; or
(4) being regarded or
treated by the employer
as having, or having
had, any mental
condition that makes
achievement of a major
life activity difficult.
S OCIAL S ECURITY
Under the Social
Security Act, disability
is defined as the
inability to engage in
any substantial gainful
activity due to any
medically determinable
physical or mental
impairment which can
result in death or which
has lasted or can last for
a continuous period not
less than 1 year.
A MERICANS W ITH
D ISABILITIES A CT
The Americans with
Disabilities Act (ADA)
of 1990 is one of the
most significant federal
laws governing
discrimination against
persons with disabilities. This Act prohibits
discrimination against
individuals with
disabilities in
employment, housing,
education, and access to
public services. The
ADA defines a disability
as any of the following:
1. "a physical or mental
impairment that
substantially limits one
or more of the major life
activities of the
individual." 2. "a record
of such impairment." or
3. "being regarded as
having such an
impairment." While
alcoholism is included
as a disability, other
socially undesirable
behaviors, such as
pedophilia, or
transvestism,
compulsive gambling,
and pyromania, are
excluded from the Act.
The ADA requires that
reasonable
accommodation be made
so as to provide
individuals with
disabilities equal
opportunities. Barriers to
employment,
transportation, public
accommodations, public
services, and
telecommunications for
persons with disabilities
are prohibited. The
Equal Employment
Opportunity
Commission (EEOC)
and the Department of
Justice are charged with
enforcement of the
ADA.
States may pass
disability statutes so
long as they do not
conflict with the ADA.
President George H.
Bush signed the ADA
into law on July 26,
1990. The legal structure
of the ADA is based on
the Civil Rights Act of
1964 and the
Rehabilitation Act of
1973. The ADA uses
concepts of disability,
accessibility, and
employment which were
introduced in the
Architectural Barriers
Act of 1968 and the
Rehabilitation Act of
1973. These two federal
laws were the
predecessors of the
ADA that mandated a
level of accessibility in
federally funded
buildings and programs.
The ADA expanded the
requirements of
accessibility to the new
and existing facilities of
privately funded
companies for the first
time.
The ADA consists of
five separate parts or
titles: Title I relates to
employment; Title II
concerns public
services; Title III pertains to public
accommodations and
commercial facilities;
Title IV refers to
telecommunications; and
Title V covers
miscellaneous other
items.
Title I of the ADA
prohibits discrimination
in employment against
qualified individuals
with disabilities. For
companies with 25 or
more employees, the
requirements became
effective on July 26,
1992. For employers
with between 15 and 24
workers, the
requirements became
effective on July 26,
1994.
Title II of the ADA
prohibits discrimination
in programs, services, or
activities of public
entities (state and local
governments), including
public transportation
operated by public
entities. The provisions
of Title II which do not
involve public
transportation became
effective on January 26,
1992.
Title III, pertaining to
public accommodations
and commercial
facilities, requires that
private businesses that
are places of "public accommodation"—
including restaurants,
health clubs, department
stores, convenience
stores and specialty
shops, and hotels and
motels—allow
individuals with
disabilities to participate
equally in the goods and
services that they offer.
This title also requires
that all future
construction of
commercial facilities—
including office
buildings, factories, and
warehouses—and places
of public
accommodation be
constructed so that the
building is accessible to
individuals with
disabilities.
Title III also mandates
modifications in
policies, practices, and
procedures. Commercial
businesses and places of
public accommodation
are required to provide
auxiliary aids and
services, and to make
accessible transportation
available when
transportation services
are offered. In addition,
companies are required
to remove architectural
and communications
barriers and to comply
with ADA in any
ongoing or new
construction. The Act
stipulates that all fixed-
route or on-demand
transportation services—
such as hotel-to-airport
and other shuttle
services—be accessible
to persons in
wheelchairs and other
disabled individuals.
Title IV of the ADA
requires telephone
companies to make relay
services available for
persons with hearing and
speech impairments.
