TABLE OF CONTENTS
PURPOSE ....................................................................................................................................... 1
BACKGROUND............................................................................................................................... 1
PARTNERING DEFINITION............................................................................................................ 1
BENEFITS ....................................................................................................................................... 1
2011 AZ TRANSPORTATION PARTNERTING EXCELLENCE AWARD CATEGORIES ............. 2
CONSTRUCTION ........................................................................................................................... 2
NON-CONSTRUCTION ................................................................................................................... 2
2011 ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENTS ............................................................................................. 2
AWARD PROGRAM GUIDELINES ................................................................................................ 3
AWARD PROCESS ........................................................................................................................ 3
APPLICATION DEADLINES AND SUBMITTAL INFORMATION ............................................................. 3
HOW WINNERS ARE SELECTED .................................................................................................... 4
JUDGES’ CRITERIA ...................................................................................................................... 5
APPLICATION FORM ..................................................................................................................... 6
PAYMENT & DEADLINE INFORMATION ...................................................................................... 7
2011 ARIZONA TRANSPORTATION
PARTNERING EXCELLENCE AWARD
Tangible deliverables of a formal Partnering
process may include a communications and
roles matrix, a charter (mission, goals and
guidelines), an issue resolution process and
agreements, action plans, evaluation
methods, meeting follow-up and reporting.
PURPOSE
The Arizona Transportation Partnering
Excellence Awards competition is designed
to recognize partnership teams that
demonstrate a high degree of achievement
through their practice of the Partnering
principles and application of the Partnering
processes related to the transportation
industry.
BENEFITS
In addition to being honored at the Annual
Partnering Event, winners will:
• Receive recognition from several industry
associations
• Be recognized as a leader in Partnering
excellence
• Receive feedback regarding strengths
and opportunities that will drive improved
effectiveness
• Have the opportunity to network with
peers in the industry committed to
Partnering excellence
• Know they have contributed to continuous
improvement of Partnering as a business
process
BACKGROUND
Partnering excellence has been recognized
by the Associated General Contractors
since 1993 and the National Partnership on
Highway Quality also recognizes excellent
partnerships bi-annually. In 2005 the
Partnering Advisory Committee formed a
partnership to develop the Arizona
Transportation Partnering Excellence Award
criteria, materials and selection process.
This committee is made up of Arizona
stakeholder groups who use and encourage
the use of Partnering.
A creative and innovative “edge” is critical to
business success. Collaborative teamwork
that achieves measurable results through
agreements and productive working
relationships is more important today than
ever before. Today, resources and time are
precious. Successful partnerships conserve
resources and allow for creative solutions.
Any team that applies for this prestigious
award will be assessed for their current
practices and relationships – an extremely
valuable learning opportunity!
Award and application booklet available at:
ACEC: www.acecaz.org
ADOT: www.azdot.gov
AGC: www.azagc.org
AMCA: www.amcaaz.com
APWA: www.apwa.net
FHWA: www.fhwa.dot.gov/azdiv
TUCA: www.tuca-az.org
PARTNERING DEFINITION
Partnering is defined as “a formal process of
collaborative teamwork to achieve
measurable results through agreements and
productive working relationships.”
Page 1
2011 AZ TRANSPORTATION PARTNERING EXCELLENCE AWARD CATEGORIES
The following categories of Partnerships must have utilized a formal Partnering process and be able
to show a relationship to transportation - the movement of people and goods within the State of
Arizona.
CONSTRUCTION
Roadway (Under $5M; $5M to $25M; Over $25M) – Your project included one or more
of the following: highways/state routes, freeways, roads and streets including
reconstruction and expansion or widening of existing facilities, bridges, interchanges,
overpasses, road tunnels.
Other Transportation Infrastructure (Under $5M; $5M to $25M; Over $25M) –
Your project included one or more of the following: airport, bus/transit, rest areas,
tunnels (other than roadway), ports of entry, rail, ITS, non-recreational multi-use paths
(part of an overall system), pedestrian bridges.
NON-CONSTRUCTION
Development/Design – Your project included one or more of the following: scoping
documents, environmental documents, design documents, plans completed to percent
stage required in contract.
General Partnerships – Multiple organizations using formal Partnering agreements to
achieve positive results, evidenced by one or two key measures related to a work
environment that supports the transportation industry. This typically includes public and
agency partnerships among and between DOTs, other local, state and federal agencies,
counties, tribes and possibly even non-governmental stakeholders, such as utilities or
private organizations. General Partnerships also are often among and between
members and work units of the same organization and can be internal or external.
Substantial completion will be evidenced by proof of completed goals and objectives.
Previous applications in the same category under the same Partnership cannot apply.
There may be multiple awards for each category.
2011 ELIGIBILITY REQUIREMENTS
•
•
•
•
The Partnership must be transportation related.
One application submittal per awards category.
Only one application per Partnership.
