Empower your Animal science business with pipeline deals for Animal science

How to create outlook signature

the honorable leader of the opposition mr speaker nine months ago torrey stafford's killer was behind bars and today she is in a healing lodge now tori's killer was convicted of the most heinous crimes imaginable something the public safety minister called bad practices torres family has called on the prime minister to use all the tools available to him to fix this situation today members will be voting on a motion that will do just that does the prime minister agree with the decision to transfer tori's killer to a healing lodge mr speaker our hearts go out to the family of tory of stafford for the loss they have endured the offender in question was moved from maximum security to medium security in 2014 under the conservatives she remains in medium security today as reports have shown the corrections and conditional release act does not permit politicians to make one-off decisions in regards to the placement of individual inmates however the minister has asked that the commissioner of correctional services review this decision to ensure that it was taken properly and in ance with long-standing policy of the opposition [Applause] mr speaker the prime minister stated on the nafta negotiations that he would be protecting supply management but he failed the prime minister made major concessions on access to our dairy market and canada accepted to cap our own dairy protein exports we know that the united states have been very generous to their producers with annual subsidies amounting to about 22 billion dollars will the prime minister can tell us which concessions he got from the americans in exchange for the concessions that he made on the backs of canadian producers the right honourable the prime minister mr speaker this is a deal that preserves and maintains supply management its future has not been jeopardized now in terms of market share we have promised producers that they will be fairly inadequately compensated changes to access to the market are similar to the changes that we made under the tpp that was celebrated by the conservatives supply management has been protected dairy farmers will be compensated and as usual the conservatives continue to play political games the honorable leader of the opposition difference the deal under the tpp and sia was to exchange for gains in terms of market access in other countries these concessions have nothing in return now the prime minister tries to compare these to other deals but under this agreement that he just signed the canadian government will be imposing tariffs on canadian exports now we know the united states has a wide variety of support and billions of dollars worth of subsidies for their dairy producers so in exchange for backing down on what donald trump wanted can the prime minister tell us exactly which measures the u.s has agreed to eliminate the right speaker i think most canadians understand that monday or that sunday night was a good moment for canadians we secured access to our most important trading partner in a time of uncertainty we demonstrated that our approach of standing up for canadians and staying firm in our principles was the right one and mr speaker the relationship with the united states goes beyond politics as it should and i want to give a specific shout out to the many conservatives from brad wall to scott mo to brian pallister uh to people like brian mulrooney kim campbell jean-charles rana ambrose james moore the honorable leader of the opposition oh mr speaker it's clear the prime minister needed all the help he could get when it comes to his position with donald trump and even after all that mr speaker he still had to back down on so many key areas he backed down on pharmaceuticals meaning that canadian patients and provincial health care system will have to pay billions more now can the prime minister tell us exactly how much canadian patients will have to pay after he's adopted donald trump's rules on prescription drug costs [Applause] mr speaker that conservatives can't help themselves but to play politics on big issues but we're staying focused on canadians and it's wonderful to hear the conservatives suddenly preoccupied with prescription drug costs because they've never wanted to do anything on that but we've made sure the canadians know that we are serious about moving forward with pharmacare we will move forward with lowering prescription drug costs for canadians and nothing in this deal prevents us from being able to do that for canadians of the opposition well mr speaker there is something in this deal that would make that program even more expensive he has just backed down giving donald trump policy preference over canadian pharmaceuticals meaning higher prices for patients now in return for backing down on pharmaceuticals on accepting a cap on otto's what has he got in return yesterday the the minister of foreign fair says that the most important gain from this agreement is retaining what we already had so specifically did the prime minister receive an end to tariffs on steel and aluminum for all his concessions mr speaker i guess we shouldn't in this house be surprised when the conservatives choose to play politics but i have to admit i am surprised on this one given that just last year stephen harper and the conservatives were imploring us to capitulate and accept any deal at any price indeed stephen harper's memo said quote it does not matter whether current american proposals are worse than what we have now well over and over the conservatives urged us to take harper's advice and surrender immediately that was not our approach we stood up for canadians and got a good deal the honorable member for him mr speaker it's funny to hear the prime minister speaking of political games because yesterday the minister of foreign affairs referred three times not just once to the elimination of chapter 11 of nafta and she referred to it as a great victory for her and her government except that it's the liberals themselves who were fighting to preserve a version of that provision