Title V ties the ADA to
the Civil Rights Act of
1974 and its
amendments. It includes
a variety of
miscellaneous legal and
technical provisions,
including one that
stipulates that the ADA
does not override or
limit the remedies,
rights, or procedures of
any federal, state, or
local law which provides
greater or equal
protection for the rights
of individuals with
disabilities.
The ADA draws an
important distinction
between the terms
"reasonable
accommodations" and
"readily achievable." For
small businesses and
other employers, no
modifications to their
facilities must be
undertaken to fulfill the requirements of the
ADA until a qualified
individual with a
disability has been hired.
At that point,
"reasonable
accommodations" must
be made unless they
impose a significant
difficulty or expense. In
contrast, the terminology
"readily achievable"
refers to business
obligations to clients or
guests and applies to
actions that can be
accomplished without
much difficulty or
expense. "Readily
achievable"
modifications must be
made in anticipation of a
disabled guest's or
client's needs, before he
or she ever arrives on
the premises.
Compliance with the
various provisions of the
Americans with
Disabilities Act also lies
with both landlord and
tenant, so either or both
parties may be held
legally liable for
violations of the ADA.
Assignation of ADA
responsibilities is
generally made via the
lease agreement. Small
business owners who
lease their office space
or other place of
business, then, should
examine these
agreements closely. The fastest-growing area
of legal activity relating
to the Americans with
Disabilities Act
concerns mentally
disabled employees.
Claims that businesses
failed to accommodate
their employees'
psychological problems
according to the
provisions of the ADA
grew rapidly in the late
1990s but stabilized in
the early years of the
2000s at around 13 to 14
percent of all ADA
claims received by the
Equal Employment
Opportunity
Commission. Under the
original language of the
ADA, the Act applied a
higher standard for legal
redress to individuals
whose disabilities
stemmed from "any
mental or psychological
disorder." But legislative
efforts to eliminate this
higher standard have
intensified in recent
years.
Problems associated
with mentally disabled
employees may include
workplace socialization
difficulties, limited
stamina, irregular
attendance, difficulty
dealing with stress or
criticism, and limited
attention spans. But
many experts in both the
mental health and
business fields insist that
the mentally disabled
can be valuable
additions to the
workforce if companies
provide appropriate
accommodations.
One valuable tool that
business owners and
managers can utilize in
establishing and
maintaining a productive
work environment for
mentally disabled
employees is the EEOC
Enforcement Guidance,
a comprehensive legal
guidebook issued in
1997. As Business
Horizons points out, the
Guidance stipulates that
"traits or behaviors are
not, in themselves,
mental impairments.
This means that stress
does not automatically
indicate a mental
impairment, although it
may be a symptom.
Similarly, such traits as
irritability, chronic
lateness, and poor
judgment are not, in
themselves, mental
impairments, although
they may be linked to
them." Legitimate
mental disabilities do,
however, include major
depression, bipolar
disorder, various anxiety
disorders, schizophrenia,
mental retardation, and special learning
disorders.
Under the ADA,
companies employing
mentally disabled
individuals are not
responsible for every
aspect of the employees'
behavior. For instance,
they are not required to
relieve employees of
work responsibilities or
excuse them from
violations of established
work policies. Nor are
they required to employ
workers who are deemed
a safety threat.
Moreover, employers
are not legally
responsible for mental
disabilities of which
they are unaware.
But employers are
required under ADA law
to make "reasonable
accommodations" for
mentally disabled
employees. These may
include leaves of
absence; minor
modifications in work
policy, supervision, or
job position; or flexible
work schedules.
"Although the nature or
form of accommodation
is up to the employer,
and is only 'reasonable'
if it helps the employee
do a better job, in some
instances the employer
might wish to consider
professional assistance in the communication
process," wrote Robert
Schwartz, Frederick
Post, and Jack Simonetti
in Business Horizons.
"Managers should also
verify that the condition
qualifies as a psychiatric
disability and whether
the person can perform
the job's essential
functions with or
without accommodation.
Management can request
reasonable
documentation from a
health care professional
about the disability and
the need for
accommodations."
