12.04[1] Example 2: Alterations Clauses - Oppressive ApproachSection 3.01. Tenant shall not make or perform, or permit the making or
performance of, any alterations, installations, decorations, improvements,
additions or other physical changes in or about the Demised Premises (referred
to collectively a "Alterations", and singly as "Alterations") without Owner's
prior consent in each instance. Owner agrees not unreasonably to withhold or
delay its consent to any nonstructural Alterations proposed to be made by Tenant
to adapt the Demised Premises for Tenant's business purposes. Notwithstanding
the foregoing provisions of this Section or Owner's consent to any Alterations,
all Alterations shall be made and performed in conformity with and subject to
the following provisions:
1. All Alterations shall be made and performed at Tenant's sole cost
and expense and at such time and in such manner as Owner may, from time to time,
reasonably designate;
2. No Alteration shall adversely affect the structural integrity of
the Building;
3. Alterations shall be made only by contractors or mechanics
approved by Owner, such approval not unreasonably to be withheld
(notwithstanding the foregoing, all Alterations requiring mechanics in trades,
including, without limitation, asbestos removal, with respect to which Owner has
adopted or may hereafter adopt a list or lists of approved contractors shall be
made only by contractors selected by Tenant from such list or lists);
4. No Alteration shall affect any part of the Building other than
the Demised Premises or adversely affect any service required to be furnished by
Owner to Tenant or to any other tenant or occupant of the Building (including,
without limitation, the building-wide standard systems of the Building required
to provide elevator, heat, ventilation, air conditioning and electrical and
plumbing services in the Building including the hereinafter defined Building
HVAC System, which systems are sometimes referred to herein, collectively, as
the "Building Systems" and singly as a "Building System");
5. No Alteration shall reduce the value or utility of the Building
or any portion thereof;
6. No Alteration shall affect the Certificate of Occupancy for the
Building or the Demised Premises;
7. No Alteration shall affect the outside appearance of the Building
or the color or style of any venetian blinds (except that Tenant may remove any
venetian blinds provided that they are promptly replaced by Tenant with the same
blinds, or, if the same blinds are not then available, with blinds of
substantially the same type, material and color);
8. All business machines and mechanical equipment shall be placed
and maintained by Tenant in settings sufficient, in Owner's judgment, to absorb
and prevent vibration, noise and annoyance to other tenants or occupants of the Building;
9. Tenant shall submit to Owner detailed plans and specifications
stamped by Tenant's architect (including layout, architectural, mechanical and
structural drawings) for each proposed Alteration and shall not commence any
such Alterations without first obtaining Owner's approval of such plans and
specifications; with respect to such plans and specifications (i) Owner agrees
not to unreasonably withhold or delay its approval of such plans and
specifications provided that such plans and specifications are consistent with
the Alteration previously approved by Owner, such plans and specifications are
architecturally and engineeringly complete and comply with the requirements of
this Lease and any rules of the Building with respect thereto and (ii) Owner's
approval shall be deemed denied in the event that Owner fails to approve or
disapprove such Tenant's plans and specifications within thirty (30) days
following their submission by Tenant to Owner;10. Prior to the commencement of such proposed Alteration, Tenant
shall have procured and paid for and exhibited to Owner, so far as the same may
be required from time to time, all permits, approvals and authorizations of all
"Governmental Authorities" having or claiming jurisdiction;
11. Any Alterations shall, to the extent necessary, be coordinated
with any other work being performed by Owner or other tenants and occupants of
the Building so that such Alterations shall not interfere with or delay the
completion of any other work, and, to that end, Tenant and its contractors and
subcontractors shall use only the Demised Premises for the performance of
Tenant's work;
12. Tenant shall maintain continuous protection of any portion of
the Building and, if applicable, the sidewalk adjacent thereto so as to prevent
any damage to the Building and sidewalk as a result of any Alteration;
13. Any debris and rubbish created by or resulting from any
Alteration shall be removed and disposed of, at Tenant's cost and expense, as
frequently and in such manner as Owner may reasonably direct; in addition, upon
completion of any Alteration, any surplus materials and temporary structures and