at the negotiating table that would allow companies to directly launch proceedings against governments donald trump is the one who wanted to eliminate it we're happy to see chapter 11 disappearing but are the liberals so desperate that they now want to rewrite history the right honourable the prime minister mr speaker we are very pleased to see chapter 11 disappear because it cost over 320 million billion dollars to canadians over the years we know that it's important to protect the ability of a government to legislate on the environment to protect workers rights and yes we stood up to eliminate that chapter 11 and we're very pleased to see that canadians will no longer be subject to it the honorable minister for remus is trying so hard to find a positive angle to this deal with donald trump that they are willfully misleading the house on this yesterday the minister for foreign affairs and today the prime minister are bragging about the fact that the elimination of chapter 11 of nafta is a great victory for them and their government the problem is that they are the ones who fought to try to keep it donald trump was the one who tried to get rid of it of course mr speaker we're glad that chapter 11 is gone but i'll describe the prime minister that he now wants to rewrite history i have to remind the honourable member for muskegon scotland that we don't accuse someone of wealthy willfully misleading the house or deliberately misleading the house i can say someone misleads because that of course could be by accident but we can't say willfully so i'd ask him to withdraw and apologize for that i remember well i'm sorry mr speaker he is misleading the house thank you i'm going to give a member another chance to without equivocations to start over again and apologize sorry instead of willfully misleading the house i will claim that he is misleading the house the right honorable prime minister mr speaker chapter 11 uh has cost canadian companies hundreds of millions of dollars in cash sorry cost the canadian government hundreds of millions of dollars over the years which is why we are pleased that we signed an agreement uh that eliminates chapter 11. the isds provisions uh which we worked hard with uh people on the cptp on theta to diminish and even to eliminate is something that we have always stood against we believe that governments should have every right to protect the environment to protect labor standards and that's what we ensured with uh this the honourable member for our bcb james ku let me quote the federal court of appeal again canada's efforts fell well short of the mark set by the supreme court of canada when it came to consulting indigenous peoples on trans mountain how can the prime minister claim that he will consult again when he has repeatedly said in this house that this project will be built no matter what doesn't the prime minister realize that he's in fact totally abdicating on his constitutional duty to consult and accommodate indigenous peoples and obtain their consent [Music] mr speaker the court ruling on tmx actually gives us a blueprint to move forward in the right way we know that proper deep consultation with indigenous peoples is essential for moving forward on any projects they have to be moved forward in the right way that means working with indigenous peoples it means getting community consultations right it means working to ensure that the environmental science is top-notch that's what we recognize mr speaker that is what we will move forward with in a responsible way to get things done the right way mr speaker because that's what all canadians expect the honourable member for btb james none a you mr speaker the prime minister has to be consistent if he's willing to acknowledge those who have a right to say yes or no then he also has to acknowledge the right for that group to say no whether it's yes or no does the prime minister not acknowledge that consulting when the decision has already been made is not the same as consulting under the court's ruling the right honorable the prime minister mr speaker i'd like to thank the member opposite for the fact that yes there are those who say yes and there are those who say no in indigenous communities we are going to be working with them we are going to be working with them in keeping with the way the court ruled there is improvement that needs to be done to consultations and to a partnership with indigenous communities and we commit to doing that seriously in the way that the court ruled the honorable member for richmond athabasca mr speaker an eight-year-old child killer guilty of first-degree murder and rape was transferred to a healing lodge with no fence there is such little security that there have been eight escapes over the years from that healing lodge in our motion we asked for that decision to be reversed as the ontario government did itself will the prime minister vote in favor of our motion as all canadians throughout the country are calling on it to do the right honourable the prime minister mr speaker our hearts are with torrey stafford's family and for their loss the inmate was transferred from maximum security to medium security in 2014 under the conservative government she remains in medium security today as several articles have already said the correctional systems and the parole system does not allow politicians to make decisions about inmate placement the minister has called on the commissioner to ensure that that decision is compliant with long-standing policies the honorable member mr speaker here's what the father of the child said last week to the prime minister from father to father would you be able to kneel down before the tomb of your child knowing that not all was done i'm begging you to do what is fair and to correct this injustice and make sure that this killer is put back behind bars mr speaker the prime minister has the power to act will he vote yes or no to the motion that we tabled in this house the right honourable the prime minister like all canadians throughout the country our hearts are with rodney stafford the inmate was transferred from maximum security to