Compliance with the
ADA's mental disability
provisions can help
companies retain
productive employees
and protect themselves
from legal peril. But
"even beyond mere
compliance, socially
responsible businesses
may elect to embrace
these legal mandates as
changes that advance the
common good of
society," noted
Schwartz, Post, and
Simonetti. "By doing so,
they would be helping
millions of mentally ill
citizens become
gainfully employed and
saving society billions of
government dollars
spent supporting the
presently unemployed
mentally ill.
O THER L AWS
Other statutes
prohibiting
discrimination against
individuals with
disabilities include the
Fair Housing Act,
Rehabilitation Act, Air
Carrier Access Act, and
the Individuals with
Disabilities Education
Act. For example, under
the Fair Housing Act, it
is unlawful to
discriminate in any
aspect of selling,
renting, or denying
housing because of an
individual's disability.
Owners are further
required make some
exceptions to their
housing policies to
enable equal housing
opportunities to those
with disabilities. The
Individuals with
Disabilities Education
Act requires public
schools to make
available a free
appropriate public
education in the least
restrictive environment
to all eligible children
with disabilities,
according to their needs.
D ISABILITIES AND
E DUCATION
Section 504 of the
Rehabilitation Act of 1973 defines individuals
with disabilities as those
who have a physical or
mental impairment
which substantially
limits one or more major
life activities; has a
record of such
impairment; or is
regarded as having such
an impairment. This
category includes
physiological disorders
such as hearing
impairment, vision
impairment, or speech
impairments;
neurological disorders
such as muscular
dystrophy or multiple
sclerosis; psychological
disorders such as mental
retardation, mental
illness, or learning
disabilities. The
legislative definition
does not spell out
specific illnesses or
impairments because of
the difficulty of ensuring
an all-inclusive list.
The deciding factor in
determining whether or
not a person suffers
from a disability under
Section 504 is whether
the impairment limits
one or more major life
activities, such as
walking, performing
manual tasks, seeing,
hearing, speaking,
breathing, learning
and/or working. The
ADA defines a disability as a “physical or mental
impairment that
substantially limits one
or more major life
activity; a record of such
impairment; or being
regarded as having such
impairment.” The ADA
covers obvious
impairments such as
difficulty in seeing,
hearing, or learning, as
well as less obvious
impairments such as
alcoholism, epilepsy,
paralysis, mental
retardation, and
contagious and
noncontagious diseases,
specifically Acquired
Immune Deficiency
Syndrome (AIDS).
The difference between
the two laws, as they
apply to educational
institutions, is that
Section 504 applies to
the recipients of grant
monies from the federal
government, while Title
II of the ADA applies
only to public entities,
with some applications
to private sector entities.
These entities include
nursery, elementary,
secondary,
undergraduate, or
postgraduate schools, or
other places of
education, day care
centers, and
gymnasiums or other
places of exercise or
recreation.
Accommodations:
Section 504 of the
Rehabilitation Act of
1973 and Title II of the
ADA cover students in
virtually any public
school district, college,
or university because
they receive some form
of federal assistance.
Some private schools,
colleges, and
universities also receive
such assistance, and
students are protected
under Section 504, but
Title II does not apply to
them. Both laws apply to
all programs of a school
or college, not simply
academics. These
include extracurricular
activities such as band,
clubs, or academic
teams, as well as
athletics and any activity
that might occur off
campus.
Neither law requires that
all buildings be made
fully accessible to
students or teachers with
disabilities. Those
buildings constructed
after the Section 504
regulation was issued in
1977 must be fully
accessible. For older
buildings, the law
requires that the
program or activity be
made accessible. Often,
classes or extracurricular
activities are moved to another, more
accessible, room to
accommodate any
disabled person who
attends. An interpreter
for the hearing-impaired
or other types of
assistance can be
supplied.