Construction Projects
o Substantially complete and ready for use by October 15, 2011.
o Previously submitted construction projects are not eligible.
o CM@R, Design Build and JOC are eligible under the Construction category only.
• Development/Design
o Documents, plans completed to percent stage required by the contract.
o Previously submitted design projects are only eligible as construction projects.
Page 2
•
General Partnerships
o Purpose, intent, goals and/or objectives must have been substantially met.
o Previously submitted General Partnerships are only eligible to reapply if purpose,
intent, goals, objectives and tasks have changed significantly.
o Subcommittees of a General Partnership are eligible to apply if all requirements are
met and if not submitted previously.
AWARD PROGRAM GUIDELINES
AWARD PROCESS
The Arizona Transportation Partnering Excellence Award process is led by a committee of
volunteers who role model excellence in the transportation industry. They oversee the award
process which includes the establishment of a high standard of Partnering performance and the
categories of projects eligible to receive the award.
Submittal requirements are clearly outlined every year. Judges are selected for their in-depth
expertise in the transportation industry and recognized leadership in building partnerships.
Judging criteria is established to support high levels of excellence over the life of the award.
Feedback to those applicants achieving the minimum standard to be considered for an award is
provided through both review of the written submittal and discussion among the experienced
Partnering judges. Feedback will be provided to the applicants by the end of the calendar year.
The award recipients are recognized each year at the annual Partnering Event sponsored by
Arizona Department of Transportation, Arizona Chapter of the Associated General Contractors,
and American Council of Engineering Companies of Arizona.
The steps of the process include:
1. Review submittals for eligibility and adherence to the guidelines
2. Judges’ review of written award submittals against the criteria
3. Selection of finalists for the award
4. Verification/clarification of recipient information and results
5. Judges final recommendation for award recipients
6. Award recipient notification
_________________________________________________________________________
APPLICATION DEADLINES AND SUBMITTAL INFORMATION
Applications to be sent to: Arizona Transportation Partnering Excellence Award Committee –
by October 31, 2011 before 5:00 p.m. MST – at:
The Associated Minority Contractors of America (AMCA) office at
5660 S. 32nd St. Suite 105, Phoenix, AZ 85040 | 877-619-0026
•
Notification to Award Recipients: February 1, 2012
•
For questions, contact: Carla Carter, 480-922-0043, ccarterinc@cox.net
Page 3
HOW WINNERS ARE SELECTED
Applicants are expected to complete the standard application form on pages 6-7. Responses
shall not only answer the questions asked, but shall also be presented in a format that includes
a total of 15 pages maximum (single-sided; if double-sided it will count as 2 pages) according to
the following submittal guidelines:
•
Table of Contents (not included in the 15 page count).
•
Application Form (not included in the 15 page count).
•
One page summary describing why the project should receive an Arizona Transportation
Partnering Excellence Award (not included in the 15 page count), immediately preceding
Judges’ Criteria. (This write up should be suitable for publication.)
•
Responses to all questions set forth in the Judges’ Criteria (maximum of 10 pages) in the
order the criteria are listed on page 5.
•
Attachments/Exhibits (maximum of 5 pages) which may include press clippings, related
special event material, photos, and a glossary of terms as needed.
•
Charter/Partnering Agreement attached – does not need to have the signature page if it is
a separate page (not included in the 15 page count).
•
Rating form/evaluation tool for the partnership (not included in the 15 page count).
Format for the submittal shall include:
•
Submission of all information in a three-ring binder or a folder that allows pages to be
easily removed.
•
No pictures or graphics allowed on the table of contents, application form or tabs.
•
Minimum font size of 12 pt Arial with one-inch margins.
•
One cover sheet can be used in front of the binder or as first page of submittal, but not
both (not included in 15 page count). Graphics and pictures allowed.
•
Tabs separating the criteria are encouraged (not included in 15 page count).
•
A total of one original and six copies shall be submitted by the deadline.
Arizona Transportation Partnering Excellence Award recipients will be selected based upon the
Judges' Criteria. Once the applications are reviewed for eligibility and adherence to the
guidelines, those meeting requirements will move forward to be examined against the criteria.
Those meeting the minimum standard for recognition will then be reviewed by the judges and
considered finalists for the award.
Judges will look carefully at the responses given against the criteria established and not the
sophistication of the package submitted. The judges will then determine which partnerships will
be recognized. If no applicants in any one category meet the minimum standards* set, no award
for that category will be bestowed in that year.
No award submittals will be returned.
* Minimum standards reflect a well-developed level of the Partnership across all categories of
the Judges’ Criteria. They also include measurable, positive results.
Page 4
JUDGES’ CRITERIA
A formal Judges Panel shall determine the recipients. Members of the panel represent:
• Government agencies
• Contractors
• Consultants
• At large
The Judges' Criteria include the following:
1. Charter/Mission of the Partnership (15 percent)
What is the purpose of your Charter / Partnering agreement? (Cite the specific mission and
goals of the partnership.) Include your charter.
2. Goals (20 percent)
How were the partnership goals developed?