medium security in 2014 under the conservative government she remains in medium security to this day the conservatives should know that the minister does not become involved in inmate placement decisions because that's exactly what the member for belgium as a minister has affirmed in the past the minister has called upon the commissioner to review these decisions but as the member for kamloos thompson caribou knows there has to be an independent process without any political interference speaker canadians continue to call on the prime minister to do the right thing to send terry lynn mcclintick the killer of eight-year-old tory stafford back to prison and while he and his public safety minister dither with this review and refused to review the transfer that didn't occur in 2014 it occurred just a few months ago mcclintic is enjoying this life in a healing lodge without a fence i asked the prime minister on behalf of tory's father and on behalf of canadians to do the right thing to vote yes on our motion today and order mcclintic back behind bars [Applause] mr speaker the conservatives continue to play a very dangerous and quietly quite frankly repulsive game of politicizing a tragedy and speaking for others that they have no business speaking for we can continue to state obviously that this is a situation in which a previous conservative government reclassified an offender from maximum security institution to a medium security institution they are current this individual is currently in a medium security facility but as stephen harper's former order i would ask the member for battle river crow foot and others not to interrupt when someone else has the floor each side gets their turn and we have to listen whether we like what we hear or not and that's kind of essential in democracy the honourable member for barry sound muskoka mr speaker the prime minister accuses the games but i remember being in the ontario legislature as an npp when the ontario legislature 18 years ago voted unanimously to ask the federal government to stop a transfer of a cop killer to club fed the minister of agriculture who was solicitor general at the time stood in this house and reversed the transfer why was that good enough 18 years ago about why is he playing political games now and saying he can he cannot do anything on behalf of tory's staffers right honorable prime minister speaker as has been demonstrated the minister does not intervene on case-by-case basis and that to if you want to talk about things said in the past let's talk about the conservative member from belgium levy who said in his capacity as public safety minister just a few years ago i do not control the security classification of individual prisoners or perhaps the conservatives will listen to ben perrin who was steve stephen harper's firmer lawyer who himself said i'm concerned with politicians being the ones who decide how any particular individual offender is treated honourable member for milton mr speaker i've been listening to the excuses that the prime minister continuously gives to this house and to the canadian public with respect to his unwillingness to transfer terry lynn mcclintock from a healing lodge with no fences and no barriers back to where she came from a grand valley institution with fences and bars mr speaker i understand that the government won't be voting in favor of our emotions today but i'm wondering does the prime minister know whether or not there's going to be some of his backbenchers who are going to see the light and know that this is a moral issue and that they should do the right thing mr speaker i would indeed suggest that this is a moral issue this is about the contrast between a party and a government that respects the rules that respects the independence of our judicial system that appreciates the professionalism of our correctional services and a party of ambulance chasing politicians who are quite frankly demonstrating a contempt for the principles of law and debate in this house that is [Music] inexcusable order the honourable member for milton order well mr speaker at least the prime minister can show some kind of emotion even though it's self-righteous indignation that we would actually question him [Applause] that convicted killers of children are in appropriate institutions both to protect the integrity of the system of the justice system but as well to protect the public and any visitors within that institution if he's blind to it get out of the way and let us go back to government and get this right honorable prime minister mr speaker it was under the conservatives that the decision was taken to reclassify from a maximum security to a medium security of course mr speaker we we point out that i'm sure they just followed the recommendations and the proper functioning of their public servants of the professionals in our corrections agency when that transfer happened all we are asking is that they continue to respect the system in place that we have asked be verified be followed upon to ensure that all the rules were appropriately followed today the liberal government decided to not appeal the court of appeals ruling on the trans mountain expansion and do you know why because the court is right despite their promise the liberals used the same promise that the conservatives did but they did not consult appropriately in the indigenous communities now the court is wrapping them on the knuckles and telling them to do their homework all over again how can they truly consult now when in any case the decision has already been made i mean it's like being saying well your call is important to us but no the right honorable the prime minister mr speaker we would like to thank the court for having clarified on the process that we should be following in order to improve our consultations with indigenous communities we take this seriously and we want to improve our nation to nation relationship with indigenous peoples and that's exactly what we're going to be doing we're going to sit down with them so that we can do more extensive consultations in order to make sure that when this project if this project