One aim of the ADA
was to make educational
institutions more
accessible for the
disabled. This aim
covers “reasonable
accommodations” such
as the following:
■Modification of
application and testing
■Allowing students to
tape-record or videotape
lectures and classes
■Modification of class
schedules
■Extra time allotted
between classes
■Notetakers
■Interpreters
■Readers
■Specialized computer
equipment
■Special education
Accommodation also
includes physical
changes to an
educational institution’s
buildings, including the
following:
■Installing accessible
doorknobs and hard-
ware
■Installing grab bars in
bathrooms ■Increasing
maneuverability in
bathrooms for
wheelchairs
■Installing sinks and
hand dryers within reach
■Creating handicapped
parking spaces
■Installing accessible
water fountains
■Installing ramps
■Having curb cuts,
sidewalks, and entrances
that are accessible
■Installing elevators
■Widening door
openings
Public accommodation
is not required if a
particular aid or service
would result in either
fundamental alteration
of the services offered or
the facility if the
accommodation would
impose an undue
burden. (See
Southeastern
Community College v.
Davis, 442 U.S. 397
(1979)). Under the U.S.
Supreme Court’s
interpretation, Congress
intended that undue
burden and hardship
must be determined on a
case-by-case basis.
Testing:
Section 309 of the
Americans with
Disabilities Act fills the
gap regarding testing
and examination not
defined by Section 504
of the Rehabilitation Act
of 1973 or Title II of the
ADA. Any educational
facility that receives
federal money or is a
public facility because it
is a function of the state
or local government as
defined under Title II of
the ADA is required to
make any examination
accessible to persons
with disabilities. This
requirement includes
physical access to the
testing facility, as well
as any modification of
the way the test is
administered to assist
the disabled.
Modifications may
include offering
extended time, written
instructions, or the
assistance of a reader.
Many licensing and
testing authorities are
not covered by Section
504 or Title II. In these
cases, a provision in the
ADA was included to
assure that persons with
disabilities are not
prohibited from or
disallowed in any
educational,
professional, or other
examination opportunity
because a test or course
is conducted in an
inaccessible location or
is offered without the
needed modifications to
assist the disabled
student. Modifications may include offering an
examination with the
assistance of a reader, in
a braille or large print
format, transcribers, or
the proper computer
equipment to help the
disabled person.
Examiners may require
proof of disability, but
requests for
documentation of the
disability must be
reasonable and must be
limited to support for the
modification or aid
requested. The student
or testing applicant may
be required to bear the
cost of providing such
documentation for
examination officials.
Appropriate
documentation would
include:
■Letter from physician
or psychiatrist or other
qualified individual
■Evidence of prior
diagnosis
■Evidence of prior
accommodation
Private and Religious
Schools:
The ADA covers private
elementary and
secondary schools as
places of public
accommodation; i.e., the
schools must be
physically accessible to
those with disabilities.
But these schools are not required to provide free
appropriate education or
develop an
individualized
educational program for
students with
disabilities. Any private
school that receives
federal grant monies or
any type of federal
assistance would then
fall under the
Department of
Education’s regulations
regarding construction
and alterations to the
private school’s
structures and buildings,
where it can be
conveniently and
economically
incorporated.
Postsecondary
Education:
Under Section 504,
colleges and universities
are not required to
identify students with
disabilities. They are
required to inform all
applicants of the
availability of auxiliary
aids, services, and
academic adjustments. It
is the student’s
responsibility to make
his or her condition
known and to seek out
assistance.
Individuals with
Disabilities Education
Act:
In addition to the
protections offered by
the ADA and Section
504, another statute, the
Individuals with
Disabilities Education
Act (IDEA), provides
additional protection to
those with disabilities in
the context of education.