• How were each of the goals of your Partnering agreement measured and evaluated?
• What were the results? (Cite results for each goal and how Partnering helped in its
achievement.)
3. Issue Resolution (15 percent)
What is your issues resolution procedure? Provide examples, if available.
What were the results/outcomes of the team having an established issue escalation
process?
• What issues were resolved by field/front line employees closest to the issues?
• How did the complexity of the issues addressed impact the success of the Partnership?
•
4. Teamwork (20 percent)
How did you develop relationships with stakeholders? How did you develop team member
relationships? Describe those relationships and how you maintained them.
• How did you inform, educate and/or engage the public or other stakeholders? What were
the results?
5. Value/Outcomes (30 percent)
How well did you meet the scope, schedule and budget?
• How can you demonstrate that your partnership added value for the stakeholders?
• How did your outcomes exceed expectations?
• What were your lessons learned and how will you use them to improve?
Page 5
2011 ARIZONA TRANSPORTATION PARTNERING EXCELLENCE AWARD
APPLICATION FORM (1 of 2)
CATEGORY
Note: See pages 2-3 for eligibility requirements. Partnerships must have utilized a formal
Partnering process and be able to show a relationship to transportation - the movement of
people and goods within the State of Arizona. There may be multiple awards in each category.
Check only one category below.
CONSTRUCTION CATEGORY
Roadway (Under $5 Million)
Roadway ($5 Million to $25 Million)
Roadway (Over $25 Million)
Other Transportation Infrastructure
(Under $5 Million)
Other Transportation Infrastructure
($5 Million to $25 Million)
Other Transportation Infrastructure
(Over $25 Million)
NON-CONSTRUCTION CATEGORIES
Development/Design
General Partnerships
Substantial completion will be evidenced by
proof of completed goals and objectives.
Note: Non-Construction projects do not have a size differentiation.
APPLICANT INFORMATION
Company Name/s (List all if joint venture or general partnership, and please assign one sponsor to
coordinate all organizations. Submitting partner must sign the entry form, verifying partnerships must
have utilized a formal Partnering process and be able to show a relationship to transportation - the
movement of people and goods within the State of Arizona.
Name/Organization
Phone
Page 6
Email
2011 ARIZONA TRANSPORTATION PARTNERING EXCELLENCE AWARD
APPLICATION FORM (2 of 2)
APPLICANT INFORMATION (continued)
Nomination Submitted by:
Signature of Submitter:
Title:
Date:
Company:
Address:
City:
State:
Telephone:
Zip:
Fax:
Email:
Partnership, Project Title:
Contact Name:
Contact Phone:
Email:
Owner:
Location:
Date Partnering Agreement Signed:
Substantial Completion Date:
PAYMENT & DEADLINE INFORMATION
Deadline: Must be received by October 31, 2011 – 5:00 p.m. MST. Late entries will not be
accepted.
Send application with fee to: Arizona Transportation Partnering Excellence Award Committee, c/o the
Associated Minority Contractors of America (AMCA) office at 5660 S. 32nd St. Suite 105,
Phoenix, AZ 85040 | 877-619-0026. Website address: www.amcaaz.com
Entry Fee Enclosed:
$300
Please make checks payable to: Arizona Transportation Partnering Excellence Award Committee.
All materials become the property of the AZ Transportation Partnering Excellence Award Committee and
may be used in education, marketing and promotion for the awards program.
IMPORTANT: Changes to AZ Transportation Partnering Excellence Award Program:
1. Speaker Presentation is no longer required. Best practices determined by the judges may be asked
to present at Roads & Streets in 2012.
2. Awards will be presented at Roads & Streets in 2012.
Page 7
Useful advice on getting your ‘Vacant Land Purchase Agreement 150344952homesconnectcom’ ready online
Are you fed up with the inconvenience of managing paperwork? Look no further than airSlate SignNow, the premier eSignature solution for individuals and businesses. Bid farewell to the laborious process of printing and scanning documents. With airSlate SignNow, you can effortlessly complete and sign documents online. Take advantage of the powerful tools included in this intuitive and cost-effective platform and transform your method of document handling. Whether you need to sign forms or gather eSignatures, airSlate SignNow manages everything effortlessly, needing only a few clicks.
Adhere to this detailed guide:
- Log into your account or initiate a free trial with our service.
- Click +Create to upload a document from your device, cloud storage, or our template collection.
- Open your ‘Vacant Land Purchase Agreement 150344952homesconnectcom’ in the editor.
- Click Me (Fill Out Now) to finalize the form from your end.
- Add and assign fillable fields for others (if required).
- Continue with the Send Invite settings to obtain eSignatures from others.
- Download, print your version, or convert it into a reusable template.
Do not worry if you need to collaborate with your team on your Vacant Land Purchase Agreement 150344952homesconnectcom or send it for notarization—our platform has everything you need to accomplish these tasks. Register with airSlate SignNow today and take your document management to greater levels!