barricades shall be promptly removed, at Tenant's cost and expense, and if at
any time Tenant shall neglect, refuse or fail to so remove any such debris,
rubbish, surplus materials, or temporary structures within two (2) days after
Owner's demand (which may, notwithstanding any provisions of this Lease to the
contrary, be orally made to Tenant), Owner, at its sole option, may remove the
same at Tenant's expense for which Owner shall be promptly reimbursed upon
Owner's demand;
14. Prior to the commencement of each proposed Alteration, Tenant
shall furnish to Owner duplicate original policies of workmen's compensation
insurance covering all persons to be employed in connection with such
Alteration, including those to be employed by all contractors and
subcontractors, and of comprehensive public liability insurance (including
property 37.06), the holder of any hereinafter defined "Mortgage", and any
lessor under any hereinafter defined "Mortgage", and any lessor under any
hereinafter defined "Superior Lease" shall be named as parties insured, which
policies shall be issued by companies, and shall be in form and amounts,
satisfactory to Owner and shall be maintained by Tenant until the completion of
such Alteration; unless otherwise directed or consented to by Owner, such
comprehensive public library insurance shall conform to the requirements of
Section 19.02(B);
15. All Alterations in or to the electrical facilities in or serving
the Demised Premises shall be subject to the provisions of Section 29.05;
16. All fireproof wood test reports, electrical and air conditioning
certificates, and all other permits, approvals and certificates required by any
"Governmental Authority" (defined in Section 6.0) shall be timely obtained by
Tenant and submitted to Owner;17. All Alterations, once commenced, shall be made promptly and in a
good and workmanlike manner;
18. Notwithstanding Owner's approval of plans and specifications for
any Alteration, all Alterations shall be made and performed in full compliance
with all applicable "Legal Requirements", and with all applicable rules, orders,
regulations and requirements of the New York Board of Fire Underwriters and the
New York Fire Insurance Rating Organization or any similar body;
19. All Alterations shall be made and performed in accordance with
the Building Rules and any rules and regulations of the Building for
Alterations, including any such rules with respect to asbestos;
20. All materials and equipment to be installed, incorporated or
located in the Demised Premises as a result of all Alterations shall be new and
first quality; no such materials or equipment shall be subject to any lien,
encumbrance, chattel mortgage or title retention or security agreement of any kind;
21. Upon completion of each Alteration, Tenant, at Tenant's expense,
shall obtain certificates of final approval of such Alteration required by any
"Governmental Authority" and shall furnish Owner with copies thereof, together
with the "as-built" plans and specifications for such Alterations; and, if
applicable, copies of all asbestos surveys and reports prepared by Tenant's
asbestos consultants or contractors in connection with, or arising out of, the
performance of such Alteration.
Before commencement of such Alteration, Tenant shall furnish to
Owner a performance bond or other security satisfactory to Owner in an amount at
least equal to one hundred ten (110%) percent of the estimated cost of such
Alteration guaranteeing the performance and payment thereof; no Alteration shall
be commenced unless any preceding Alteration shall have been fully paid for and
proof of such payment furnished to Owner. To the extent that the employees of
Owner or its agents examine any plans or specifications submitted by Tenant to
Owner in connection with any proposed Alteration, or to monitor the progress
thereof, Tenant shall pay to Owner, promptly upon Owner's demand, a reasonable
sum based upon the time incurred by such employees; however, if such examination
or monitoring is by an independent architect or engineer employed by Owner or
its agents, the Tenant shall pay to Owner, promptly upon Owner's demand, a sum
equal to any reasonable fees charged to Owner in connection therewith. Owner
reserves the right to disapprove the plans and specifications for any proposed
Alteration in part, to reserve approval of items shown thereon pending its
review and approval of other plans and specifications, and to condition its
approval upon Tenant making revisions to the plans and specifications or
supplying additional information. Any review or approval by Owner of any plans
and/or specifications or preparation of any plans by an architect or engineer
designated by Owner with respect to any Alteration is solely for Owner's
benefit, and without any representation or warranty whatsoever to Tenant or any
other person with respect to the adequacy, correctness or efficiency thereof or
otherwise.