The act was originally
passed by Congress in
1975 but has been
amended on several
occasions since that
time. The goals of IDEA
are as follows:
■It ensures the disabled
children are given a
“free appropriate public
education,” emphasizing
special education and
related services that
meet the specific needs
of each disabled child
■It ensures the
protection of the rights
of disabled children and
their parents
■It assists states, local
governments,
educational service
agencies, and federal
agencies to provide for
the education of disabled
children
■It assists states to
implement a statewide
system of early
intervention services for disabled infants and
toddlers; it ensures that
educators and parents
have the necessary tools
to improve educational
results for disabled
children
■It assesses and ensures
the effectiveness of
efforts to educate
disabled children
Unlike ADA and
Section 504, which are
nondiscrimination laws,
IDEA is instead a grant
program. It requires
states that accept federal
funds to provide free,
appropriate public
education to disabled
children. Although the
means by which IDEA
operates differs from the
ADA and Section 504,
each of these statutes
serve similar purposes
for the most part.
P UBLIC F ACILITY
A CCOMMODATIONS
Many people think that
the Americans with
Disabilities Act (ADA)
primarily covers
workplace
accommodations. The
only public
accommodations they
associate with ADA are
handicapped parking
spaces and Braille
numbers on elevator
buttons. In fact, the
ADA’s public facilities rules, as outlined in Title
III of the act, are far
more comprehensive
than that. All sorts of
buildings and businesses
fall under Title III:
restaurants, schools,
office buildings, banks,
doctors’ offices, and
movie theaters, to name
a few. Accommodation
can include anything
from adjusting store
shelves to constructing
special ramps and
entryways.
Some people mistakenly
believe that ADA
requires businesses to
make all sorts of
prohibitively expensive
changes or else face stiff
penalties. The truth is
that ADA is designed to
benefit the disabled, not
to punish business
owners. The key to
understanding ADA is
knowing what is and is
not required, as well as
what constitutes an
acceptable
accommodation.
The section of ADA that
deals with public
facilities is Title III.
Public accommodations
include any building or
outdoor space through
which any person can
enter, with or without a
fee. Essentially, that
means all buildings
except for “private”
clubs (any club that
requires members to
vote to admit an
individual) and religious
facilities. Among the
facilities covered as
listed by ADA are the
following:
Lodgings (hotels,
motels, inns)
Establishments
that serve food
and drink
(restaurants,
bars, taverns)
Establishments
that offer
entertainment
(theaters,
stadiums)
Places where
public gatherings
may be held
(auditoriums,
convention halls)
Sale or rental
establishments
(retail stores)
Service
establishments
(medical offices,
law offices,
funeral parlors)
Places of public
display or
collection
(museums,
galleries, public
gardens)
Social service
centers
(homeless
shelters, day care
centers)
Recreation/exerc
ise establishment
(golf courses,
gymnasiums) It is important to
understand not only
which facilities are
covered under ADA, but
also who is considered
disabled. Under ADA
guidelines, anyone who
possesses a physical or
mental impairment that
significantly limits at
least one major life
function—for example,
the ability to feed
oneself, the ability to
walk, or the ability to
breathe on one’s own.
Alcoholics and other
substance abusers are
also covered if they have
been shown to have a
history of such abuse.
A public
accommodation is
expected to follow three
basic guidelines under
Title III of ADA. First, it
cannot deny goods or
services to a disabled
person covered under
the legislation. Second,
it cannot satisfy its
commitment to the
legislation by offering
benefits that are separate
or unequal. Finally, it
must offer all services in
as integrated a setting as
possible.
This kind of wording
frightens some owners
of public facilities.
Retail store owners, for
example, sometimes fear
that Title III compliance
means having to make
expensive structural changes to their stores or
keep people on staff to
accommodate all
possible disabilities.
Would a small company
have to install an
elevator in its building?
Does a restaurant have
to make Braille menus
and sign-language
interpreters available?
In fact, ADA’s Title III
guidelines do offer a
certain degree of leeway
for facilities, but that
leeway is dependent on
a number of factors
including cost and a
facility’s special needs.
E NFORCING THE L AW
In the 25-year period
from 1976 to 2001, the
Access Board
investigated more than
3,300 complaints against
public facilities,
including post offices,
military facilities,
veterans hospitals
federal courthouses, and
prisons. In general, the
Board works with the
facility to find ways to
bring it into compliance.
One example is the
Holocaust Memorial
Museum in Washington,
D.C. A group of
children with varying
degrees of hearing
impairment were touring
the museum when the
fire alarm went off.