goes ahead that we do it appropriately that's what people expect that's what canadians expect that's what the justice system expects in all indigenous communities now promising to finally meaningfully consult indigenous peoples on the trans mountain pipeline proposal no no seriously this time he really really means it but here's his problem he's already made up his mind about the project so asking indigenous peoples for their opinion but refusing to hear the words no is the very definition of paternalism so how about this why doesn't the prime minister go and sit with indigenous leaders so they can teach him what free prior informed consent actually means or does he only agree with indigenous rights and title when indigenous people agree with him the right honorable prime minister mr speaker i take this opportunity to highlight what the member opposite well knows that proper consultations with indigenous peoples are possible and lead to good outcomes for everyone and a great example is the lng canada announcement that highlighted how much you can work with indigenous peoples and i know the member must be very pleased because it will benefit people right across northern british columbia to have moved forward on this lng canada proposal uh that will help indigenous peoples will grow our economy we'll get our resources to markets other than the united states this is a good good day for canada and it happened because of proper consultation with indigenous people remember albert edmonton mr speaker for weeks the minister of public safety has tried to pass the buck over the outrageous decision to transfer child killer terry lynn mcclintock to a healing lodge but no matter how hard the minister tries to avoid taking responsibility but stops with him he has the authority to reverse the decision he has the authority to put mcclintock back where she belongs behind bars mr speaker once again the conservatives are showing they will not let the facts get in the way of a political opportunity and that mr speaker is a real challenge for them and for canadians watching let me set the facts straight as reports have shown the corrections and conditional release act does not permit politicians to make one-off decisions in the regards to the placement of individual inmates that mr speaker is the facts are the fact those mr speaker are the facts uh the conservatives yet again are playing politics for elgin middlesex london mr speaker let me give the prime minister the facts this was an eight-year-old girl who was tediously murdered she was murdered and these people were convicted of first-degree murder and sent to prison behind bars are you telling me that sending this convicted first-degree murder or i think she means is he let her correct that where may i start can i start from the beginning and i'll make it less personal so the bottom line the bottom line is from southwestern ontario we are angry as a parent as a member of parliament will this prime minister do what is right and put this convicted murder behind bars where she belongs mr speaker let me highlight that people not just from southwestern ontario but right across the country uh are upset and stand with the terry stafford's family uh on this terrible strategy people right across the country's hearts go out to the family mr speaker in 2014 the individual in question was reclassified from a maximum to a medium security uh facility uh that mr speaker are the facts the conservatives are playing politics in a particularly inappropriate way order member for chilliwack hope eagle creek excuse me mr speaker as a mother and a grandmother i can only imagine the pain and suffering that tori's family has experienced tori's father has been begging the prime minister to reverse the decision that has allowed terry lynn mcclintick to serve her time at a healing lodge in saskatchewan when will the prime minister listen to tory's father do the right thing reverse this decision and put torrey's killer back behind bars prime minister mr speaker our hearts go out to tori's father to her entire family on this terrible tragedy we understand the anguish and the questions they have and the uh the difficulties they have lived with over the past years mr speaker uh the corrections act does not permit a minister to weigh in directly on the classification of an individual prisoner the minister has asked the corrections uh services to look into what happened here to ensure that everything was done ing to proper procedures and to make recommendations if the procedures need to be changed honourable member for chilliwack hope mr speaker tory stafford's family doesn't want the prime minister's heartfelt sentiments they want him to take action they don't want the prime minister's excuses they want tori's killer back behind bars conservatives do not respect the decision to put this killer in a healing lodge without fences we want her back behind bars and so does tori's family why doesn't the prime minister use the authority he has take action today and put this killer behind bars [Applause] i would ask the conservative members to not make guesses about what tori's family wants and instead be honest about what it is they want they want to play politics with a heinous tragedy they want order members don't get to all talk at once one at a time as i was saying democracy requires it let's have a little respect for this institution the right honourable prime minister mr speaker the conservatives want to play politics with this issue the conservatives want to drag up this terrible murder and try and look at political gain on this they have been politicizing this for well over a week with all of the passion that they can muster and mr speaker they are debasing uh the nature of this house and the debate the honourable member for chile mr speaker the prime minister can boast about the u.s mexico canada agreement but there is no guarantee to eliminate the 10 percent surcharge in aluminum and 25 surcharge on steel you can't call that a success small businesses in quebec are vulnerable to fluctuating prices caused by this tax workers are worried does the government have a plan