Section 3.02. Nothing in this Lease shall be deemed or construed in any
way as constituting the consent or request of Owner, express or implied, by
inference or otherwise, to any contractor, subcontractor, laborer or
materialmen, for the performance of any labor or the furnishing of any material
for any specific Alteration to, or repair of, the Demised Premises, the
Building, or any part of either. Any mechanic's or other lien filed against the
Demised Premises or the Building or the Real Property for work claimed to have
been done for, or materials claimed to have been furnished to, Tenant or any
person claiming through or under Tenant or based upon any act or omission or
alleged act or omission of Tenant or any such person shall be discharged by
Tenant, at Tenant's sole cost and expense, within ten (10) days after the filing
of such lien.Section 3.03. Tenant shall not, at any time prior to or during the Demised
Term, directly or indirectly employ, or permit the employment of, any
contractor, mechanic or laborer in the Demised Premises, whether in connection
with any Alteration or otherwise, if such employment will (a) interfere with or
cause an conflict with other contractors, mechanics, or laborers engaged in the
construction, maintenance or operation of the Building by Owner, Tenant or
others or (b) interfere with the use or occupancy of the Building by the
occupants thereof. In the event of any such interference or conflict, Tenant,
upon demand of Owner, shall cause all contractors, mechanics or laborers causing
such interference or conflict to leave the Building immediately.
Section 3.04. (A) Tenant shall pay to Owner on demand and as additional
rent in connection with any Alteration a fee equal to ten (10%) percent of the
total cost of such Alteration (referred to herein as the "Alternative Fee").
There shall be excluded from such computation the actual cost of "Tenant's
Personal Property" (defined in Section 4.01), painting, carpeting, free-standing
cabinetry and telephone installation. In addition, Tenant shall pay any fee
charged by the lessor under any "Superior Lease" or the holder of any "Mortgage"
in connection with reviewing the plans and specifications of such Alterations or
inspecting the progress of completion of the same.
(B) Prior to making any Alteration, Tenant shall submit to Owner a
statement of Tenant's independent licensed architect, if employed, or
contractor, estimating the total cost of such Alteration and the estimated time
required to complete such Alteration. The Alteration Fee shall be calculated on
the basis of such estimate and shall be paid, without offset or deduction, in
equal monthly installments during the course of the performance of the
Alteration on the first day of each month thereof. Within ten (10) "Business
Days" after completion of the Alteration, Tenant shall pay to Owner the entire
balance of the Alteration Fee if not theretofore paid in full.
(C) (1) Upon completion of an Alteration, Tenant shall submit to
Owner a statement of Tenant's independent licensed architect, if employed, or
contractor, certifying the total cost of such Alteration. The Alteration Fee
shall be adjusted, if necessary, based on the certification. If the Alteration
Fee, as adjusted, shall be greater than the amount theretofore paid to Owner by
Tenant on account of such Fee, Tenant shall pay such deficiency simultaneously
with the delivery to Owner of the certification. If such Alteration Fee, as
adjusted, is less than the amount theretofore paid to Owner by Tenant on account
of such Fee, Owner, within ten (10) Business Days after Owner's receipt of the
certification, shall pay to Tenant the amount of such overpayment.
(2) If after receipt of the aforesaid certification Owner
shall dispute the statement certifying the total costs of such Alteration, Owner
shall have the right to employ an independent certified public accountant to
review Tenant's books and records relating to such Alteration. The determination
of such accountant shall be conclusively binding upon the parties, and if
necessary, the Alteration Fee shall be adjusted accordingly based upon such
determination. If such determination shall review that the Alteration Fee paid
on account of such Alteration shall have been understated by more than five (5%)
percent, then Tenant shall pay the fees of the accountant in connection with
such review. The payment to be made to Owner as a result of any such
understatement shall bear interest in accordance with the provisions of Section
19.04 from the date that the first installment of the Alteration Fee was due and
payable until the date any such amounts are paid to Owner. Any adjustment in the
Alteration Fee, together with interest thereon at a rate of two (2%) percent per
annum above the then "Prime Rate", as well as any payment of the fees of such
accountant, shall be paid by Tenant to Owner as additional rent within three (3)
Business Days after such accountant's determination.Section 3.05. Without in any way limiting the generality of the provisions
of Section 3.01, all Alterations shall be made and performed in full compliance
with (a) New York City Local Law by Owner for fire safety in the Building; (b)
all applicable laws, ordinances, statutes and regulations of all state, federal,
municipal and local governments, departments and commissions; and (c) all
provisions of the Americans With Disabilities Act and any successor law of like
import then in force and effect insofar as it relates to the Demised Premises,
including but not limited to, the performance of all Alterations, structural and
otherwise, foreseen and unforeseen, in order to so comply. No Alteration shall
affect all or any part of any Class E Fire Alarm and Communication system
installed in the Demised Premises, except that in connection with any such
Alteration Tenant may relocate certain components of such system, provided (i)
such relocation shall be performed in a manner first approved by Owner, (ii) the
new location of any such component shall be first approved by Owner, (iii) prior
to any such relocation Tenant shall submit to Owner detailed plans and
specifications therefor which shall be first approved by Owner and (iv) Owner
shall have the election of relocating such components either by itself or by its
contractors, in which event all expenses incurred by Owner shall be reimbursed
by Tenant upon demand of Owner, as additional rent.