Because the students
actually thought the
alarms were part of the
exhibit, and because
they could not hear the
evacuation notices, there
was potential for serious
consequences. A
complaint was filed with
the Access Board, which
worked with the
museum to install new
alarms that offered a
more distinct and
distinguishable signal.
Another example is a
homeless shelter in
Phoenix, Arizona.
Although rest rooms in
the shelter had been
renovated twice using
federal funds, they were
still not ADA compliant.
The Access Board
worked successfully
with the shelter to
address the issue and
make the rest rooms
compliant.
Those who feel that a
public facility is in
violation of Title III may
file their complaints
with the U.S.
Department of Justice.
In cases of repeat
violations, the
Department has
authorization to bring
lawsuits against
offenders, although the
more desired outcome
would be correction of
the problem with the
help of groups such as
the Access Board. The
Department of Justice
web site that handles
ADA issues is http://www.usdoj.gov/cr
t/ada/adahom1.htm.
W ORK A CCOMMODATIONS
In the United States,
approximately 43
million people have
physical or mental
disabilities or
impairments that
substantially limit major
life activities. In an
effort to avoid
discrimination against
disabled people in the
workplace, Congress
enacted in July of 1990
the Americans with
Disabilities Act (ADA).
One way that the ADA
seeks to improve
employment
opportunities for
disabled people is by
requiring employers
under certain
circumstances to alter
the workplace to
accommodate
disabilities. These
alterations are known as
workplace
accommodations.
Just like individuals of
different races, colors,
religions, gender, or
national origin,
individuals with
physical or mental
disabilities historically
have faced
discrimination. Disabled
people have been
excluded from
mainstream society, segregated, provided
with inferior or unequal
services, and denied
benefits that non-
disabled people enjoy.
What is different about
the discrimination of
disabled people as
compared to other types
of discrimination is that
there is often a rational
basis for treating
disabled people
differently from able-
bodied people. Whereas
there is usually no
rational basis for
treating, for example, a
woman from South
Africa differently from a
woman from the United
States, there may be a
rational basis for treating
a woman who is blind
differently from a
woman with good
vision. The visually
impaired woman may
require the use of
Braille, for example.
Another difference in
disability discrimination
is its intent. Many types
of discrimination, such
as racial discrimination,
are rooted in hostility or
hatred toward people
who are different. But
discrimination against
disabled individuals
more often is rooted in
ignorance or apathy.
Some people view
disabilities with pity or
discomfort, leading to
behavior that may
patronize people with
disabilities. Other people
simply fail to consider
or understand the needs
of disabled people,
leading to benign
neglect or misguided
efforts to assist.
The U.S. Constitution
does little to protect
those with mental or
physical disabilities
from discrimination.
Courts historically have
not applied the
Constitution’s Equal
Protection Clause to
discrimination of
disabled persons with
the same level of
scrutiny as
discrimination of such
protected classes as race,
religion, and gender.
People with disabilities,
therefore, had little or no
recourse when their
disabilities unfairly
prevented them from
getting suitable jobs.
Only two-thirds of
employable disabled
persons in the United
States were employed in
the late 1980s, and many
of those employed were
not working to their full
capacity to earn given
their disabilities. By
1990, more than 8
million disabled
individuals were
unemployed and forced
to live on welfare and
other forms of
government assistance. Congress began enacting
federal laws in the 1960s
designed to protect
disabled people, but
these laws did not
outlaw disability
discrimination by
employers. Such
protections did not enter
the workplace until the
1990 passage of the
ADA.
The ADA prohibits
private and state and
local government
employers, as well as
employment agencies
and labor unions, from
discriminating on the
basis of disability. It
does not apply to private
employers with fewer
than 15 employees. The
ADA prohibits several
specific forms of
disability discrimination.
One example of an ADA
violation occurs when an
employer fails to make
reasonable
accommodations to
allow disabled workers
to work.