to settle this situation or are they just acting on a day-to-day basis as usual the right honorable prime minister small businesses entrepreneurs in quebec and canada wide are happy with our agreement with the united states with the united states and mexico but as i said to workers in a factory we will continue to protect them our tariffs will remain in place until a certain countervail is lifted we want to create the situations that will help the middle class and offer more opportunities for canadians and we will continue to defend our workers the usmca we learn that canada will finally eliminate chapter 11. canadians have been hit with millions of dollars in legal fees and payouts to private corporations and now thanks to the tireless work of new democrats labor and civil society it is gone canada has been the most sued country under isds and for years liberals have argued to keep this clause they argued to keep it in the cptpp which they're going to be ramming through this week and created a whole new investor court system in ceta where the liberals finally commit to no future isds in trade agreements mr speaker i know the member from essex knows well the people in windsor are very happy with this deal which secures canada's auto industry for the coming decades it demonstrates a real win for the canadian auto and auto parts suppliers industry but yes we also got rid of the investor state dispute resolution system which has cost the federal government more than 300 million dollars in penalties and legal fees i'm glad to hear the the member opposite support uh for the umsca uh we continue to work to defend people in windsor and right across the country the honourable member for vimy mr speaker next week canadian communities will celebrate citizenship week our government has made significant reforms to the citizenship act to ensure fairness while maintaining the integrity of our citizenship program which has been used for divisive purposes under the harper government can the prime minister reveal to the house what progress was made since our government changed the canadian citizenship program the right honourable prime minister i'd like to thank the member for the me for her dedication to new canadians since changes were made to the act more than 150 000 new canadians have joined our great canadian family that is 40 more than conservatives we have reduced waiting times from 24 months to 10 moods mr speaker during this week there will be 54 citizenship ceremonies that we will welcome 13 000 new canadians for us on this side of the house a canadian is a canadian i cannot imagine the honourable member for uh louisiana mr speaker i don't know if this agreement is uh really liked very much by people in steel and aluminum workers in this field we're talking about 20 000 jobs for uh aluminum plants can the prime minister tell us tell us if the tariffs on aluminum will be eliminated yes or no the right honourable prime minister mr speaker i visited aluminum workers in their plants and the government will be there for them our countermeasures will be in place until the unfair duty on them is lifted we have always tried to create conditions that will help the middle class and create more opportunities for canadians we will continue to work until this duty is lifted hey the honourable member for luisa logo well when they negotiated with the government they said this duty would be lifted in quebec alone in quebec alone 20 000 jobs in aluminum must i remind the prime minister that for ten years he's been the member for uh papino a quebec riding what is he going to do for the people in in this uh working in this area in quebec right honourable prime minister mr speaker it seems that you're on a anti-house mission because harper asked people to accept an no matter what he said that there were no differences between our and theirs but on this side of the house we are not capitulating we are perseverant and we have achieved a good uh agreement for canadians [Applause] this government would capitulate and he was absolutely right for the first time for the first time in the history of trade deals there are more tariffs after the conclusion of the deal than there was when the negotiations actually started my colleague asked when will the steel tariffs be removed now that the prime minister has backed down on pharmaceuticals and dairy and so much else so i ask again when will the steel tariffs be removed when [Applause] even though the conservatives in this house are continuing to play politics there are conservatives across the country who understood that standing together for the good of the country was important that's why conservative prime ministers like brian rooney or kim campbell uh premiers like brad wall and then scott moe and brian pallaster and others stood strongly on team canada to make sure we negotiated a good and right deal and why we were able to count on smart conservatives like ronna ambrose and james moore who stood with us understanding that relations with the united states is bigger than mere political points unfortunately not all conservatives says the prime minister who's been repeatedly misrepresenting the position of the conservative party on this negotiation from the very start but it is true conservatives many conservatives entered on a rescue mission to try and help the prime minister who was clearly floundering from the beginning but now we have the result he backed down on pharmaceuticals with higher drug prices for canadian seniors he backed down on dairy imposing canadian tariffs on canadian farmers why did he give up so much to get absolutely nothing that we didn't already [Applause] not have did we secure access to the united states for our middle class for our workers at a time of protectionism and uncertainty we got rid of the ratchet clause that infringed on our sovereignty by preventing our government from controlling our access to energy resources in the face of stiff opposition from the americans we kept chapter 19 in the dispute resolution system we got a cultural exemption that for now now will apply to digital platforms that's modernizing nafta