Section 3.06. (A) Any dispute with respect to the reasonability of any
failure or refusal of Owner to grant its consent or approval to any request for
such consent or approval pursuant to the provisions of Section 3.01 with respect
to which request Owner has agreed, in such Section not unreasonably to withhold
such consent or approval, may be submitted to arbitration by either party, by
notice to the other, and, if so submitted, shall be finally determined by
arbitration in the City of New York in accordance with the rules and regulations
then obtaining of the American Arbitration Association or its successor. Any
determination pursuant to the foregoing provisions shall be final and binding
upon the parties, whether or not a judgment shall be entered in any court. In
making such determination, the arbitrators shall not subtract from, add to, or
otherwise modify any of the provisions of this Lease. Owner and Tenant may, at
their own expense, be represented by counsel and employ expert witness in any
such arbitration. If the determination of any such arbitrator under this Section
with respect to the reasonability of any failure or refusal of Owner to grant
its consent or approval to any request for such consent or approval pursuant to
the provisions of Section 3.01 shall be adverse to Owner, Owner shall be deemed
to have granted the requested consent or approval but that shall be Tenant's
sole remedy in such event and Owner shall not be liable to Tenant for a breach
of Owner's covenant not unreasonably to withhold such consent or approval.
(B) With respect to all Alterations, including, without limitation,
all repair work and improvements made by Tenant pursuant to the provisions of
this Lease, Owner shall have the right at all times to monitor the performance
of an Alteration for compliance with Building regulations and procedures for
Alterations, Legal Requirements, and "Building Rules" (as defined in Section
33.01). If Owner determines that any of such Building regulations and procedures
for Alterations, Legal Requirements, or Building Rules are not being strictly
complied with, and if such non-compliance is not corrected (i) Within five (5)
days of Owner's notice thereof to Tenant, or (ii) immediately in cases of
emergency or in cases where the safety of people or property is threatened, then
Owner may immediately require the cessation of all work being performed in or
around the Demised Premises until such time as Owner is reasonably satisfied
that the applicable Building regulations and procedures for Alterations, Legal
Requirements, and Rules and Regulations have been or will be observed. Owner's
monitoring of any work in or around the Demised Premises shall not be deemed an
acknowledgment by Owner of Tenant's compliance with any applicable Building
regulations and procedures for Alterations, Legal Requirements, or Building
rules and regulations with respect to Alterations, or a waiver by Owner of its
right to require strict compliance with such Building regulations and procedures
for Alterations, Legal Requirements, and Rules and Regulations, nor shall such
monitoring relieve Tenant from any liabilities relating to such work.As can be seen from this example of a very oppressive alterations clause,
very little can be done by the tenant without approval of the landlord. Approval
of the landlord can be fairly arbitrary or can be withheld for almost no reason
whatsoever. Whenever there are approvals granted, there are costs associated
therewith to be reimbursed by the tenant. Throughout the alteration articles,
any conceivable burden is placed on the tenant in the name of regulation under
this clause and exactments of fees, profits, overhead and general requirements
or conditions are heaped on liberally.
This is not a clause where a tenant can operate for more than three or
four years comfortably. Assuming the initial alterations can be installed with
the minimum of grief, any repairs, alterations or renovations that may happen
under a ten to twenty year lease would add a considerable number of dollars per
square foot to the overall costs of a form containing a paragraph such as this.