R EASONABLE
A CCOMMODATIONS
The ADA requires
employers to make
reasonable
accommodations to
qualified persons with
disabilities unless such
accommodations would
cause an undue hardship
to the employer. A
disabled person under the ADA is someone
who is substantially
limited in the ability to
perform a major life
activity or who has a
record of such an
impairment or who is
regarded as having such
an impairment. To be
qualified as a disabled
person under the ADA,
an individual must show
an ability to perform all
of the essential job
functions either with or
without a reasonable
accommodation. Courts
look at mitigating
measures in determining
whether an individual is
disabled. For example,
persons who need
eyeglasses may be
substantially limited in
the ability to read, which
is a major life activity,
unless they wear
eyeglasses. Because
eyeglasses mitigate their
bad vision and allow
them to read normally,
they are not considered
to disabled under the
ADA.
There are three general
types of reasonable
accommodations. The
first type modifies the
job application process
to enable qualified job
applicants with a
disability to be
considered for the job
they want. The second
type modifies the work
environment or the
manner in which the job
is performed to allow
disabled individuals to
perform the job’s
essential functions. The
third type modifies the
workplace to allow
disabled employees
equal benefits and
privileges as similarly
situated employees
without disabilities.
More specific types of
reasonable
accommodations may
include making an office
wheelchair accessible;
restructuring jobs;
providing part-time or
modified work
schedules; modifying or
purchasing special
furniture or equipment;
changing employment
policies; providing
readers or interpreters;
and reassigning disabled
individuals to vacant
positions. An employer
is not required to
eliminate an essential
job function or
fundamental duty of the
job to accommodate a
disabled person. An
employer is not required
to lower production
quotas or standards that
apply to all employees,
although an employer is
required to provide
reasonable
accommodations to help
a disabled individual
meet production quotas
or standards. An employer is not required
to provide disabled
employees with personal
use items that are
necessary both on and
off the job, for example,
hearing aids.
The ADA does not
require that reasonable
accommodations be
made when the
accommodations would
cause employers an
undue hardship. Undue
hardship means
significant difficulty or
expense when compared
with the employer’s
resources and
circumstances. The
employer’s financial
capabilities are one
factor in defining undue
hardship, but undue
hardship also occurs
when the reasonable
accommodation would
be unduly extensive or
disruptive or would
fundamentally alter the
nature or operation of
the business. Courts
determine on a case-by-
case basis whether a
reasonable
accommodation would
be an undue hardship for
the employer.
P ROCEDURE
Individuals who want a
reasonable
accommodation must
request it but need not
mention the ADA or the
phrase “reasonable accommodation.” It is
sufficient if employees
simply ask for an
accommodation for a
medical reason. Once a
request is made,
employers are obligated
to investigate the request
and determine if the
requesting employee is
qualified as a disabled
individual under the
ADA. If that
determination is
positive, then the
employer must begin an
interactive process with
that employee,
determining that
individual’s needs and
identifying the
accommodation that
should be made.
Sometimes this is an
easy process with both
sides agreeing on the
reasonable
accommodation. Other
times, the interactive
process can be
complicated and
contentious.
Sometimes, employers
do not know about or
understand the disability
enough to determine a
reasonable
accommodation. In these
cases, employers are
entitled to obtain
documentation, such as
medical records or a
letter from a doctor, to
learn about the
disability, its functional
limitations, and the sort
of accommodation that
needs to be made.
Alternatively, employers
may simply ask the
requesting employee
about the disability and
limitations. Unless the
disability is obvious,
that employee must
provide the employer
with sufficient
information about the
disability to help the
employer determine a
reasonable
accommodation.
As long as the
reasonable
accommodation is
effective in allowing the
disabled individuals to
perform their job
functions and receive the
same benefits as other,
non-disabled
individuals, then
employers have the right
to choose among
reasonable
accommodation options.
Employers may choose
options that are cheaper
or easier to provide, for
example. If employers
offer disabled
employees reasonable
accommodations that
employees do not want,
the employers may not
force the employees to
accept the
accommodations. If,
however, the employee’s
refusal of the reasonable
accommodation results
in the individual’s inability to perform the
essential functions of the
job, the employee may
be deemed unqualified
for the job. The
employer may then be
justified in terminating
the employee.