we got rid of the isds that cost canadians so much the auto sector got a big win here in canada we have new enforceable environmental labor standards an honorable member for windsor tecumseh the failure of this liberal government to get the u.s to lift the steel and aluminum tariffs is hurting employers in my riding of windsor and essex county and the rest of southwestern ontario tool and mold manufacturers that rely on the specialized metals from the united states are fed up this government failed to secure an end to the punitive tariffs imposed by the u.s during the recent usmca negotiations and some of these businesses have already had to relocate to the united states so what is this government doing to keep jobs in canada now ministry mr speaker i know well having heard from many canadians in windsor and across southwestern ontario that they are very pleased that we have moved forward to secure the auto industry in southwestern ontario and in windsor we've protected good middle-class canadian jobs that will continue long into the future because we have secured the future of canada's auto industry with this usmca uh the fact is mr speaker i look forward to getting the support of the members from windsor because folks in windsor are really pleased that we've moved forward on protecting their jobs long into the future of a member for timmins james bay the speaker then after renegotiation the prime minister left steel and aluminum industries hanging in the wind but he's also abandoned small businesses across this country like northern boat sellers who are paying punishing import duties because of this prime minister's tit-for-tat war with donald trump so when he explained his logic to clint chartron of guiho sales and timmins who's being hammered by punitive penalties from this government why is government has squeezed 300 million dollars out of hard-working canadian businesses they've only paid eleven thousand dollars back when are these penalties going to end against canadian businesses mr speaker right across the country canadians have been clear that they want us to stand strong to be firm and to stand up for canadian jobs and that's exactly what we did but the members opposite don't have to take my word for it they can ask jerry dias of unifor who said this is a much better deal than the deal that was signed 24 years ago or perhaps they'll listen to hassan yusuf the president of the canadian labor congress who says the usmca gets it right on labor provisions including provisions to protect workers against employment discrimination on the basis of gender this deal is a good news story for middle-class canadians right across the the country leader of the opposition oh mr speaker we know that the prime minister backed down to donald trump on so many files in fact donald trump's senior economic adviser thanked them for backing down so graciously now after combing through the deal trying to find something to latch onto that he can claim as a positive he tells us it's investor state and the ratchet clause well this prime minister actually fought to get the investor state proposition into the tpp and the energy ratchet clause has never been used but steel and aluminum tariffs have been in effect and are hurting canadian jobs has he removed those tariffs mr speaker we will continue to stand up for canadians in the steel and aluminum sector uh but despite what the member opposite says we have got a an awful lot of wins on top of obviously securing our access to the us markets yes we've eliminated the ratchet clause uh that uh prevented our government from controlling access to our energy sources we got a cultural exemption that in the spirit of modernizing nafta will now apply to digital platforms yes we got rid of the isds platform we got a new auto deal for canadians that will secure our auto sector we have enforceable environmental labor standards which i know the concern the honorable member for yorkton melville mr speaker the lucille's husband morris served this country for 28 years he developed ptsd while serving his country dutifully and honorably he witnessed acts of violence and faced unimaginable horrors when the minister didn't respond to her letter lucille contacted my office saying how horrified she is that garnier who never served a day in his life is receiving veterans benefits due to the ptsd he developed while murdering the officer campbell can the prime minister explain to lucille while chris garnier is still receiving veterans benefits mr speaker our government places the highest priority on ensuring veterans and their families have the support and services they need when and where they need them the member knows well that i can't talk about the specifics of any individual case on the floor of this house but we have been firm in our commitment to enhancing access to veterans burn benefits unlike the conservatives who cut frontline staff closed offices and balanced the budget on the backs of veterans we continue to follow up on making sure that all the rules have been followed and we'll make modifications if necessary the honourable member mr speaker when a criminal is in receipt of benefits while serving his sentence canadians ask where is the justice in that when this criminal receives benefits reserved for our brave veterans veterans ask where is the justice in that once more can we do we know if christopher garnier is still in receipt of these benefits and when will the prime minister demand justice for canadians brave veterans and for the family of police officer katherine campbell the right honourable prime minister mr speaker all members in this house are their hearts go out to the campbell family perhaps we can change policy to make sure this never happens again we have increased the level of monitoring this policy we will continue to support veterans and their families while maintaining the integrity of the system new technologies have changed the way we access information shop leave socialize and work as a result of these changes our economy has transformed to become increasingly data driven these transformations have brought with them new and