During the hiring
process, employers are
not permitted to ask
whether job applicants
require a reasonable
accommodation unless
an applicant’s disability
is obvious, such as an
applicant who uses a
wheelchair, or unless the
applicant voluntarily
informs the employer
about the disability. If
the employer offers the
applicant a job, it is with
the condition that the
applicant is able to
perform the essential job
functions either with or
without a reasonable
accommodation. Once
the applicant receives
the job offer, the
employer may inquire
about the necessity of
reasonable
accommodations.
The ADA also mandates
that employees with
disabilities be permitted
to enjoy the same
benefits and privileges
of employment as non-
disabled employees
enjoy. Therefore,
employers must provide
reasonable
accommodations to allow the disabled
worker to gain access to
such privileges as
workplace cafeterias or
lounges, gyms or health
clubs, training programs,
credit unions,
transportation, or any
other perk offered to
non-disabled employees.
A blind employee, for
example, would not be
able to read employment
related notices placed on
bulletin boards. In that
case, the employer
would have to provide a
reasonable
accommodation, such as
sending that employee
telephone messages.
T YPES OF R EASONABLE
A CCOMMODATIONS
An employer may
restructure or modify a
job as a reasonable
accommodation for an
employee with a
disability. Job
restructuring may
include reallocating job
functions or trading
certain job functions that
are difficult or
impossible for the
disabled worker with
other job functions of a
non-disabled worker. A
disabled secretary who
cannot climb stairs, for
example, may be able to
fulfill the essential
functions of the job but
cannot easily retrieve
files from the upstairs
storage room. In this
case, an appropriate
accommodation would
be to assign the disabled
worker additional filing
duties and require an
able-bodied co-worker
to actually retrieve the
files.
A disabled worker may
be entitled to a paid or
unpaid leave of absence
from the job as a
reasonable
accommodation for such
reasons as the worker’s
need for surgery or other
medical treatment, the
worker’s recovery from
illness related to the
disability, or the
worker’s education or
training related to the
disability. An employer
does not have to pay the
disabled worker during a
disability-related leave
of absence beyond the
employer’s own policy
regarding sick pay or
vacation pay. The
employer is required to
hold open the disabled
worker’s job during the
leave of absence, but the
employer may
demonstrate that holding
open the position for an
extended period would
constitute an undue
hardship. In the event of
undue hardship, the
employer can fill the
disabled worker’s
position with another
employee but then must try to identify an
equivalent position for
the disabled worker
when the leave of
absence ends.
Unless doing so would
cause an undue hardship
to the employer, the
employer must allow a
disabled worker the
option of a modified or
part-time work schedule
if required by the
disability. This may be
necessary for individuals
who need medical
treatment periodically.
Another type of job
modification involves
workplace policies. An
employer who prohibits
workers from eating or
drinking at their
workstations may amend
that policy for a worker
with a disability that
requires this worker to
eat or drink at specific
times of the day. An
employer who requires
employees to work at
the employer’s office
rather than at home may
alter the policy if a
disabled worker can
perform the essential job
functions from home but
cannot perform them at
the office.
An employer may claim
that undue hardship
prevents the provision of
reasonable
accommodations, but
undue hardship is not
easy to prove. The em- ployer must demonstrate
that the specific
reasonable
accommodation being
considered would cause
significant difficulty or
expense. The
determination of undue
hardship is made on a
case-by-case basis, and
courts consider such
factors as the type and
cost of the
accommodation, the
financial resources of
the employer, the
number of employees,
and the overall impact of
the accommodation on
the employer’s
operation. An employer
cannot claim undue
hardship resulting from
fears or prejudices about
an individual’s disability
or fears that an
accommodation would
result in a morale
problem with co-
workers. An employer
may, however,
demonstrate undue
hardship if an
accommodation would
unduly disrupt the work
of other employees.