unchartered challenges surrounding the changing nature of work privacy information and consent can the prime minister tell this house how our government is helping to unlock the potential of data derivative economy while balancing canadians right to have their data and privacy protected honorable prime minister i thank the member from richmond hill for his question his first passion on this file we recognize the potential of a data-driven economy must be balanced against the right to canadians of canadians to have their data and privacy protected we have launched a national consultation on digital and data transformation to better understand how we can drive innovation and ensure canadians have trust and confidence in how their data is used we want to hear directly from canadians on how to grow the economy while protecting their data ensuring privacy and building trust the honorable member for calgary nose hill two years ago the supreme court overturned a bestiality conviction on a child molester because they ruled the law doesn't cover non-penetrative acts since the since then the prime minister hasn't included the simple definition change at any of his legislation while bestiality charges aren't being laid and more cases are being impacted why is the prime minister failing to protect humans and animals by refusing to pass updated bestiality legislation honorable prime minister mr speaker we take the integrity of our justice system very seriously and we'll continue to look for ways to improve it and to ensure that what canadians expect and the values that are shared amongst canadians are upheld and defended while at the same time we protect we uphold the law the honourable member mr speaker the planned demolition demolition of the palestinian village by the israeli government runs counter to international law the european parliament has even passed a resolution stating that this situation is and i quote that it would further compromise the viability of a two-state solution as well as any prospect for peace we're still waiting for our prime minister to react to say something why is he silent in the face of this serious problem for peace and human rights the right honourable prime minister mr speaker we are a steady ally of israel and we have spoken against the demolition of this village and we have communicated this to the israeli government were particularly concerned by the destruction of the school in this area but i think any unilateral action would compromise a two-state solution security uh [Music] [Applause] order i'm going to ask the member from davenport to try again and hopefully we'll be able to hear okay order mr speaker davenport residents have let me know that their data privacy their online information the threat of hacking is a priority and a worry for them our government takes our responsibility to protect the private information of citizens and the integrity of our critical infrastructure systems very seriously we committed 155 million for a new canadian center for cyber security establishing a unified government source of unique expertise and support can the prime minister update this house on the implementation of the canadian center for cyber security prime minister member from davenport for her question and her hard work on behalf of her citizens we know that good cyber security is critical to canada's competitiveness economic stability and long-term prosperity this week we launched the canadian center for cyber security we had promised in budget 2018. this new center will provide canadian citizens and businesses with a trusted place for cyber security advice canadians can rest assured that their government is prepared to meet the cyber security challenges of today and tomorrow honorable opposition house leader mr speaker just moments ago in manitoba the premier of manitoba my premier brian pallaster announced the manitoba is rejecting the carbon question to the tax minister is this now that another province has said no carbon tax for their province will this prime minister recognize that a pro carbon tax penalizes canadians penalizes farmers it penalizes industry it penalizes canadians it does nothing to help the environment will he do the right thing and do what brian palster did today and say no to the prime carbons mr speaker i continue to find it puzzling as to why conservatives insist on making pollution free we believe that polluters should pay and that's why we are putting a price on pollution we would prefer to work with provinces right across the country but if they are unwilling to make sure that polluters pay we will bring in federal measures to both collect a price on pollution and return that money to hard-working citizens right across the country honorable member for saanich gulf islands order thank you mr speaker today october 3rd is the neb deadline for comments on the list of issues in the redo of the kinder morgan trans mountain pipeline review now as an intervener in the initial failed and flawed process i've written the national energy board asking that they include the upstream and downstream climate impacts of the proposed pipeline just as they did in the case of the private sector's energy east it certainly seems fair they be held to the same standard doesn't the prime minister agree honorable prime minister mr speaker i thank my colleague for her question the review that the neb will undertake is related to the recent court decision on marine scoping direct and upstream impacts were reviewed under our interim principles announced in january 2016. as we've demonstrated we are moving forward with this project in the right way we are ensuring that we protect the environment and consult properly with indigenous peoples to grow the economy and protect the environment you need to do both at the same time that's exactly what we will do order i would like to draw to the attention of honorable members will come to it the attention of members the presidents and the gallery of the social sciences and humanities research council of canada 2018 impact award winners jean grande shane nielsen tanya lee jennifer llewellyn carla lipsig mummay you